Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/685/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/685/2004 Generato dall'IA

Lien Validity Upon Judgment Revival

Numero d'incarto ATAS/685/2004
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case involved a challenge to the enforcement of a lien stemming from a prior judgment, where the judgment debtor claimed the lien was unenforceable due to procedural defects in the original enforcement filings and subsequent procedural lapses, arguing that the enforcement period had expired under the relevant statute. The court reasoned that the lien remained valid because the underlying judgment was properly revived within the statutory timeframe, and subsequent enforcement attempts, though potentially defective in some respects, did not constitute an abandonment of the lien rights; therefore, the lien was deemed valid and enforceable against the property.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Lien Validity Upon Judgment Revival: The court reasoned that the lien remained valid because the underlying judgment was properly revived within the statutory timeframe, and subsequent enforcement attempts, though potentially defective in some respects, did not constitute an abandonment of the lien rights; therefore, the lien was deemed valid and enforceable against the property.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
validità dell'esecuzione vizi procedurali pegno immobiliare revisione di una decisione insinuazione del credito validità della disdetta di locazione

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied because the complainant must bear the costs of the appeal.
Generato dall'IA
A/3972/2007
Post-Judgment Payments and Lien Enforcement Validity
A/1921/2003
Lien Enforcement Affirmation Despite Procedural Irregularities
A/4039/2006
Lien Enforcement Validity Due to Defective Notice
A/4399/2006
Lien Validity and Notice Requirements Appeal
A/339/2005
Lien Enforcement Validity Challenge

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied because the complainant must bear the costs of the appeal.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               %&'('%)) +%'(,%)-

""+

 +"  . +   " . .

-/  01   & 2  )- 



 3333333333   !" ! # $!"  %  &"' "(()*"( !!"



"!

. . +  ! 4  .  + +,  !"( -./0123& "*



              !" #$

   60426  

 5+

/7 #! 89999999999 *"" * & :"! "& ; (< (  *"*   "= >9999999999 ?           @   89999999999 A   !"  :"! ( ! ( 3&/BB,7

07 "" *"*  *"* (" ! C:" ( /2 =*&!! 0111 ( !$ ( !3!"(3&7

D7 !(*(0/(*$!011/ ":&( " E6 !3F G"=*;#!89999999999(*("" ? 4  4  ! ! ( (" (* (" ( 2H,BI =!7 01 ! '*/BB57 ""(**""$*!""(*"!"(2IH111=!7

,7 ! " ( /I C&! 0110 '"*!*  "!C"* !! "! "" (*  !3( "(!!"3!('!6&" !&&" E 4/52540110G7  (* *"" !$"!!    )'  =("!(-==!)*""7'"**""!)( !(! ("!)&"=(*(*7

+7 ! !*& ( /B ! 0110      !C" ( !!7  "" )'* (' *"*   "=  !!" *"" " ( "! ; '!6& " !&&" ; ""! ('(* ("7 'J" !K  =!" (  !" ( !!"  ( '"!"* = " E6 !3F % G  ! (' !!  "3! =   &" *"* "!" ( "<!  !!" ('== !  !! " )) *"" !")" """ !'*/BB57!=! '*""=(*!"<" ('== <*"* ! ' %  !  * &"7 ! ! !)  !*"" (  !*(! ("  !3 ( ' %  !"   *&" C""("" !!"=!7

57 !!!!(50110!!"()*)*"*&"(*::*( !" !""!()("")''&"6. * (!/BBI7 !(" ! ("(! !'* /BB5*""< !*"!)7

I7  // C" 0110   '" <*"* "  !(" '"""" ( ! !/BB5"" !*")':!")(" &"."!" ((!( !*"==!7 "")'*;! $"*"*( *"*!!"'*"" !*"=:!" !'""""7  )"*('*(&"."!)=*('(* ("(!")(*(

 4/52540110   6D426   "" *"" $* !  "<" = "  !  !7 ! ! ' %  &" "!6"  !(  (* (*="& ( "<" ! '* /BB5 !"   "  !& ( I1H111 =!7  (* ( "<" &" (."!!*;5H5+1=!7,1 /25=!7(=!("!"=7

27 !(*(/0C"0110 =<*""( ! *!( (C&!/BBI;C01117!/BBI/BB2"/BBB""'*&"; 5H2D5=!7,1 !*"*""$*!!&(*"!"(I1H111=!7! C&! ; C 0111  !& !   " *"" ( 2IH211 =!7 "  "" =<*;,H02I=!7D17

B7 !"(/DL"0110'"*!*"!C"*!!"!(* ! "= )' '*""  "&* "  =(" ! ( -==! !$"!! (6.E 4/2/+40110G7 *"";'*&(=!"(' !!! )'!! (" ;!&7

/17 ! !*& ( , "$! 0110    ! * )  !!" *"" " ( "!;' ?"")'(* ("7""(&"*"*=<*! $(=!"=! !' M"=*(*!(!"7

//7  !!"  "* ; ! ! ! ( (* !  (*"!!  ""= (* ! (  =! !6(&"  !$ " ( !;)&"*"*"!/!L"011D7

/07 ?!((( !$"(!  !(" "= !0B"D1 *!(7 !3&*!=" !3( "!"* =  "<" &" *"* " ( !" )   '&" ("=(!&!!(*7

/D7 00(*$!011D!!""*C"( !*(!!"&; (<!!7

/,7 ! !( ( /0 C&! 011,  ?  C"   4/2/+40110 ;   4/525401107

/+7 ! !!! ( 00 ! 0111,  !!"  ()* )  *"* *"" &!""  =" ! )' ' &" *"* ) !"! =7 "" "" (* (" & ( =$ !&  "<" ('== !!* *""""* !! 7

/57  !$ ( *  !) ( =!"  *"! ( "!"* =!""<"(0B3"D13 *!(

/I7 (""*"*)*< !"":!(*;C:!7

 4/52540110  6,426  

 "+

/7 :&!'!:"C(!EG*"*(=*"""*(3 /!L"011D !$"(!E ?G *( )C: ("  !*(" "  &6 !*(" )  *" " N C: !E!"7/"7!"+5 G7

?";'"('*"(NC:! ! !$=*(*! E %G0IC&!011, E %/D1 /15G!( :& ( "* /D=*&!! 011,  ( " "!"! !:" E!"7 /50 G !"""  ?(*:!!;"!C:""!('"""('*" (&<C:!7

?""" !  !! ( (!" $  %  (  !!." !(  /!C" 011, =!* ) "" ( " "!"! """  "   !""*""(!!O"=!(!"=*(*!E!!."/7/2D4011,G7

:"()"(H*&"""""*( ? % "* )  !*" (  "!$  &" ."! !   &  =! (*!:"! ( (!" =*(*! "  !"3!" ( '!"7 +I    '!!7

07 =!*" ; '!"7 D 7 D ( ( " "!"!   "!(" &"'"!*&:!(" ("(&" "( !! " *"* "! ('==  !$ " ( !  """")!""""3!(H!6&" !&&" E=7 !"7 +5  G7  !$ ( * "   *""   "3!7

D7 =*(*!! !":**!((!"(!(5"$! 0111 E6 !3F  G " "!*  &:!  /! C&! 011D "!O" ( $!(="(((!7(' 3 (!""=!*: !( "&:!C)'D/(*$!0110 *:!( ! )C:(!' ; !(! (*!"(="((!"('*""(=" "*!!;(" (*"!" (  (* ": E % /0I  ,5I (7/ /0/  D25 (7/$P=7*:"( ""!"!!"7207/ G7 !*" ":!*)<*;3!(( "(=*(*! ! '!6&"!&&"(01(*$!/B,5E6 !3F  ?G" ( !3:" '!6& " !&&" ( D/ "$! /B,I E6 !3F  ?G&:!C)'D/(*$!01107

 4/52540110   6+426   ,7 * *(=!"(* * ! !*"!!"!&$ &!"('!"72, ?7

+7  ": !" !  "" ! ( !  !!" ; '! &"!&&"7

57 ? '!"7 /! 7 / (   ? " !* =!*" ;  !*"   ! -J) (*  ?7  !* " " ( J! ( "" "" )' <!"  "&"* !"& E!" D 7 /!  ?G7  "" ( !* ) <!"  "&"* !"& " *  !6 "(!& !&"('<!('"&"*(* (""(* ("E!" ,7/! ?G7

"!* "*!& !&"('"&"*!"&(* ("('!"7B 7 /!  ? "" !& ) (  "" (* (" !&" ( '< "" (' "! ! ! ("! !" :!  J&('<!(' !=$*!("""!"&"*E!"7/I  ?G7  "" !K !  !& !&" (' "&"* (* ("$"("! !(&"."! J* ! ! !*"!E!" 017/! ?G7

?!"&!""("!&!(* (""( !  "&"* !"& EG  *   "= <!"  "&"* (* ("))"' !(! !" " !;!- (==!(*"*"")'(* ("EQ/10,G7

 "" ( I2R " !K !  !& !&" (' "&"* (* ("7!!""!&"!!(" (/11 =!*(""=*!!7?'"=*!!;,2D11=!'*3& ;I211=! !"<("""!*C)';,0R $!3 (*:!= E!" 5 7 /!  ?G7  !& !&" (' "&"* (* ("  !( "" !& ( "!& "! )  !**!" !  "!& (""(* ("7!& !&"('"&"* (* (" "   " ! ! ::* ( '"! ! " (*"!* !  "!"*="")*<( "E!"7B7 /"D ?G7"" !K!!& !&"('<!(' "&"*(* (""(*"!*"&!* *!()"7? ! " ( J! ( "" *::  !3 " ( (! ""  (" *!   ( "" 6 !" =<* !  "<"('==E!"/,70"D ?G7

!*"$!!&(*"!""!"*="=("! "<" *  =! ( ' M" =*(*! (!"7  '$ (' "<" *  =! ( ' M" =*(*! (!"  (* = (*"!" " "!*("<" *=!(' M""!!&;(*="

 4/52540110   65426   ((*!"&*!=*!"&;' M"=*(*!(!"7!!(  " " * !  (* ( "!"* = "7 ?  "!"*=" &" )!!&(  " "!"  !& (*"!" ! =<!  "" "   " ! !::*('"! !!$((*("( "7  ! " ( J! ( "" (&" !:!   (  ""!(( !(!"" 3"E!"70D ?G7

?  C! !( "" "<" = " !** =! ;  !*"*P "" !* " "."!=!*) !(="73!)(  " " * !  (* = " )  C: ( !  <  !  )"  (* (   )" ;  *:"*C:!"H*!"!((*("<""!*=!) 6 "" ( !!! =" " (L" !&* )H " $ ( !"=! (H$*  H H  ( "!  " (H**" ( ="  !""3!=(*"!"! (!7  " *:!( (   (" ! H<""( (H "<" =  ==" 7(*"!"(!&"==""S-)$<"!"* ="H !"" C:(!( !*(!6. ;"<"7H!*<!K""&"*!"&(* ("("(=! &!(!""3!("<"6&==")6 "&!!  ( "" ? 6  !!  (  !*(! C(! = E %//125(7,"DI17/15/D1(7//10D1(7DP? /BBI 705(70$"!*=*!G7

! !  !  !"  =! "!:" ( " = H )" *:"   ( "<" (H==7    (  ""C:(!"6* !" ==(*!"<"(H== *=!$)6" !*)H"<"*"$ !*(!!(!H"6;6(! !! !" ; ( (* !3" E %   $* ( + (*$! 0111    T/+411P /B22 7D0/"!*=*!G7

I7  ' 3    (*"!*  "" ( !!" !  $ (' "&"*(* ("7 !"; ! )*"" "( *"*"=7 !$(*!!)""=)""*"* !""(!!"( '!:")"*;."!! (-:"('*"!&/BB57$(  !$$)''" *"* ) !"! = ( "" *"*  ('""  )' ' C * ('."!'((<*7

 (*"!" ( !& $  !!  < "!"* =7 '"!"*==!; (*!)&" * !!" "! /BB5 " 01117  !!" () ""!  "<"

 4/52540110   6I426   )  !! (!"  ;  !*"*7 !   (*C;  ' ( =! &!  !:" (  (! (' !*(! C(! = )  !(=!!"<"('==<)&"*"*7 (-! ( =" !$" !""" ( !&!!  !* " ( =!"* (  "<";!*"*C:(!!"H*!"!((* ( "<" "!*  =! )  6 "" ( !!! =" " (L" !&* )H " $ ( !"=! (H$*  H H  ( "!  "(H**"(=" !""3!=(*"!"!  (!7

' 3**"*;' (!!"<"";'< " ())("!" "$"*(*"* !'*/BBI7 '!*  !("  3 ) !""!" ( ! )  "<"  =! "(!" ( !!! =" "   '  " ( "!  " ('"! **" (*"!" !   ( ! 7  " *:!(("!"'*/BBI !("" ==" ! =!!  !* " ( '<""( (  "<" =  ('""  )'("!"="=!* !$(*"" ( "<" ('== !  0B " D1 *!( "  * /BBI6/BB2 " /BBB601117  "<"  $" ! ( !& ! "= ( I1H111 " 2IH211=!7  ) !! ( < "" !" !    ' !"" ( C:( !*(!;&"<"7

27  $**= (  ) !*3( '" ; $ (!" )   '" $* !  =!"!K( !"("!"*= !(*"!!""( "" !( !!!"7

 !! " ( !C"* "  (* ( "" =!* ""  !" '* /BB5  "" )'  =<*  "" ( ; 5H5+1=!7,1 /25=!7 (=! ("!"=(3!* "("<"= (*="&7



 4/52540110   62426   " . +5  +"  . +   " . .

 06   7  2   8$ &') 

  6 

/7 *!!!!&$P

 6

07 !C""P

D7 =!  (* "")* ""  =<"  "" ! '*/BB5;5H5+1=!7,1 /25=!7(=!("!"=P

,7 ") !*(!":!""P

+7 =!  !" (  )' &" =!! !! "!  !*" !!." (  (* ( D1 C! (3  "=" !  !(* (!*  !$ =*(*! ( ! ?-UN!-=) 5 511,     "! < !7  (*  " ."! !:*7  *! ("F G ()! <"")(*!!"(*!$"!" ((* "")*P $G < ! ! ) "=  " &! ((! "" "! (*P G !"!  :"!   (  ! !*""7 ?  *!  ""   "! **" **!*  ""! G $G " G 6(  !$=*(*!(! !! "!!"3!!!!)' (&!(*!!!!&$7*!(!!"!!J ( !& ) !" C"  )  (* "")* " '&  ( )*"*< *(*!!"E!"7/D0/15"/12G7  :!==!F  !*("F   8(  #          !*"!6C!"F #!T ##  

 =!( !*"!!."""=*< !" !:!==

 4/52540110