Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
VB.2003.00024 • VG ZH VB.2003.00024 Generato dall'IA

Tendering Exclusion Due to Bid Modification and Recusation Issues

Numero d'incarto VB.2003.00024
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Zurigo (CH-ZH)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court case concerned the exclusion of a party from a public tendering process due to a subsequent modification of their bid, specifically the retraction of a reservation regarding a lump-sum price, which constituted a change in the offer that should have led to exclusion according to the procurement documents. The court reasoned that because the tender documents required a lump-sum offer, the awarding authority was within its discretion not to disclose potential construction costs, and the bidder's withdrawal of its reservation on the lump-sum price effectively altered the offer, justifying their exclusion from the procedure; additionally, the court addressed the issue of prior involvement and recusation of an executive member in the context of a procurement procedure before ultimately upholding the appeal against the exclusion decision.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

Submission | Ausschluss der Mitbeteiligten vom Verfahren aufgrund der nachträglichen Änderung ihres Angebots. Anwendbares Recht und Legitimation (E. 1). Gemäss Ausschreibungsunterlagen war eine Pauschale zu offerieren, weshalb es im Ermessen der Vergabebehörde lag, lediglich die verlangten Leistungen und nicht auch die mutmasslichen Baukosten bekannt zu geben (E. 2). Durch den Rückzug ihres Vorbehalts zum Pauschalpreis änderte die Mitbeteiligte ihr Angebot und hätte vom Verfahren ausgeschlossen werden müssen (E. 3). Bemerkungen zu Vorbefassung und Ausstand eines nebenamtlichen Exekutivmitglieds im Rahmen eines Vergabeverfahrens (E. 4). Gutheissung.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
esclusione dell'offerente bando di concorso per appalti pubblici potere di apprezzamento amministrativo procedimento antisovvenzioni contenzioso contrattuale rigetto provvisorio dell'opposizione

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 29 lit. I BV
This provision is cited in the context of the general principles governing administrative procedure, which underlies the court's decision regarding the exclusion of a co-party.
§ 26 lit. I a SubmV
This provision is cited as the legal basis for the court's ruling concerning the information disclosed in the tender documents and the discretion of the awarding authority.
§ 27 SubmV
This provision is cited as the legal basis regarding the mandatory nature of offers, relevant to the modification of the co-party's offer.
§ 28 SubmV
This provision is cited as the legal basis concerning the exclusion of offers that do not comply with the tendering requirements.
§ 5a lit. I a VRG
This provision is cited concerning the recusal (Ausstand) of an executive member, which was discussed in the reasoning and relates to the procedural conduct of the case.
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 29 lit. I BV

This provision is cited in the context of the general principles governing administrative procedure, which underlies the court's decision regarding the exclusion of a co-party.

§ 26 lit. I a SubmV

This provision is cited as the legal basis for the court's ruling concerning the information disclosed in the tender documents and the discretion of the awarding authority.

§ 27 SubmV

This provision is cited as the legal basis regarding the mandatory nature of offers, relevant to the modification of the co-party's offer.

§ 28 SubmV

This provision is cited as the legal basis concerning the exclusion of offers that do not comply with the tendering requirements.

§ 5a lit. I a VRG

This provision is cited concerning the recusal (Ausstand) of an executive member, which was discussed in the reasoning and relates to the procedural conduct of the case.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

Verwaltungsgericht des Kantons Zürich: VB.2003.00024

--- · --- · --- · --- · --- · [Standard Suche](/findinfo/xhtmltemplates/standard.htm) · [Erweiterte Suche](/findinfo/xhtmltemplates/advanced.htm) · [Hilfe](/findinfo/help/index.htm)

Druckansicht

--- · --- · --- · Geschäftsnummer: · VB.2003.00024 · Entscheidart und -datum: · Endentscheid vom 09.07.2003 · Spruchkörper: · 1. Abteilung/1. Kammer · Weiterzug: · Dieser Entscheid ist rechtskräftig. · Rechtsgebiet: · Submissionsrecht · Betreff: · Submission · Ausschluss der Mitbeteiligten vom Verfahren aufgrund der nachträglichen Änderung ihres Angebots. Anwendbares Recht und Legitimation (E. 1). Gemäss Ausschreibungsunterlagen war eine Pauschale zu offerieren, weshalb es im Ermessen der Vergabebehörde lag, lediglich die verlangten Leistungen und nicht auch die mutmasslichen Baukosten bekannt zu geben (E. 2).

Durch den Rückzug ihres Vorbehalts zum Pauschalpreis änderte die Mitbeteiligte ihr Angebot und hätte vom Verfahren ausgeschlossen werden müssen (E. 3). Bemerkungen zu Vorbefassung und Ausstand eines nebenamtlichen Exekutivmitglieds im Rahmen eines Vergabeverfahrens (E. 4). Gutheissung. · --- · Stichworte: · ÄNDERUNG AUSSCHLUSS AUSSCHREIBUNGSUNTERLAGEN AUSSTAND BAUKOSTEN BEHÖRDENMITGLIED ERLÄUTERUNGEN LEISTUNGSUMFANG SUBMISSIONSRECHT VORBEFASSUNG · Rechtsnormen: · Art. 29 lit. I BV § 26 lit. I d SubmV § 27 SubmV § 28 SubmV § 5a lit. I a VRG · Publikationen:

· RB 2003 Nr. 1 S. 43 · Gewichtung: (1 von hoher / 5 von geringer Bedeutung) · Gewichtung: 2