Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
VB.2001.00406 • VG ZH VB.2001.00406 Generato dall'IA

Challenge to Selective Tendering Award Based on Evaluation Criteria Flaws

Numero d'incarto VB.2001.00406
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Zurigo (CH-ZH)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party challenged the award decision in a selective tendering process, arguing that the evaluation of the criteria "experience" and "references" based solely on prequalification documents constituted a significant procedural defect, and that the evaluation of the "price" criterion did not properly account for its weighting. The court reasoned that relying on prequalification documents alone for evaluating experience and references did not constitute a material procedural flaw in this instance, but confirmed that the assessment of the price criterion must duly reflect its assigned weight in the overall evaluation scheme.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

Submission | Beurteilung von Offerten anhand der Zuschlagskriterien im selektiven Vergabeverfahren Die Beurteilung der Kriterien "Erfahrung" und "Referenzen", die allein auf im Rahmen der Präqualifikation eingereichten Unterlagen beruht, stellt in casu keinen wesentlichen Verfahrensmangel dar (E. 3). Die Bewertung des Zuschlagskriteriums "Preis" hat dessen Gewichtung Rechnung zu tragen (E. 4b).

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
criteri di aggiudicazione procedura selettiva vizio di procedura valutazione delle offerte aggiudicazione di appalto pubblico esame di merito

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 16 lit. II IVöB
This provision is cited in the case summary, implying it was a substantive rule used in the decision regarding the awarding of the contract.
§ 31 lit. I SubmV
This provision is cited in the case summary, implying it was a substantive rule used in the decision regarding the awarding of the contract.
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 16 lit. II IVöB

This provision is cited in the case summary, implying it was a substantive rule used in the decision regarding the awarding of the contract.

§ 31 lit. I SubmV

This provision is cited in the case summary, implying it was a substantive rule used in the decision regarding the awarding of the contract.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

Verwaltungsgericht des Kantons Zürich: VB.2001.00406

--- · --- · --- · --- · --- · [Standard Suche](/findinfo/xhtmltemplates/standard.htm) · [Erweiterte Suche](/findinfo/xhtmltemplates/advanced.htm) · [Hilfe](/findinfo/help/index.htm)

Druckansicht

--- · --- · --- · Geschäftsnummer: · VB.2001.00406 · Entscheidart und -datum: · Endentscheid vom 20.08.2002 · Spruchkörper: · 1. Abteilung/1. Kammer · Weiterzug: · Dieser Entscheid ist rechtskräftig. · Rechtsgebiet: · Submissionsrecht · Betreff: · Submission · Beurteilung von Offerten anhand der Zuschlagskriterien im selektiven Vergabeverfahren Die Beurteilung der Kriterien "Erfahrung" und "Referenzen", die allein auf im Rahmen der Präqualifikation eingereichten Unterlagen beruht, stellt in casu keinen wesentlichen Verfahrensmangel dar (E. 3). Die Bewertung des Zuschlagskriteriums "Preis" hat dessen Gewichtung Rechnung zu tragen (E. 4b). · --- · Stichworte: · BEWERTUNGSMETHODE EIGNUNG ERFAHRUNG PREIS REFERENZ SUBMISSIONSRECHT ZUSCHLAGSKRITERIEN · Rechtsnormen: · Art. 16 lit. II IVöB § 31 lit. I SubmV · Publikationen: · - keine - · Gewichtung: (1 von hoher / 5 von geringer Bedeutung) · Gewichtung: 3