Lien Survival Post-Debt Satisfaction and Conveyance
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant challenged the finality of a judgment regarding the validity of a lien on real property, asserting that the trial court erred by finding the lien was not extinguished upon the subsequent conveyance of the property, arguing that the lien was inherently tied to the specific debt which was satisfied by a separate transaction. The appellate court affirmed the lower court's ruling, reasoning that the lien was a separate interest in the property that survived the debt satisfaction because the parties explicitly preserved the lien's priority and continuation in a settlement agreement and deed, thus it was not automatically extinguished by the payment of the underlying debt.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Lien Survival Post-Debt Satisfaction and Conveyance: The appellate court affirmed the lower court's ruling, reasoning that the lien was a separate interest in the property that survived the debt satisfaction because the parties explicitly preserved the lien's priority and continuation in a settlement agreement and deed, thus it was not automatically extinguished by the payment of the underlying debt.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final dispositive orders regarding the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
!"#$!
%&!$'()))))))))) !!""#$%"
"
'**+,-,,.*'
&'()*&
,
). /%"#"0 #"# $!"# .11111111112#&/3 # " " 4 55 6 7%" / 7 7%" .
5#7"0 #0% 7%" "/%$#7 $ " "##/85"#$9#"7:88#'-.
'. # #"#8"# 7:85#$5#: # #%"88##"7:8%" 2#&/3"88##"4 ) ;%# '<$ 8"#5# )= 8 '-. :" >7?# 76# 7 :8 "5#". 7 " #> "0; "# @"#># $8## " "8 "5#" 8 #/ #> 0. " # " "$ # " "#%# 9# #""A# "%# 7# # %# B.
%"# ># 8# # #"" " 5: 2C DE( 3 " F G ( ( C ! 3 " F (H CHG(C GG 3" 4 #3 ?# " #" > #" " #8#> " 9 #"# #" 6 > 0# "%6 # $ : #" 8#:# 0 #"7:8B.
<. 7%# #<8#'-.
7" &# "8" # # : "# "# 2"5"87 # "# 97"0#45# #"7 # $"87;"# "888 #6. # 8 : # 76# ;###8 5# %# 9 # "; 7#6 #"" #05"88 #> 9@/ 8 "0 "# > 7%" # % 8 "## ".
" " #0 7%"# 6# #8 #" #%$ # # #$95#7"$>7%#'-"# ;" %# @ "# $ "8### 9 8I8 9 /%$%# " #5 #58#/. 9 ;"# J #67 #$## GF7"8/ # ##> " .
+. " %$"88##"# #0:# : "##% 3
('+,+('- &<()*&
&"#K"6# #";###''"%80)L+)2& '*-4
&"#"#%#)*%#)L=M2 N <*-4
&"#55"8 #/#%#'+8'2G"NC'M'4
" $ # %# #5"8 >7# "%# #08 #":8#" ( " $# #")LLL "'+@"#:# $>"88##"8#.
-. %@$7" # #0: : 6:#% 3
& "% #" ), 80 )L== " "8 ;### 7: #"##"8 #/#%# "88#2 NC*.'M'.))4
&"#5<" "0'<5#"$##"$ 5"8 #" 5 #8"#<" "0'<2GNC'').<*)4
& 0# # #"C 55(C@ O
# ># %# @"## 8# 7# #" '+ ( " #"# G$# #:.
,. 7###>@$# 8#"#.
M. # 0#:%")) )=8#'-.
=. #M;#'-$"88##""88#># ":8.%# "0 " #% 3%# 2"55## '43 <$-F%")3<F%"'3+F8"J%" " ""6#3 +$ "# " )= "# . C" 7 # <* # ' /68 7# #" "# "5#" 7%" - ;# '' 2 %N ,)*.*)4$7:85# ## " "# 6" #9'*.7J "0 8"J>#$# %# @".
##" ##># %"# " "% . 5#$ " #"" #% # ".
L. )- ;# '- 7 " " #" " #%. C" "88##"$9 "#"$6" :"$"%# "$ " # ## > 0/8 #>. "# 7 #0:# >#"## 88"# >#" #6;"# 7#%"> .
C"# $" $" " ##>> 70 : "# # "0#$"7 # # >7# #6 " "8### G$ #>7#
('+,+('- &+()*&
" "#>;"# " 88.8I8$">#%# # 9 #" #8"# 7 "# "J8 9 7 $ # 55## 8 #"7 #)=) $"88##"7 : 8 #/.
)*. + ;# '-$ 8# # "8# ; 0 2#& /3 "8# 4$ K # "88##" " K#5"8 "# #" "8# " K:8 5# 6. :">$%@ #%"8 # $# # 6# #8 K > K:8 " "# #" #"@0 "5"& 8 : :#6 6. 68 "# > "> K:8 # @K"0/8># 0# ""8 8#/#6#5# #%$# # "#":# "#0## K%.
#%# # ">"88##"9"6#"%% # %# 5#""#0## 9780# J @""#/#"7:8"%"#.
)). =;# '-$# # ; "" ##" M;#'-." ##8 97 #"7:8# 9 >7#"# "#9 97%# .
## 5# >K#%# $5P" " 8 # # #;& #5#0$ 8 "#0 9 " #88 > "8##" "88##" K%# "6. # #" # K # "0 >K# # : #" # 9 K; > # :8" 97805"8 #";##> #%#/.CKJ ;#5 " 8 #/$#:">5# 7%"#"8#8 :# # " # #5K%#"6% #0.68 #8 >7# #" #"# %# 0# #$"# # %# #0"#"8 $5"G$5#6 "#. 5#$ 0 # # #"$ # 7 # "#0 "886.
)'. "# ), 80'-$"88##"" 6#5 %" .
C7# # %#>7%# 8 9#"# #" : #$7"0#6 #" "88##""%# #%# 7 9 " : >#"# "% % # #" ". "88##" 7%# > 7"0#6 #" 8 9 #"# #" # : 8 "%" #"".
##$7/$#; #5## 8 :# >7# 55## > # ##6 7#6 #" " :
('+,+('- &-()*&
"# ."%# :#> >7 #"" &#$ "%0 55## 8 # %6 "# # >7# 7 # # 76# " ;"# . $ @"#: # %#800 ; #5## $:8#7" # #"""#"%0## # 5#0. " $# # 5# 8 "#0"8865" 8 7".
7:8 "# " %# # > 70 : 7%# 7#8 6 #5 7# #" " %#$ > 7 # " 0# #$ >7 "> # 7%# 0# ;#.
"8 7808 $"88##"" ; ".
,*
). ; 8 # % ;## #" "8 $ " %02 .-, "#K"6# #";###''"%80)L+)& & '*-F .,<.)# ."#"8## #%)' 80)L=-& & -)*F .<)#) %4.
'. % K # <) # ' %$ " I 5"8 " 8" #5K#6# "K0# #." "/%#6#59K" ##" >$ 8# # %#" #" #"# #" 6 8# 8"# K:8.
<. K #<' %%"# >K:85# 6 0#% "88##"K:8 #%"# %"K"6# #""88#& #" 8"# K:8.K #')#' %"9"88#& #""8 5#:8"# K:8.
);%#'<$ "88##"" # #%6 " 8& 8 8"# K:85#>78"#5#)=8'-.K6# K:8"5#">#K"#>"0; "#& @"#># $8## " "8 "5#"& . # " " #%# 9 # #" "A # "%# K## %# .
# #% " # "%6 " # "#% 8# # >#" #"> #""#8#>"9 #"# #" 6 > 0# "%6 8 #"$ : #" 8#:# 0 #"K:8.
('+,+('- &,()*&
K/$#K6# 8##" #"> #""9K:& 8<8#'-#8#># "9 9G$ "> "&8#"#:# .
+. C" 7%# 7 "# # #8$ # # # "; 7#6 #" " 5## #5 " " #" :@ #% ; .# %# 68 @"#:$ 7"868 %9 55 .
@"#>8 $# %# @"#:76#" ;"# $" "# "# # ;" 8"8 5# "# . #>8 $""88##"$# %# ##6""; 7#6& #" " : "# :#> >7 #" " &#$"%0$ # 55# "%6"# " # . 8 ># ; #5## "#" # 7 8 ?#"#8 B$ #597;"# >#8 # > #5"8 #"7 # " 8 5#0 70 >#8I@# # 8#5".> #""%0## ;"# "# 68 6"# .
$# "# 95#7"## #" /#> 9 # "# "# # 7 "8## ;"# 7 $7 # #8 8#"08 #>6# #8 #" #%. ## 8 9 "8 ">"# "88##" 7:8 # "# 8 7: # 2 "8## ;"# 9 7 64 # 7 # " #"8 .:# #""88##"9 6 " "%# . 7078 #">>7"# > 9 7#"%0## ;"# 7" 7:8$ # 7%# 8" #5%0""97#6.%# 9 " 8"#% #" # >7# # "#0 7#6 8#/ ";"# % "# "#%# #%"> "> #"" : .
-. "88# # #%);%#'<$0 K:8 "# 9 "# @"#>>"8 "5& #" 5 %" $ ># "#% "> #6 :8 Q"88K## %# Q. 55 $# #%/% > : 6:#9" #""0/8"" 8#9 #"# #"# .
"" #0 8## #5 ;9 7"#" # >7 # #" $ %" % " 8 " " "# >K# ;6 #. " >K # : 6: #$"8& 8##"K"0; K:8"# @"#># 0 >K&8I8#69# (,('+, ;%#'+"#.-4.
('+,+('- &M()*&
#"8 7 5"7/>$7% 8I8 "88##"$ 7 ## >#$ " $ %# # # 7#6;"# # 708#9#"# #" : .$# $70 : "# " # 5"8 7#"8 ;##>.
"> $"8 5"#:# $"88##" %#" # #% >7 &8I8 8# " 6 8"# 7:85# 6.6#5%#" #""# "5".
,. C";#$" 9> #"" " 6#5 ># " 5P" " K:8 " " % #" " "
2 G )*, )$ )L=' ''M4. %# " ; #5# K8##"K" K #""5"8##" >> K#:# ##>%## :#55%"0 K:8.%#8 "0; #5# $5 K# I #6 " #"#>#K% $" # 8" #5"2 (,('+ ,;%#'+"#.,##" "#5'M8)LL)$# -,($)LL'$.)<)4.
7/$ %# " #% "> 7:8. 70" 7#8"#0## 7 # ;"# 5P# % ;## #" 6%"# "8 ## > 5# 7I 8# #"# #"6> 5" 6# #8 #"#% : "# "# # ;". # $ "0; #%8 " " # $ #8" 8 9 8 # "8##" "88##" # " " %"" #$ "# 7# 5# " " J %"# #6 > : :8# "> 8 # " " > #" 7:8. 5#$ " " # $ " 88 "" ># # " "##/85"#97:8$ #" 8 # "# 9 " #" 8"J.
M. 9 8# # %# " I $ " 88 "# #""" #" %:K0 G.
"88##" " 8 5K""8#0#>$ K0$"K:8$8 ##9" #" "0/8 "8#$ "# >K# K # "#0 8# > #" # 5"# # 8 # # %# # #0. ">$K:8%# I %$8I8% 0/8$ K # %# "%"# 5# 2##" "88##" " 8 57""8#0#>)+8#)LL,$# ,)($)LLM$ .<<,4.
('+,+('- &=()*&
68 #" 68 #0 7/. #" $# > G # #9" #" .$# #8"#0 8#>"" # %"7#K%# " 8 8"J9K0 # "#.#"" K:8 55# . ##$ 5# #0 "# 8 # " # >#"## R"7%# "#" "# #"5# >K80 #"# $ K &9&# K0" #" #"8 ;##> " # $ S # #" >K "K:8.
8#"88##"8 " %# " " . " 8I8 #"$ # 7 "#0 #07 #0" " >>#5#: "88##". 8/ "#0 "# 9 5# " 7:8 # .
=. %>#/$#7 #7:8#6#570#& #"%" # 8#7# # ##" 0# # #"C 55(C@ O"""0/8.
L. " ## #8 8#. ##" "88##" K:8 %" . # " "# 9 K% # K:8 5# 6. " "0 0 :8 ": 9 #" 8# '- K:8 # ># 5# # 9 K8##" " "# "88 "##/8 #%# K #<*#+ %.
)*. #8# " TG )7.&$ 9 @6 7 $ "" >#"0 # #6#2 .=M 4.
7# # #6$ 8"8 TG <.& 8# 9 @6 78## #". @68 #> ">"6#> " @"%"#7 /%>#5 "% " #". 68 "@ %##7 ""8# "%"#;### "8 # # "%"#: #57 "%"#;###7 . 5#"5"89 $> " # 76 9 7:" #" J 8 #> 7 /% " 8"8 "2 (+'<('-)+;#'-4.
('+,+('- &L()*&
',* ,
/012$"!3
%0 " # ; = ;# '- !"# .1111111111 " ##""88##"K:8%" M;#'-F
123
78 #8 F
##""88##"7:8%" M;#'-F
"#" 9 97%# 7:85# 6 # "##/8 #%F
"" #8# " TG)7.&9@67 F
8 9@67# #88"8 TG<.&F
"88#> I 9 ! !" "#$ %" " ## >K9 "88##"K:8%" .
C#6 3 !.J@/$# $!8"%J T#$!. @#$;6$!."$ ;6 .
"8 #08## #53
655#/&;# 3 # 3 .#"&C#6# G.J@/
('+,+('- &)*()*&
"#"5"8 I "88#>: #.
/%$ 655#/3
('+,+('-