Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/500/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/500/2004 AI generated

Statutory Challenge Affirmance

Case Number ATAS/500/2004
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Court Costs Borne by public authority

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involved multiple challenges to various aspects of a statutory scheme, including challenges to provisions concerning notice requirements for certain actions, discovery limitations, and the application of specific time constraints, with the court ultimately affirming most aspects of the lower court's rulings. The court reasoned that the notice requirements were constitutionally adequate as they provided reasonably calculated notice under the circumstances, that the discovery limitations were a permissible exercise of legislative authority balancing efficiency with the need for relevant evidence, and that the applied time limitations were correctly interpreted and did not violate any substantive or procedural due process rights asserted by the challenging parties.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Statutory Challenge Affirmance: The court reasoned that the notice requirements were constitutionally adequate as they provided reasonably calculated notice under the circumstances, that the discovery limitations were a permissible exercise of legislative authority balancing efficiency with the need for relevant evidence, and that the applied time limitations were correctly interpreted and did not violate any substantive or procedural due process rights asserted by the challenging parties.

Keywords

AI generated
statutory right procedural limitations substantive requirements challengeable acts affirmation of jurisdiction rulings determining validity

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the court costs for the appeal proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the provision of legal aid.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

     

    &'()&*++, "&-++&*++,

"

 " .  " .    .

$ */ #$ *++,

-0  1 

  

  2222222222 3 45 56  6 5 3  7 8.  "



6$ 2222222222 3 45 56  6 5 3   "79



 

  " "  !9  : .. $  ; (' 5 36 -*'< )*)) 04 ))

!"

             !  "  #$% # $%&#

 :"

),  -.  )' !/ $01 23! 4 5 2  6 -72 $+1  2/  528 2   5!  2 2 5  27  2.   !  2 )99' 5 : :;;;;;;;;;;1 !  72 )9()1  2    !5/23 2221   :2 :;;;;;;;;;;1 !  72 )9'$1 2.22  87,

$,  2/  528 2   !  5 . 5 2 2!  72  5!7< 5"2 ! 5 :2 :;;;;;;;;;;   2.   2  2  2/     21 5 5! 4 ,

0,  -.  27  7 !"22 2"  ( "!72 $+,

+, =2  2 ! 5  2/  !  52  ! 2 3 :2 :;;;;;;;;;; 58  5  2   2 58   >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>    7 ! 2  $9 "!72 $+  $$A''+ ", &*,

6, >  /    2" 21  2/  !  ! 2!      5  2  2/ 5. B 7 B  2  52  : :;;;;;;;;;; B ))A0&' ", &*,  2  ( 2 $+1  5 2  ! !

272 ! B  ! 2   , > : :;;;;;;;;;;  "2 .   2  23 1 5    $+ 2 $+1   7   "C  "21 22 3  !   2 2  2  5!7<1 B 72     >>  >   > >1   D  999+'((1 5!7< ! D 6')9*,

 "

)% E  2 .72  =.2 2 -222 FE  ! ! 2"2!   2 2 !1 8  ) G $01  2/     2 F , )  ,  E,

%'()%$+ # 0%&#

  H  0*  $+1 5 1  2/ 22  2" F2#58 E    ! =""2  2 !  = , )  ,  1 2! 3  > 72 ! ! !!  72 2  = , )0)    2  2 .72 #   #,

/E @      3   2  2 2  2/  !1 4  2" 27  I

#   "2. 5   252 2"  =H , 1   252 2" = -. 5 3!2 = 2 !   J -.!1     2", = 2 !   J -.!  =!  B 4#2 3    K  252 2" < 72 45!  K 2  55  B  3 2 2 2.2 F @ 9(  $96 L M551 !2  2 22  2"1 +8 !2 21 )99)1 5, $+&  L N/J21 2 -222 527! 21 )9&)

5, 0)0  ,E,

# = 2 !   J -.!  7 32 3=2  2 3 5  < 3  2/ 572 42 F", M551 5, 2 , 5, $6)E, 1 2 55O  =58  4 3  72 1  H 572 1 B =2 =  2 - ! 5 72 2  2  52 23    H !  2 =  "24     =! 2  -.   >1  P   2  22 !   2 2 2    -22 2,

#  2 2 2  2  2 H  !! , >1 =  52  552 2  #2  / F", #@C2 / 1   J  >JQ2R1 7, 1 )99)1 5, )'&1   +0*E,  72  5  7 3= 2/  2  8. .!! =.2 7  1 5 5 228 3  !3  = 2 /72   !.2 -223 F @ ))$  0)0E,   2"    221 8  3  2! 523  =H  72 B 2 =42  = -22 2 32 " 2 52  ) G $0 !-B1    -. 2 21 22 3  -. 55! 1  ! ! !.28 !,

E  > 42 =""2  5!  L 7 =H   0*  $+ 2 -3=B  42 1 2  !. B 7!2"2  "2 ! B = , )0)     2 =2 2  ,

 >   -22 2 22  27 5!21    3= 2   2 5 22   2,  <  2  55 3  = , 6'   2 "!!   5 2 .!!  2   2 # #1  !  72.  ) -72 $01 J3   2 2   2/ 

%'()%$+ # +%&#

1 32     2  23      2   2,   252 2 !. "!! /2.    B .5     24   2   H 2 1   24 -3 B !5 2 B 87   27 22       , = 22 5 !5 B =42. 5! 5  2 "!! 3  !.2  .72  !!  >,

> = , )0) , )   1 S  2 ! /2  2/4 5  5 -.     272  5! L   8.  /1 =.2 21  -22 2   5!  T,    ! 2   )9')1  252 2  2  2  ! ! 5! ! 5  2! $1 2/!  2 I S 2/ 22  2"  2 2 ! 5        2 22  2"    K  2  5!72 T,

  2  2 =2 58    H 5225 3  2 22,  8. =2 5!  2 5   -.  !..   = 252 2   I  2 5 2 B  2 5!  2 2 !1 J2 231 !!.23  < ! 23   ,  -. 7 5 2 522 2  4  2   2,  1   H  0*  $+1  2!! 3  4   = , )0) , $    22 5  5 5 =  2/4        2 22  2" L 2  2 5! ! S  2/ T  2.2"2 S   2/ T, 1 = , )0) , $   5!2 3  2/ 22  2"  2 2 ! S    K  2  5!72 T, = 2 3 !2       24 22  2" 87 =  -22 2, 22 =2 5!  2 2 ! 5 B     3   S  T 2 H  32"2!1. 2 1 = 2 2! 2!,

  <     "2! 5  2 5!  2 J2 23  !!.23,  !   74 5!5 2 F:!2   2 U : # )9'*1 5, 66+ ,E 3  !.2   )9'*  2 !1 4 P !  -22 2 272  5! 42   5!7 B = , )0) , )   1  2/ 22  2" 2!5  572 4! 2",  2/ ! 2  2! B 5     2 ! U 2 =  1 22  1  V 32 72 B O       !22  !5  ,  =! 2 5 5 3 2 3  5 2 .!!1 2 5 3  2/ =! 2 7  !  5!  = 2/ 2,  ! 2 !72 3  2 22 5!2 72 /2 1    2   52 2 5 228 F52 2 52 21 45 VE, >  :!2   21 5, 66'1 S   < 8 72.!1  1  2 =    22 5!22!   2 2  ! ! !2!1  2    

%'()%$+ # 6%&#

-22 2 22  27 2 2   2!5 1   3  !5 2  5!  T,

8  ) -72 $1   ! ! 2  /!!"2 =  .!!  5! ,   22 7  -22 2 22  27 5!2  2  F , 6( E, 71  2 2  22   5!2  ! ! 45! !""2! F: )99'1 5, 9+0*E,   2  22 !   -22 2 =  5 -2 ! ! 2  1 2 5  @ 2 5  @ ,   72 5   2 2  32 2 5HJ!  !.2 1 33 ! 5 1  "2  5!    28 = 21 -3 B !7 B  22  1 B  -22 2 22  27 5!21  >  =,

>2 = 72 27 =2 5!  2    H  0*  $+1    >1 2 !.      22   5!21 < 52   J!  2#H 2 2 2  2,  = 2"  5 ! !  / 72! 5  !.2 ,

 7   32 5!81  ! 2  >  552 2     " B   2  2 .72,

=! 2  -.  < 5 2 ! ! ! 5  2/ "!!1   H  $' -72 $+1   2 .72  5 !1  )0 "!72 $+1  252 2 2 2 5   >  2!.   B 2 -. 2 21 1  =    =! 2  74 ,

$, A , $6   2 "!!   2/ 5.   5!7< 5"2 7221 727   2722 !  )' !/ )990 F@E1  !  72.  ) -72 $1 8.  5!    27,    !  -2    5  2   2 B 5 .    27 F , )$$  )$0 E1  -.  2  27 5!     A , '0 , ) 1 2 B 87  2/     2 52  ) G $01 2 1 58 3 A""2 2  ! ! 2 F , )+$ E1 4!  A""2  5 .   /   !  !5 2 2 ! 2! 5  -.  27,

0, > A , $$ @ F7   72. 52  ) -72 $E1    271  5  2   2 32   2.  5 .! "! 4  , )$$1 )$01 )+)  )+$ L   , 0 B 6 @ A5523 5 .2    B "! F, )E,  J3 -2 1  5  2   2 B 5 . 5 B  2""!    5  2   21 . !

%'()%$+ # (%&#

 72  2/ 5. 42  !7     271   5  2   21 . !  72  2/ 5. 42  !7      2  2. F",  , $+ @E,   1  -  B  5  2   2  B A72  2/ 5. 42      2  2.  2 !H      27 F @ )$&  $0*L @ )$9  +++E,

+, 4   = , ' , ) 1  2!   2 B = /2. 2 5  722 3 8  ) -72 32 2    B 3 2   $+ ,  = 8  3 8     3 =72  722  B H  !,

6,  =581  2/  528 2   !  5 . 5 2 2!   5  2   2 32 5 :2 :;;;;;;;;;;    ' 2 )99'

  ( "!72 $+,   5  51  2 B !  5  2  2/#5.  $$A''+ ", &*,  1   2 2  0 2 $+   >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>  1  5  2   2 B     2.  2,  "21    K :2 :;;;;;;;;;;  !  72 )9'$  = 8  5  B   72  722 3 8  ) -72 )99'1 B 72 3  2 7  2.1 2 < 2  2! 3      5  2   2 58    28 2  ! ! !  28 1  2 531 5    !  2.,

 2 2!     $$A''+ ", &* 5!  ))A0&' ", +* F  5 ))A0&' ", &*    ! ! 23! 5  4 5 2E1 2 55 2 B  >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>   7      5   5!7< 5"2  : :;;;;;;;;;; 58       >>  >   > >,

(, "! B  -251 52  - ! 2 5  5 . -3A   "   5  2   2    1  -2 27! /!!"222    5  2  2 B  2 !H  5 2      #2,  2 !H   !  4 22 !.  A , )$  A   5!7< 5"2 7221 727   2722 !  )& 72 )9&+ F $E    4 !. 21 2 2#2  5!2 F @  5/2!  0(%*$  )& -2 $0E,

%'()%$+ # '%&#

',  !  1 2 72 !. 3  >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>  .     B "!  4 22 !.   4 !. 21 2 2#2  5!21 8  ( "!72 $+1    = !  "  J -.!  5!  27,

WWW

%'()%$+ # &%&#

  ": . " .  " .    .

$

=56>6   ?  366 6  @% )(* .;A

), 72   >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>  1 !  2  72  722  :2 :;;;;;;;;;; B 7   5   5!7< 5"2  : :;;;;;;;;;; 58      >>  >   > >1 >   +1  "J1 N#&)0+ 2Q21   D  999+'((1 !7< ! D 6')9*1    ))A0&' ", +* ,

$, =272  B 71  5     1  2 !H  5 2     2! 1 8  ( "!72 $+ -3=   " L

0, =<    3  /2,

+, 2 3  5!  . 2 ,

6, "  5 2   3A 57 "     5! H   !2  0* - 8   2"2 2 5 52 ! !  2/ "!!  1 >JQ2RJ"32 (1 (+   1  2 452,  !2  5 H  5.!,  !2 2 I E 223 4  3 !22   !2 / 2  2  5   !22  3!L /E 45 5 3  2" 2  2 572      !22L E 5   2.      5!  , >2  !2   2 5  2 !!  !!!    E /E  E 2#1  2/ "!!    5 5     28    3A2 7 ! 27/,  !2    2   <  571 32  -2 1 22 3  !22  3!  A755  3   ! ! 45!2!   F , )0$1 )*(  )*& E,

 .""28I  !2  I

?X  Y :<  : 

 52 "  5! H   2"2! 4 5 2 22 3=B =""2 "!!   2 5  .""

%'()%$+