Retroactive Application of Arbitration Clauses in Successive Agreements
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellate court reviewed a case concerning the validity of arbitration clauses contained within successive versions of an agreement, specifically focusing on whether the later agreement's clause applied to a dispute arising under the earlier one where the later agreement did not explicitly state its retroactive effect. The court reasoned that arbitration clauses are generally interpreted to cover disputes arising under the contract they are contained within unless the language clearly indicates an intent to apply retroactively to prior agreements, and since the subsequent agreement lacked clear language mandating retroactivity to disputes arising under the prior, unmodified agreement, the earlier agreement's dispute resolution provision governed the matter.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Retroactive Application of Arbitration Clauses in Successive Agreements: The court reasoned that arbitration clauses are generally interpreted to cover disputes arising under the contract they are contained within unless the language clearly indicates an intent to apply retroactively to prior agreements, and since the subsequent agreement lacked clear language mandating retroactivity to disputes arising under the prior, unmodified agreement, the earlier agreement's dispute resolution provision governed the matter.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispositive explicitly orders the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
&'()*&+,,- .&/*0&+,,-
.
. " . " "
12 34 $ +- 5 +,,-
67777777777 7777777777 ! " %% #$!%%&$'!%''(
$ 67777777777 ! " ' ) #$!%%&'$'!%''(
!
8 . ... ".9 " %''! !' %$4% %!%'* +!,--../0012 )
9: 9"" ; . !. 334! .56//7
!" #$%
80968
8.
7( :+!%7-'0//,7; 3* % '*% '; '!
'7>>6(
0( @ 3'44 - % %''!'4 % :+! $'!$ '* % '; '! %$ !+ '!'$%<' %<''&' 3 % $A % ! '+ ! ! ' '* ! % ' $% A(
-( :+!%%'< !%<%$4''!'47?:'0//,(
,( #'! !'$ '*%$ '%%$! ' $$! '<!B
!!' % !' C!$ 7? :' 0//, ; % D%!' !'!!' $!'<B,0E.,>4 (7/F
!!' % !' $ <! '+ < '!$ C! :&# 7? :' 0//,B76E>,?4 (F
!!'% !'$%! '+B05E>/04 (7/G,0E.,>4 (7/8 76E>,?4 (H
!!' % !' C!$ 7? :' 0//, ; % ' % ' $<I<''%#! '! ' B7>E>654 (5/(
6( @ *%'4 !' '*%$%$! '$!!% !!'%'* +J< D%!'!'!!'$!'<J '%' $<I<''! '! ' J-E,?0
4 (?6(<'!$J%$! ' A8$A!%$ $%# % <'8' ' %.!%0.!* 0//,(
97-5.90//, 8-968
.
7( E !( 06 % ' 4$%$ '* + % $<I 4'<'' <'<!!'<'%'!$%7?%$* 7>>-GDH ! $<'+ 7 :<' 0/// ;+ $% %%'< ( & :'!!%# % !!'% !'J !+ G !(700! 70- % '<'8 H:+%'%%'< $!!%E !(?-( 7%'4$%$ $<I 4'%06:'7>.0GH'!J ;< '*!% '%'7 K!0//-%'! ;&E44' '$!$! 'G !(7,0 HA$! %E44' !+ *%$% $ !'!'%$! '$ :+%%'< .
0( @E !(00 DG<! <'+ %'7 :<' 0///H %%'< !!'% !'&'% ! '+! !+$ 4 $!A !(70070-7,7!7,0 F !(-J6DE'&! +'!!J! 4$ G(7H( 3&:'! !!'% !'J !+ %J%'44$ ! !!'% !'+!$ % <' % '* + A'!! $<!! ! % %'< ! !!' % !' +!$ % <' % '* + A'!! $<!!!%'% '+G4( !(0,DH( :!J !!'% !'!JE<' %'* +A'!! !%'% '+'!$ C!%!%%'< G D 70.0-/F D70>,,,H(
-( #; :+ % '; '! %$ !+ '!'$ % <' %<''!'!$ 3%$A% ! '+(%! !'! ! %# ! % '+ J <' , ' 7>>6 ! %#! !7?:'0//,%!J&:+!%%'< !%<A$!' (
@';%%' !!'&'%! '+ "'
A8$!!%7-#,674 (/6G05E>/04 (7/B0H!8'%'!J % ' % >E>?. 4 ( -/ G7>E>65 4 (5/B 0H % ! &#' !'! J
4 (?6(
,( 4 $! J : ' % %' : %$! '! !+ :&E ! % ! 4 ! % !!' % !' % %
97-5.90//, 8,968
:'! %'< $ *$$4''' % !! !!' % '! J % '!$ C! !' !! % 8'( '!$ C! ! $ !A '' $+ E !( 70 % E % $<I 4' <'' <'<! ! '<'%'!$ % 7. < ' 7>., G 0H !A $+!' ' '8' ! $ ' G D *'$ -59/0 % 7. :'! 0//-H
6( $! L $% $!!+ !'!G !(?-(0! .>)(7%' $% %''! !'<%70!* 7>.6H(
MMM
97-5.90//, 86968
.8 " . " . " "
$
<3= > ? ;% ')+ "@A
7( <'! D%!' !'!!' $!'< J ! 4$ % ! % '*
4 (?6 J $<I <'' %#! ' ! ' 4< %
0( <'! %'! D%!' J < % !! % '!$ C! !' %%'%$ !%;7.:'0//,F
-( #I%!!&%*'(
,( '!& $% !+ !'!(
6( 4 !' % &E <! 4 ! $! C! % %$' % -/ : %; !'4'!' ' %$ % $ '* 4$%$ % @3O'P 34&' 5 5//, ! ' A' ( %$' ! C! +$( $' %'! B H '%'& A!! & %$'' ! %$' *!' ' ! % %$''!!&$F*HA &!'4'!'<' %% !! ! %$''FH ! '+! % $!!(@'$' !'! ! ' $$! $$ $ !! H *H ! H '8% '*4$%$ % ! !'; &E' %< %$ ' <*($' % !' I % < &' ! :'! '' & %$'' !!&$ ! E< % &$!$A$%'$ !G !(7-07/5!7/.H(
+ 44'; B $'%!B QR 1 "I "
'4 % $! C!!!'4'$A !'''&#J#44'4$%$ % ' + 44
97-5.90//,