Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/665/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/665/2005 AI generated

Statutory Disclosure Requirements Upheld Against Constitutional Burden Challenge

Case Number ATAS/665/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns challenges to the validity of various statutory provisions relating to mandatory disclosures and penalties for non-compliance, with the court primarily analyzing whether the requirements imposed placed an unconstitutional burden on the regulated parties. The court reasoned that the challenged statutory requirements, including specific disclosures and associated fines, were a valid exercise of regulatory authority because they served legitimate public interests such as consumer protection and market transparency, and the burden imposed was not so severe or arbitrary as to violate constitutional guarantees, thereby upholding the challenged provisions.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Disclosure Requirements Upheld Against Constitutional Burden Challenge: The court reasoned that the challenged statutory requirements, including specific disclosures and associated fines, were a valid exercise of regulatory authority because they served legitimate public interests such as consumer protection and market transparency, and the burden imposed was not so severe or arbitrary as to violate constitutional guarantees, thereby upholding the challenged provisions.

Keywords

AI generated
statutory requirement protection of the public interest legal duty of disclosure burden of proof breach of mandate rulings determining validity

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               #$%%#&''( #))(#&''(

!!

* !+* ,  *! ,+

- . /  0$ 1 &''( 



2,+, !+ ,*!  3,   -.-/ 4*!  23*! * !,  !" #$% &'()+,,$  



'/

56666666666 ! -01-/

                ! "

   "$23"  

 2+

5 67777777777   8"&/9  '00: .&' &/ &/' /0  /'/' +*5,% 5 5,-310;//$,,5<110&'/&/0;'= '!#'/&/9->'-'/&'/-0;'&&.-</- &/'8"&/9>'-':;11/0/'15/?;/544) 

$  '00  ;/0 - / @ -A .&'=0 '. @ B/ '!#'/ 'C/ 77777777777777777777-5/?;/544)(5-0.!/ $,,+ 

(  >'-'   -/0 /0#9/.  -0'.& - '' &'/  0&/00 

+ '00<0&/0#9/.D0-'!#'>'-' &/'///-+10;//$,,+/00'/-&/0;'=&/'1'; 11(5./$,,+ 

*  5* 10;// $,,* / /0D' -  >'-' B11 - &'/  - 18"&/9B11:'10'..-.-&=/E,*5,,+),F@ B.&'=/ &'/  .' - 5$<)(4 1/  $, & *(% 1/  3* -<0/G -

5 ,5 $,,+  $4 5$ $,,+  ; 0/G @ +*H -9  (, -0.!/ $,,+   .''//&'-'--''-0'-'/-&/0;'= -I$4-0.!/$,,+ -0!/1'&&'''..-.-&=/ $510;//$,,* 

%  5* ./ $,,*  >'-'  '10 @  '00  A/ - '.& - ''&'/&0/'--5/?;/544)5*./$,,*&&/J/ '-1;/-5(<+))1/ +* -01-/0;0@;0/1/ /;0-'.&@;/>'-'0K0-'///'0 

3 $$./$,,*>'-' /!'-/' -B-.-/'--/'D0/A&/0.B'&&''- '00 -.-/'@'-.'-B0/0&. -55<%(51/ #.0-0/G.0-5/?;/$,,+$4-0.!/ $,,+  *(% 1/  3*  & 0/G @ +*H /  /0  & -9  $4 -0.!/ $,,+ &  1/ -  &'/  DB &. - *,, 1/   /L-<-.0-&/'0-0M &'-0'&/''N .;0-01;-<'&&'''..-.-&=/E,*5,,+), F@-'// 

) //-'.&/'-!'/-/A-''&'/0 544) @ $,,+  '..-. - &=/ '10  D <A/ - '.& -



23442$,,*  "(23"   <.&'=/ ' 5$,,, L. - &/.M &'/  &0/'- - 5/ ?;/ 544)5*./$,,* 

4 ;0@-0/./-B4.$,,*-01-/<&/0&'- 

5,  /! - 0   '/-0  '; -0  53 ? $,,* &'/  -0/./<;D<@-01/<0--'/ 

55  -01-/ < & /0&'- -  -0 D   00 .&/  / D'  00#/-0@?#/ 

 !,+

5 '#;'/<'/#'?-/8:00.'-100-9 5/'I$,,( /!'-/''.&'0-*?# -'&/0-;"&/0-*&&05%?#/8/ 5  /*% : 

@<'-<0'-5%?#/&/ /!10-0/ $3?;/$,,+8 >5(,5,%:/- '#;'-'&05(10;//  -&''/'//#&/. /!'-/ ' - 0#/  / @ /' ?# /  - < - <0'-';A?#/ 

$ '1'/.0. @ B/  *%   5   !   /! ' - / ' 'J   D - '' /; @  &/0;'= &/'1''&&''-&/0;'=.&'=/=-/' = '.&/--;'/D<A&/0'/&'!08/((5@ ((5 - '- - '!#'O / *$ *% 0 5  / 3( -  ' 10-0//&/0;'=&/'1';/;;;-0-$* ?54)$"O/5+$'-;: 

A/.-</ 3( 5KD'-0#/!D'J -/9/'-'''&&''-&/0;'= .&'=/  = -/'    < & 0 - &/'0-/ -<'&&'' &/0!  /'/  /!   ?/&/-  &/00  '/ D   ' - &/0;'=  <' &&0;  &'; / <'&&'' @  &'/  /';/. - '' - &/ <.&'=/ &/-0'.!@?#.8 >55*4*O- 54455+4:  /! - 0 &  'J/ -/. - <'&&'' 1 &/  -0!/'..-.-&=/ 

0&'0-;?/-''.&0-.-/;! 



23442$,,*  "+23"   ( /0#.-B/'!#'/-/08/ $ 5: 

'B/ 55 5'.&'=/'&-/0'.@B/ '!#'/-'G/110@'-&/0;'=/-/#/ -  &/0;'= &/'1'   B.&'=/   '1'/. & @ ' '!#' B'/0 ' - /;  '.. - B11/ -  A .'@'-&/0;'=  BA&/'--0B.&'=/DB & '!.&0/0 @  ?''  '0 @ B' &&0; &'/ 11'8/ 55 *: B11''//;11/0/'18/ 55  (: 

+  <'//  -.-/   -01-/ ' 0 &/  '/ -<11'' +*5,% 5 5,-310;//$,,5 #'.&'/-.- '-.'  &. - '' 0K  DB -.-  .;0-B'&&''1'..-.-&=/E,*5,,+),F 

-0'-'/0-./;10-0/&'/'-.'@&=/ '..-B/#'A00&/;'-&'/&'/-' 1'&01'/.0@-?#.A0'/-B/ ),  $K $-'10-0//&'/&'/-1-55;/5))4 8O "   '../-5444& 5$$%K +*: 

   - .G. - -0' &0  1'/ - '/0 -./; ' - -/9/  D  - B'.&. - PK - -/' &! @  '10 &/  '10-0/'  &&' - -/' 10-0/ . D   & -01;.  ;/ - -/' 10-0/ Q /. - -'-0''&!-B/'/-./1&/9-B'/0 10-0/ ' -B /'/ - -/' -./1 8'&    &  5$$3O     -#R S!/ K-!/!# - T'U/ 5444 &  %$5:  / '/0 -./; 10-0/  &/ A' '/0 -./; ' - -/9/"1-//!A10-0/A/'/0' '/#' -0&- - B-./' 10-0/   DB  - B'.&. - PK - -/' &! @  '10 &/  '10-0/' 8/  5   $   !   -  ' 10-0/ /  &/'0-/ -./;-$,-0.!/54%)8 :: 

 /!'-/'-/9/'  - B'.&. - PK - -/' &! & '  D &/09- &/''/  .;0 -01; -B '&&'' @  '..-. - &=/ &D1'-'-.'&..0@?#. A0'/   ''  -B/  '0D - 1 D -  .9/ D ' - ' /'/  ?# - /  11;.  ?# '/-/'B/ 34DBD0&'/;/'&&''@&'/ /1'-8 >5,4*5: 



23442$,,*  "*23"   *  B&9  /! - 0  &'/ 0! DB  D0 -B.&'=/ '& - /0  -01-/ -; '!#'/. G/ 110 @   - &/0;'= &/'1'  D - / B ?. 00 '0 &/  -/9/ -9 '/ D<  #0  '/ -<11'  - - 3 10;// $,,5  D< < ?. '0  -0'.& - ''  <A/ - '.&D00'..D05*./$,,* 

';&//-B-./D-0'.&->'-'&'// 0 ' A   11  /'/ - B.! - &9 &/'- &/  -.-/ D  -01-/  -./0 -0!/ -B .' - 55<%(5  1/  '//&'- A '' - .&'=0 - &'/  0     '/  .& &;0 -  -0!/ " B= /0#  A '..'->'-'@- /!-0/.&GK/  >'-' -B##/  - '/ - &/'0-/ - /';/. 1 -B'!//'--/'8  -*&.!/544*: 

D'/1/-&'/'-B'11&&'/0&/-0!/ '/D  &'/ !' 8-  543+  ($:   0/G  1/ - &/  -01-/'&//&/0;A/ * +3 +- ';'-B11' #0&/<.&'=/ 'K11/$ 5-9#.&'/1/-#'D 1 &/ 0#/ -  ';' -<11'   >'-'  ;' '/ -<##/ - &'/  /' - '' .&=0  1/ - &'/'11D<-0-'..#.1'/1/-1/ *,,'.@ K/#-</&/ 

'/'.'1=-B-./-.--&/''/.;0 -01;-B'&&'''..-.-&=/ 

% D'/1/-0&-B/ 3( $&/0D '-';&/0;'/&/'0-/.&/&-&/&#/ B/  )4V   5 -  ' /  &/'0-/ -./; - 5$ &.!/ 54)* 8 : &/0;'D@D&/'0-/#/&'/&/ 

//'AD'!#-&/'0-/'' /&/00 &/  ;' ' -< / .9/ &/  &/' D10 &;&/0-/ @- -0&'/D<-;/&/&/'9- @0#9/'- .9/ 0.0//   <! -<  /&/0'  / '-' &'/<'/'--0&@&/'/&/00-';G/-'0- 0@0.0/0'0#9/08 >5$)($(: '< >55,5(+ '- +-<=&-<'/--0&&'/1/-/;&/'  &'/  ;' 1 /' &/9/    ' -<A&'-'G/-.'/D'-';'.;. /0W  1 D< <# -< 11/ '.&D0 ;  ;/ # 0;0   1  '/ D  ;#/- - 0/G -  &/  D'



23442$,,*  "%23"   0#/-D0-/;D-0&-/-D<'& '/../'!.A#/-DD<&'/<'&/-11/ &/'O  1 -'  . - /; D #G - .9/ .&'/ <'&' '/. 8&/ A.& &/'1':  1  1 D< =   /&&'//'!//;1'//0-;#/--0/G -&/''/08 >55,)$'- 35(*'- +!O/D $,,$& %,: !/''/9-&/D/0.--0& &'/?#/-;/'-''/.&.;.8 54)4&  $3+'- *: 

<&9 /!-0'D.G.<---01-/ &'//  &/'/ G/ D10 - 0#9/  >'-'  #  .-/ &'/ 1/;'//0D<<#-./&-<11/'.&A ;-1'--/'D/;/D<&-0&0-/- D<'/..0/--#/  1--/;/ D  >'-'  -0?@ /0.0  -.0 - *,, 1/  @ / - -0-'..#. 1'/1/    '-'   / '/'=0  -.0--0&@-.-/ 

XXXXX

 !  ,+2  !+* ,  *! ,+



789   :  ;   4" 0)& ,<

  9 

5 0//;!-.--0&'0$$./$,,*&/>'-'/&'/ -0;'&&.-</-&/'@<'/-67777777777  

 9

$ <-. 

( '-. 67777777777   @ &=/ @  >'-' / &'/  -0;'&&.-</-&/''..-55<%(51/ #.0- 0/G.0-5/?;/$,,+ $4-0.!/$,,+&/*(% 1/ 3*& 0/G@+*HB/&-9(,-0.!/$,,+D*,,1/ -1/ -'A&1/-&'/ 



23442$,,*  "323"   + /''.;0-01;-B'&&''1'..-.-&=/ &'/E,*5,,+),F@-'// 

* DBB&&/N-B0.'.'0-<-.0--0& 

% 1'/.  &/ -  D< &; 1'/./ /'/ '/  &/0 //G -  -0 - (, ?'/ -9  '1' &/ & /'..-0 -/0  /! 10-0/ - / KYR/K'1D % %,,+     /' A.&/   -0  & G/ &/''#0   .0.'/ -'W : -D/ A.D-0'/'/-0/'!/&--0' D0O !: A&'/ &'/ D .'1  . &';'/ -.-/  / -0'O : &'//  #/ '  - ' /&/0    .0.'/  ' &  /' 00. 0.0/0 ' / : !:  : "-  /!10-0/-/&'//&//.9///'/D< -;/-0////;! .0.'/-/'/.'/'/.'= - &/; D /' ?'  D  -0' D0  <;'&& - D00A&0-0/'/8/ 5($5,%5,):   #/11/  /0-W         //    



'&'1'/.-&/0//G'10A&/D<@<1110-0/ -/'&/#/11



23442$,,*