Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/457/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/457/2007 AI generated

Stipulated Right of First Refusal Revival Upon Conveyance

Case Number ATAS/457/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellate court reviewed a dispute concerning the interpretation and effect of prior stipulations regarding property interests and rights of first refusal, specifically addressing whether a party’s right of first refusal, previously established by stipulation, was revived after a conveyance to a third party, or whether a later conveyance rendered that right unenforceable. The court reasoned that the language of the stipulation clearly indicated that the right of first refusal was intended to be a continuing right, triggered upon any future conveyance of the property, and therefore, the subsequent transfer to the third party reinstated the party's right to exercise that option, as the right was not extinguished by the intermediate transaction but merely held in abeyance pending a new transfer.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Stipulated Right of First Refusal Revival Upon Conveyance: The court reasoned that the language of the stipulation clearly indicated that the right of first refusal was intended to be a continuing right, triggered upon any future conveyance of the property, and therefore, the subsequent transfer to the third party reinstated the party's right to exercise that option, as the right was not extinguished by the intermediate transaction but merely held in abeyance pending a new transfer.

Keywords

AI generated
transfer of property right to property right of repurchase reconsideration of an earlier decision right of pre-lease redemption of an easement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision governing the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           ()*+(+,,- #(*.-(+,,-

#

 #$ #     $

"/0  1 ' + / +,,-         !  "#$#%  ' % &'()!(   *!( +(',"    '   !-.(./  # 0&'()!(   *!( +(',"    ('  $$ $  $ $   112('34 !2' (21    %    $    $    ('(  &( 5'&6&(78839 "  %    $$       : */;   

       !  "  #$#% ! &' ' 

 <-= 

 2$#

/. '?6(8/?) '<>>= ' 56' (   &'!   )'    !   /@48 (  '  !  /@=@ ' !  (  </ ? ( /@37 A    B%'C.

 '!(   )(  !2  ( )  6! &'  !&D  <7 ?) ' <>>= ( 16! &'  ?6   )' :   ) '  ! &'  '(A&'(6'2'!(A*'(.<< 2!!''   5' &6   &'!)E &'2  )   ') )( ( )  (!/;!5'/@@8B%C.

<. ' ?6(  /3 !5' <>>4  /4F 15'  ' 5  &' F' (  '  ?6( 2'G  ( * !'! D!( '  $ .  ?6( )'()!2  ( 28/?) '<>>=(!(!(' *22   ' 5!<>2!)' '<>>;&'D!( &'(6.

8.  ' 5  !    (!  '    ( ((   &'!)E&  ('&!&' (   :' (( ) ': '(' 6 (('</? (/@37(8/?) ' <>>=.

7. $'' ' H  $$ $//)' <>>; ( (( &'F '

:'!( (22  !/ !5'/@@</7)5'<>>< &'(( : &(' 6&' # (38*/=72'.@>(!(!)'! A $$ $  $ $  .

' '' '  /8 ( <> )'  <>>;  %     $     $   6 '!6    $  '  2 '! ) ' ('2!'! A  %     $     $     ('(  &( 5'&6A9 "//)5'<>>4 (&'F*('! 2'?6( )'/4*=482'.'&'!(() ':   /' ? ( <>>8  8> &(5' <>>= ( &'! ! :  &'((   '(  !8/?) '<>>=!( (/>*@/32'.

//)' <>>; $$ $  $ $  2 '!:  &'((  :  &'  ' *!F) A />4*/>@ 2'. 7> (!'I(  8/ ?) '<>>=&' .

 &'((  (( :  &'  ' (     //;*><; 2'. 7> B/>4*/>@2'.7>J/>*@/32'.C.

=.  ( ( !(! ('  D &'(  (  ?'  (  '   :! :*A !2(*5')( *  /' <>>;''I(' (''((5.     -/>;>-<>>4 8-= 

4. ''' '<8)' <>>;' :! ' 5! '!&( 5'&6)'(&'F%     $$      .

;. *5*5?( ! 2 D!!(!6'!A?6'.

 $#

/. *'(.<= %('!) 6'/'?) '<>>>'F6&'!'  )'.':? ((&K''&'(( '(  A&'(6'B'(./<<(/<8  ) # C?6  )'&!(( *'(.;8./ 2!!''&'!)E&'2 <= ? /@3<BC (AF) ' 5(' &  /'L(<>>8 (&'F:*22 ' !(!(' B'(./7< CD!(' *22   &'(6 '  5   !  '!&'( (  !(' ! &'  ?6   )'.

<. $*'(.<<%B)(') 6'& /'?) '<>>>C   )'  &'((   '(  :  '(  ' 6 ( &'(6! 2'!( D'(./<</<8/7/(/7< M'(.8A= %*&& :( &'6 ((A('2!''B./C.'1:? (&'((  '( A&'(6'''&A 22!'('&'(( '( 6(!  ) '   5' &6 D (( !)((  (   )' (  &'(( '( 6(!) ' 5'&6D ((!)(( ( ' 6B2.'(.<7%C.'?( A  &'((   '(  ( A *) '   5' &6 D ((  (      ' 6  (!'I(   (   )' B % /<3  <8>M %/<@777C.

8.  *&F  ?6(   )' 2'G   16! *'  &'  !&D D (' :   ) '  ! &'  '  (&'(6!2'!(A*'(.<<%.

!'!&'( (   !(!&'! !(!.

7.  ?6( ' &'  ' 5  6' (     8/ ?) '<>>=!(!!'!D!( '$ &' ' 5&' F' ( (/3!5'<>>4.

=. $  ( &' (  &'((  :  &(  ' 6 &'  ' (  //;*><; 2'. 7>  (!'I( E( !?A !(! ! &'  ( (( &'!)E!2'.  ' (AD#!& ((=3*=/82'.;>B//;*><;2'.7>N<C.     -/>;>-<>>4 7-= 

4. 2'!( A  ?' &' &   ?' !(' ( &'  &'(6 ?:*(('2'(&'(( '( '? (  )'!5!!2   '((&'(( ' (A (!'I(&( '' ((# .  (!'I((!(D  !6*'(./< *''&'!)E&'2 )  ') )(( )  (!  /3 )'  /@37 B <C    (D '!6( '    #  ( &!' ' B %&5 !84-></3? (<>>8C.

;.  !(  ' &'G  &'!' !(( 6'( ( B'(. ;8 . <  ( 3@"./ '&'!'  ('( )/<&(5'/@3=C.







    -/>;>-<>>4 =-= 

   3#$2  #$ #     $

/. ) (  $$   $   $ $   A ('2!''  &(   '     =3*=/8 2'. ;> A  %      $$      2)' !  : (!'I(&( '  !'(F8/?) '<>>=?:*(('2'(.

<. KE((:5 .

8.  (:&'!'(6'( (.

7. 2'  &'(    :K &)( 2'' '' ('  &'!( ''I(   !   8> ?' F  ( 2 (  &'F  ' 5 2!!' B$1O P'12: 44>>7  C&') ''( F'' ( &5 2'!(D'(.3< 2!!'' ' 52!!'/; ?  <>>= B %CM  ! '  ''  (  :'    ( 2 ( E&')(&'(' 6('''(( 'M  ( I(' '!  ' 5 2!!' &' )  &(  &' )  !(' : D  (   *'(. 7<  %.  &'!( ''I( (  & F  &   ''( ):!E&') )(I('? (A*) .  6'22 F'  '! (N     ' #  9 ' Q  

& 2'&'!(''I((( 2 !D&'(   :KAK22 2!!' ' &'6'22

    -47<-<>>;