Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/19/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/19/2006 AI generated

Historical Land Rights Interpretation and Application

Case Number ATAS/19/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court addressed multiple appeals concerning land transactions and property rights stemming from various historical agreements and legislative acts, with central issues revolving around the proper interpretation and application of these older instruments to current ownership claims. The court reasoned that the relevant statutory provisions and historical deeds established a clear, definitive pattern of ownership rights and reservations, concluding that the current claimants' rights were either clearly established or extinguished by the language of the controlling prior instruments, thereby affirming or denying the challenged property dispositions based on a strict textual analysis of the governing historical documents.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Historical Land Rights Interpretation and Application: The court reasoned that the relevant statutory provisions and historical deeds established a clear, definitive pattern of ownership rights and reservations, concluding that the current claimants' rights were either clearly established or extinguished by the language of the controlling prior instruments, thereby affirming or denying the challenged property dispositions based on a strict textual analysis of the governing historical documents.

Keywords

AI generated
right to property right of reservation strict interpretation and application subdivision of land subject of expropriation easement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the imposition of costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               "#$%"&''$ "()"&''*

!!

+ !,+ -  +! -,

. / #  (& 01 &''* 



 !!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'%((# % )'%((*%  + 

%

,   "(+%-./"$%012/"3133 %#'    33



                ! 

   -142-  

 2,

38 '%'9!!!!!!!!!!+ :%;-$<='%'>"%?%( ## ( <& ; > ($  30 :'& 3..0" &% $ @% )A% %  &%(#%'%?:#%B"C'(%%(%@%(?" %&D('?"(C??%(('&$$#%CE$$%%B $ ( $%$%8  '%' :% $% ( ?$ F!!!!!!!!!!8 8 8" ?%'  &( ;+ >" B $$%% '?#%'%'F!!!!!!!!!!G!!!!!!!!!!+ :%"H!!!!!!!!!!+  :%%F!!!!!!!!!!G!!!!!!!!!! 8" (8

18  !!!!!!!!!!'%'% B%'(C(#%%B& ?%(&(30:'&3..08

58 < )'%' 1777"  '%'  %' ( (::%' :< %  %%  C% $ '%' B%%' (  (' $% $  8   %$:(C +( ,'('%(%$#(;-$< >" I B  '%' '%% ::'"  (J ('$ $ 'B% ( $%8

K8 3KL1773" !!!!!!!!!!&'L?B'%'%&% %%((%%#%%:%'%'$'10$%#@17738

08 +% I  # ( ('% $' %&  / &#@ 1773"  ?#% ( $#%  '%'  &  !!!!!!!!!! %  $% $''%''?'L&17718

68 )'%%(%'%'$@'K$%#@17718

28  3/ :'& 1775"  % ( (':% ( @  '%' %:' I   $  #%%(,85)/K08-8

/8 33('#@1775"%:'I !!!!!!!!!!(' '$%((##?(C#%%(,85)3218278

.8  11 ('#@ 1775"  !!!!!!!!!!  :#' $$%  :% %##%&B))&%$##('???&8

378  ('  $$% (%' ( 3/ %@ 177K # %:'  3/ L& 1770":#'('%8

338 %(36:'&1770('$'?A%( @%( " !!!!!!!!!!%L%'%%%('8



450641770  -542-    :% %##% &  $$% ( (% $   ( '#  '$%((##?8%%B)%)(%B(%)$$B #%<"(<B))?%()%%%((%#%'8<&B &((##?-:%L(B#%('%#%-(%($'( :%%%(%'&(%8

318 &%'I$""('$(11#1770"C?%( $$%"'#C&BC(%C%$$@B(M (#('$%((##?%%&&%3L&17758  %"&'?#%%%$$@8  :%& B$$%(C%80185 +%$$@$(##?B C$:%&&%3L&1775$%%B' C% $  '%' $% I %% (%  C (%8 <  B  $(:%'%'$@'3KL%1771"(''$%( (##?(33('#@1775)'%%""$$%8

358 '$B(1.&1770"%#%$%8:%& B" %#% I  B %%  "  )% $  ##% B  (#('$%((##?%:#'B%('%#%$& &(%)$$B#@((''$% ((##?8)"-%')(%"@B $$%##'I)(%'?#%8

3K8 ($B(3.#1770""$$%"'?#%#% $%8 (#%B<?($$%'#%((%#%'"# %# B" $B  ('  '$% ( (##? )'%% $ $'#'  3 L& 1775" )%  & (' ( $$% B % $$@" :#'#% I )%8 /1 8 3 3< $A    B  ($% #%'(%$$$@D$%%%D' :D'&%%'&?8

 !-,

38 ?&C?%L(;>'%'#(:'%%%'"(< 3J%1775" @%("#$'(0L?" (%  $'(% %  &-$'(%" 0 $$'% % 36 L?  ;%8 3 %8%06 >8

+%IC%(C'%(36L?"$ @:'(' 12L&177K; ,357376>"( ?&($%'"35:'&"  ($%%%?%$#%%% @%(  ( '?   I % L? %%" " ( C%%% ( C'%(&DL?8



450641770  -K42-  

18 :#'#% I )%8 06 " + *%  % B %##% (%%%$'&IC%806(:'('$%?''((% ((6%@1777; N/5783>%&I:'(' (17('#@3.K6C-&%&&%; +N%8068 3%8A83>8+#$'%$L?((C$<%('%@8

58    % %'  &?  3 L& 1775" %*% ( #@ #(:% (  (# ( C-&" %##%   B C%801 +8'#"$@%'(C#$E%'?'( #< $ ('%' BC$&% I C%8 01  + %  %8 /3 % /1( <?#%(53%@3.K2C-&%&&%; +>% '%' @?'8  & ($% '? % %##% #$'  $'((('(#%%&"&"()$$%"()%( '$%((##?;%8/3 +>"$$'(( ('"(('$$%%(((%(#%%:;%80181  +"(%&?($3L&1775"%801%06 >8

K8  @ ( ' %% B  " %L%'  %#$ % ;%8 67 83 >%&@:#8

08 + )%8 01  +" % B) &? LB) 53 ('#@ 1771" )#$E B"%%#%$'???&")@&$($$%%    (##? I   ( #$%" % % I '$%8 + )?%$#"$@%'$%)'%("I%%@(" D?B%?#; ,31530(80@"31166(8 K"33.K70(81%':'>8

)%80183 +&?($3L&1775$()%801  + B#%  #(:%8  %# O ( #$%P % #$' $ OP"  B  %*  A?#% B% D (%($@%'()#$E;:8 ,31.35&8(8580>8

68 + $  &A  B% $'@ ( & B %  ($% $$@#%<($$%)$<8

) %8 /1  +" B '?%  ::% ( %#$   '  '$%((##?"'%'@?'I%()%'&?( % B%%('#'?'$)%80185 +8%':<I %%($%%:%&B)$?::##%%Q%$<& ((##?B)@%(:%('%'"(% B$'%%'%%$%$'#'B)%:'(' ('$%((##?8

28 > + ) %8 /1 8 3  +"  (% ( (#(  '$% ( (##?$%B(#$%:%$&$



450641770  -042-   ('('$% $<B)((##?"%" %%"I)D$%()('(BI#$%(:%(##?@8 )?%(('($'#$%"B(#$%%('A ((%()D?'$%((##?)$?(('B ;:8 , 31/  31 (8 0" 32 (8 1" 316  K03 (8 1" 313  5// (8 5@ %  ':'N :8 '?#% (  " $% % $'#$%()"=%$&'%",@? 3..7"$8115%112>8+(('('$%((##?( ('%"()$$%"&%%(57LI#$%( ##%M()$$%;%8/385 +>" (% % &?(' $ %%  (' (  $'(" LB)I  B  (' %  :  B) L?#% (':%: % ( ;  3..3 $8 356 (81NR%$@'8(/L&3..7S 3714//T(81>8

@> )%8 01 8 5  +" (  %  &? ($  3 L& 1775" $'&% B  (% I '$% % $% ;O&LUA%PN O $&P>    $<B(#$%#$'%%((##?%" (%"B$<&(-8 ('$&%R% %#$ % )#$E $%  I ) $'&8  )?% ( (' ( $$%"($'#$%"##%(%D%'? %(%&D $'$%( ;,,3..K$8.6K%,,3...$8KK11>8

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



450641770  -642-   R%#%<((%:(15&#@1773"$@' , $8/." @:'('""%A'B%(#<&%= :#'  L$(  B ( '  #%< ()#$Q% :'(' (%'%%#$)#$()(%(&%$& $$B&($%%&I$$%"@B# % %'?' I  $% (   %& I  $'(8   $$' B  $$% %  %%% ( (% #%' B  (%#% )D%('%B))@()'?#%%D$% (&(%"L%:()D#()$<($%()(% ; ,3163(81%':8%'>8

/8 '(%'##%(&((##?")%-I- ( (< B ) (% (#%% B  %% (  $&% $ R% &'"$(#%:L(B(:%; ,31.3.0(8181"316 KKK(85"3135/K(85@@"5//(85>8 %B ( %% % :$$' ( $'#$%"    ( :%"   ( )#$@%'$('$'%%($'(( (&#%8(##?%'$%'R%&##%()&<#% (  $'#$%   L (  :%N  L #B '?#%  (  (''$%%(%I$%(B%('( 0()%8/183: +; ,31.3.0(8181"31536 (80>8

 )"  :%  '%' $'  (% ( 10 $%#@ 1773" (% I B(&%( R%:D'&((##?%( '(8 $$%(L$(%'$"%(  ($% '?  #%< ( $'#$% B )$$B%8   %:%(''$%((##?B)(%(33('#@1775" % $ () ' $< &   ( (##? ; K $%#@ 1771" (% (  $@% ( )'%% ( %>"    ( ? %(&#%8  $*% ()%% $ L%:' B) ##% M      ( (##?" )%-I-(  ##% M  ##' I   $'#$%()"<?'%%$$@8&% (B)(&%?(('()'8

'?(D('%B$'<(%"%(#8





450641770  -242-  

!  -,2  !,+ -  +! -,



345   6  7   89 (*& -:

  5 

38 '&@8

 5

18 )(#%8

3. (# C%#' I & I  %  ## ( ,83)777"-- I %% ( ('$N

K8 :#  $% (  BC $&% :#  %  $'% R% (  (' ( 57 L (<  %:% $ $ ##(' ('  @ :'(' ( " +AVWA:B 6" 677K   "  % D#$8  ('  $% R% $?'8  #'# (%= > (B D%#%B('%('@%%$((' %%B'N @> D$ $ B #%:  %# $& (#( %% % ('N > $%  ?%   (  $'%%8 +  #'#  %% $  % ''#% '#''  %% > @> % > -("  @:'('($$%#%<BC (&('&@8#'#(#%#E ( $&" B % L%"  B  (' %%B' % C&$$ ( B'%'D$'('%;%8351"376%37/>8  ?::<  $'(%         ,, X+ X

$:#($'%R%%%:'D$%BCIC:::'(' ($?::



450641770