Security Interest Validity After Contract Amendment
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed whether a contract amendment, which altered the payment terms for prior work by changing the valuation method and extending the payment period, constituted a material change sufficient to invalidate the original security interest. The court reasoned that the amendment, while changing the structure of payment for completed work, did not fundamentally alter the obligation securing the interest, as the underlying debt for the work performed remained the same, thus the original security interest remained valid and enforceable against the collateral.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Security Interest Validity After Contract Amendment: The court reasoned that the amendment, while changing the structure of payment for completed work, did not fundamentally alter the obligation securing the interest, as the underlying debt for the work performed remained the same, thus the original security interest remained valid and enforceable against the collateral.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!"###### ! "#$%&
&
$% & $ ' ($) * +&" &"$ %"'" "&" (
)*+,)
12 !&" !333333 4")56 & & '" 7$ 1* ( 1,.-$ &( 8 " " & " '& 9 : ;"2< &($ $1,==$;"8" 9 '("&( $ & (( & 8 % %"&> 1,?@$ :$ 8 A" '("&( & 8 (">1,?,$;"$8B"C"&&%"&$ "(" 8A" "&" 9&B'"&2
&$& '9 " && &<A"($ 10("1,==$&" "#& "'&" "(( $ % & D "<<" << %" "&2 9 %" B#B& &%" %E " #%" B'" ( &" "2& '9 " "F &<G"#$10<%"1,?,$&" 8'9" ' &H #% &" "("H 8 %&( ( "&( 2 9 &"#" B'' A&&#"B$ &( &H &" !2!333333$ "B "B 9 9" " $ "B &% E " " ( %&& "& 2
*2 !2!333333 &(&"5<&"@&%(H1,,? &'"H"B &5%8""B "& & "% %"& % 2 & '" && " ( " "&' "-@A"<<1"* &" *1 (H 1,@= 4 I ; @112/7 & " &( " & # H" ( &( ' " ( FA" "B$ " J# ""H ' " ("2 !2!333333 " " 8"& A()&&2
10 %" 1,,,$ & "& J &%&" & !2!333333 B" "" 5 9 '#"& &A" 8 & '"'E &"&'9 FA" $! AK$ && *1J%"1,,?2
1@ &L 1,,,$ "H < J &%&" " & &" H" <&( !2 !333333 & 'E & "&2 & (( "( "<& #"< & & B ('" ( " "&& "&2
1- <%" *///$ !2 !333333 & " & ! AK & <9 (&"##2 <<"(" B " %" ( "&
+--.,+*//0 )@+,)
B " % " & & '9 " & B'" ' %" B' 2 " !"" 5 H"$ BM &<"( A(HM "&-("*///21-("*//*$!"" 5H"< &%"&$< M( &%92 ""& &<"( A(HM "&.J"*//*2
11& &H*//*$!2!333333&(%""&5 & "&2#" B'E J"" "& " <& <9 (&"## & ! AK2 ( J E 1=J%"*//@2
@2 5( 8 & J"""$ !2 !333333 H<"" ' "%"FA&&#"B A "B2
;& & FA&&#"B *@ & &H 1,,? H" !&" A"" <<$ & FA&&#" FA&&#)FA& A $ !2!333333 " "%" FA&&#"B %" (" "& A()&&2 " M"(& &H ((&" & B" " " &A ##" 8 M"% " " ( 8&# (2
&"*1%"*///$!2<<"<&( &"%" FA" "B 4")56 ;7 B !2 !333333 " "%" " * & &H 1,,? """ ("5 ""# & A "B2 A" %"" (" (8 &%"<&( "& "%9 & ((&" '" 2 !2 !333333 " %" "( M "J "2 & " " " &" & M" &"& A" NOB N2
9(& "B1? (H*///;" "$ ((H ;$%B")"&%" M" M"(# & (& "&$%"&&9" 2 " %&" &(8 & " "%#&" 2
;& & FA&&#"B . <%" *//1 !2 <<$ H& & A "B M " " " !2 !3333332 ")" "" <" "(" %&" "J ( &(2( " !"" 5 H"$M9 $%" "( & FA&&#"B&" &# &" &"2
M5 & !2 << 1@ J" *//1$ &"# "%$!2!333333M "(" &J&%" "(M"J "2
" &9("&"B*- (H*//1$;" " & B%"&<" !2!333333' " (&"<""M 2
+--.,+*//0 )-+,)
? (" *//*$ &< G"# ; & FA&&#"B H" !2 A"" << 1, %" *//*2 & " " & B"%" A "B " " &("<"&%(H*//1$ B!2!333333M " &&8 "%"$("(" &J&& "&$ "& & B " A# A "B %" " "2&<G"#( "&" "B!2!333333" " 8 " <" & B " %" &( BM" <" M ( "5 " A# FA& A "B B" %"" B&B &H5("89" 2
& M9(1@&%(H*//*$ " $((H ;$ & B& ""B$ && !2 !333333 ( " "B89 &M9( 2
1? (H*//@$ !2!333333&"" ;("&% M &% 9 " FA" "B2 " BE *? (H "% 2*/& &H*//@$"B"%(M" ( $ &B$&"$&H %" " 2
*@ & &H *//@$ # "& ("&)J""B ;$ &(& & (( 9("FA" $& !2!3333332
""& 1* J%" *//-$ ; < M&& &% 9 " %(M" ( 2M !2!333333' " ("&"H &" ( 2'" " " 8"<" <" & " ( $ " A# A "B B"% 8 &P <" 2(H" & <&"&M%"%&" " A# & D"&92;#&" M%" "(" " <" " B$ ("" &% $ " &(( &% "< "&$ &% &P ( "H &"8#8M 2
1* <%" *//-$ !2 !333333 " J & 5 "H 8M& ""& ;2E 0J" *//-$& J 2 & "& "H<J $1?& &H *//-$&&" ("" "<<&(!2!333333& E 2
-2 *=J%"*//.$&'" "&# "&("&)J""B ;$ !2 !333333 9"( &A" <" &$ 8 <"$ 8 9 ""%2" (&"1@<%"*//.2 ; BE =(*//.2
!2!333333&( &&(H2 "&& ,("*//02&"!2!333333'&(("B ;?J"*//0
+--.,+*//0 ).+,)
""B B 9 " H"" 5 & ! AK J "<"" %('" ( 2
'9 " &&(H &" 8 '9" ' &H &" !2!333333$"("H8 &H ( 8 %&( ( "&( 2' "H&A8!2!333333 " & %& ( $ &<"(" B"%" &J&< & " ( 2 &H " "<<""( " H 9"#" '##( " "&FA& A "B2' " " B' " ( FA& A "B( " "("("5& H "B &((""& &%9 " 2 ;& &&(H$ 8 < " ( $"B" " $B"" &A" H"%"' " ( !2 !3333332 " &(&( " #%( " H"B$<<"( B%"&& ")"%" <" % " (& & " " ("#" H"B2
.2 , &L *//0$ # "& ("&)J""B ; !2!3333332 " <<"( &<<" ' &H FA"B '" ' "%" FA& A "B "B( & " &B&#" "& <"" " "&2" "<" &B"%" &(2
1. (H *//0$ !2 !333333 &H% "& ; & 8 % ( '" ( && H ' F&&! AK " " "2
02 ""&*& &H*//0$& "<"8!2!333333*=& &H*//0 8 & &" @/ & &H *//0$ ; < % ( '" ( 2 ' FA"B !2 !333333 '%" %& " & " ( 2 " " 8 " B" " " &A <" "% & " ( 2 %" &((""< "&& #%" " &" <" B"&"" 8" % H<2 " &J&#& H"B "B ""%&%" E B('" ( 2'9 " &&(H J "<"" F & "$ A & " "&$ & (( &B' <<"(" B !2 !333333 &(&( " H"B & &" B "B ""%' " #"#H2
=2 & *= &%(H *//0$ !2 !333333 & 5 "H ("" "< & ""& * & &H *//02 & "&( ;B"<&8 & ("'9 " & ! AK> 9 " &$ " "(&"H '<<"( B !2!333333 #&" H"B(& "<B& '%&2'9 " &&(H&%" E $' "
+--.,+*//0 )0+,)
& " "& % <" & 2 ;" ; %" & 9 "$ " " " ( 9" "& &(( "8'9 $B'"'%" <" 2
?2 1 (H *//0$ "H ("" "< B" & J "&((" "&&"&&+,./@+1,,=2" ("*/(H*//02
,2 = (H *//0$!2 !333333 (" H<" '" J""B2
1/2 11 J%" *//=$ ; & <&( &H% "& ""5 ' <8""& B2
112 1* J%" *//=$ "H ("" "< "<&( " B'" #" 8J#2
%
12 J ( " % J"" "& &( $ & %H4 2.0 &"M&#" "&J"""&%(H1,-1) ) */.> 20@21 2&"&("" "%1* (H1,?.) ) .1/72
*2 "H("" "< &( &9("H")<& ""& " "#" 4 +1*=+*//= */ ( *//=7$ )" F " % ' %"# &% "&" "& &" < 1@ (H*//*(&"<" "# &"*1(H 1,@=4 );@112/)*//02@-., @.@.72
& <&"$ E J#"""&B% "H '" "& " (2 << $ " % 9(" & $ # 8 ' " * A"<< * "&" "& " &" ' "0.&"'" "& &" ' &"<( "51=&%(H*//04 ) -1/7$ %"# *= J%" *//=$ & '# &% &" H<"" '&%&"'9(#2
$ &J&&'E " $ &" E 9(" & '# '" &" 2 A#( #" "< ' 5 " &" &H"# "& & # ' % 8 '" ( '" ( B"<2
;& ' " 1/ H $ ; " ' &" &( & (( &( <"8'" ( $%&"AD" $A&"
+--.,+*//0 )=+,)
& " ( (H &" "B &(9$ & &" "H "& 8 '" & "(& 5# &" 2 " &( #( && (" &&" # "&2
'5$ &'"$E @&%(H1,,?$&<"( & "& "H<$&(& 8" "B "& & "% %"& % & " &( "&'" ( 2 J"" "&& & "(B'"& & ( $& &(&( " #%( " H"B B'" F%" "(""<(&%"("#' " 4 2-@A212* 72
@2 &"%$<"" "%( &8'"$(&&$" < 9(" ' & "B B' &(( &% "< "&4 :1?&"2@21.+1072#&" ' " ($ & B'" F " & % & H #&" & && % ( 4 E "H <
0 201+*//-1?& &H*//-$&"2-2172
'5$ ; ""& "5$ 5 %&" & 2<%('" ( "& 'H'%& "&' & $" 8" B" " " &A 8 < "% & " ( $ & B'" %" &((""< "&& #%" " &" <" B" &"" 8" %H<2& ;$& " &J&#& H"B "B""% &%" E B('" ( 2
-2 " "B & J '9 " ! AK & 5&<" & 'F ;( (&"<" &"&2 << $ & J8 5 & '9 "! AK2;" & ! AK $ (&<"( A(H' "&2;(%""&'E &'" J 2;" 8""&1*J%"*//- ; < M&& &% 9 " % ( M" ( $ &<"( "H ("" "< 0 J" *//-$ " & "& "H<1?& &H*//-$ "5J"" "& J# &(( ""H B & " ""%" " # & " H"B2 J"" "& ' (" & ! AK2 & " J# B 'H '%& "& ' & " """ 2' & &"H%&"&((<" & '& " "& 9 "1,==""B1,?,$' $ ! AK 1,,?$' 2'" "&#&" & %&% #%" &" 2 ; " &<&8&" "&
+--.,+*//0 )?+,)
& ! AK&&&'H'%& "&' & '9" '#J "<" &" ( 2
.2 !2!333333& #( <" B ;" &"& '9 ""% &&(H&((& " &" '" 2& E "%"&" 2 &&(H&P B"B""% 9" B" E B " ( &"25 & B & " 8 < & " ( $ " (EA & &(& ( & "(" "&"B""%2
&&(H <<"( " "B B & &(&( " #%( " H"B2 9 J "<" <<"( "& & " "& % "B ""% <<"( B %"&& & %" <" % " (& & " " (" # " H"B2 " "& "&( "H %'E @&%(H1,,? &'"B"&(& 8 " "B"&& "%%"&% 2 & '" "& ##% Q R "& Q"( '9 E(%"&B"&(# "%%"&R4 E $2*7$ B" 8 %" "( B &(H 8 B'" &&(( B" &(" & Q (& "< #&S "<""&9$#&%" "(R4 E $2*72 &&(H & "" 8 'H #&" "B( B'" " #&" 8 "% " 8 " & '"2 ' & 8 H& &" B ; &" B 9 " & " '" "& #&" & " "& J "<" B'&" 2
02 %B"5$&J 2
&&H '"" "#$("&( " "&& $ (&( T4 ?= 72
UUUUU
'$ %
,-."!/
%H & " J *= &%(H *//0 !&" !333333 & ""& &"%"FA" "B*& &H*//0>
+--.,+*//0 ),+,)
./
J >
" B'"' T'(&( >
" B$ &<&(( 9 " ?* "% &" < "H < 1= J" *//. 4 :); 1=@211/7$ E E & J& B" "% & "<" "& )% "H <$ %&" &( "5&" H">((&"&&" ""B&"&$ (& "< (&F% & "# & &&( ">" &" E "H <$ 1/// 1-$ %&" & & %&" &"B 9 &" "& M " -* :2 E "5 &"& & $ "%&B &(( (&F %$ &"% E J&" 8 M%&">
&(("B E 8 ! " #$ %& & $ &" %"FA" "B$&" &"%"'" "&" ($ ""B' "H'" "&" ($&"<&( "&2
;"# 6 !(&%F$" $!(G"$!2 A"$J#$!2# !2 $J# 2
&( "H("" "<6
#<<"5)J" J22"26 %")" 6 2 2&%F &"&<&( E &(("B9 "2 5%$ #<<"56
+--.,+*//0