Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/547/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/547/2005 AI generated

Appeals Concerning Contractual Obligations and Remedies

Case Number ATAS/547/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court considered multiple appeals involving various financial transactions, primarily concerning contractual obligations and associated remedies across several different lower court rulings. The core of the reasoning across the decisions centered on the proper interpretation of the governing agreements, the application of relevant statutes to the established facts, and whether the lower courts abused their discretion in awarding damages or granting specific performance; ultimately, the appellate court affirmed, reversed, or modified the lower court judgments based on whether they correctly applied the law to the record evidence, often focusing on specific performance criteria, notice requirements, or contract formation elements.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 93, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeals Concerning Contractual Obligations and Remedies: The core of the reasoning across the decisions centered on the proper interpretation of the governing agreements, the application of relevant statutes to the established facts, and whether the lower courts abused their discretion in awarding damages or granting specific performance; ultimately, the appellate court affirmed, reversed, or modified the lower court judgments based on whether they correctly applied the law to the record evidence, often focusing on specific performance criteria, notice requirements, or contract formation elements.

Keywords

AI generated
contract interpretation specific performance financial transaction interpretation of the law civil and commercial matters award criteria

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 93
This provision is cited in order 2% as the basis for the decision concerning the appeal.
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision is cited in order 2% regarding the decision on costs.
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 93

This provision is cited in order 2% as the basis for the decision concerning the appeal.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in order 2% regarding the decision on costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                 !

"#$"%%%&' $(')'#*'

$+ #*+%, &%"%, $' +#%&' "&*,'

-  ./ 0   1  



2 3 45555555555  !"#$%&&&&&&&&&& !! ' #$'(!)$! !'' !"*!   +'##,'#$

!

"22*&' &%"%, $' ,6+#%&'7*%8,*$*'!# $' -./(0*

        

   851228  

'% 2*

2% "! "%&&&&&&&&&& '   2.96  '' *$ #: # *! '!';!4*!5666%$'##<= )#,''< '  '#>*?#*!'!';! ><4 *!5666 #)!$ !'*#:<'$$2629 *!5666 !<'$5/*!5666 @'@$2/ $ 5666% :!' !'  (   # !; ! -<>, '*0! A$$ '' ! $ 0 -#!$ #-)'B !; $',  !),C AB% ! ! # !&&&&&&&&&& #5.$5666 &&&&&&&&&&#5/@5666&&&&&&&&&&#22@*!. *!5662C%

5% ##3B'*!!5662:!'#!'B!$!(:BB# :!8*#'A8 !0: C!$ %*; #   5*!5666 # :# #:! !  *D!   #'*D!  *! :!  <! $>! B!   ! )   #' !% !   # B!    ! )   * $$ ; #: ! !'#! (   A *!  #  0>   @$;C ! >!A# !C !!!A#$ 0C !!! !!#;##<#, !*!!$! <; !0:D!*' !0D!')%

7% 25@5662:!'#' '#$## ! !0#:  *(:!#:!%

9%  ! #  #BB' $!  '  "#$ %&&&&&&&&&&  #'#'#B! !'#!(#$'>$##;#%

3% :! ! E&&&&&&&&&& F% %  ';  #*  27 @ 5662 ! :#:*;#G #:#<#:$#26+/H/B!%93  %

4% ##5/I5662"!&&&&&&&&&&!><'! ' !$ $'# # :J=  # K)  ';  ! ! # * ( #$ ! :$'>$ #   # ;%   ! ' , :!' ' #' # ! #*,#% !#$ ' * $$#' # !*) ! $'>!  >;  #)0$  # ; $ !  #< # G    *;% : # # G   @B $   #: ;' !'# #   A !' #: *; >D  >C  # $  ' #  0 ! :!'% F:!><'! $ #-$ $># #$;! # @! ' <L  A7 @! ! $  $$$C  $'>$ ! !$;#',%



1234215667  871228   /%   !!! # 5. I 5662  ! &&&&&&&&&&  ' , :!' < ' ( :J=  # K) #   27 *$;! 5666  ! #: $#!>, <!,'#! ' ( #$ !!!'>0!MN8#%

H%  # # 26  $;! 5662 :! ! >''! #:'!' G$     #!' ( :!'  B! !   '!, BB'#*#;#:$#2+666B!%

.% ! !!! # 29  $;! 5662 "#$ &&&&&&&&&&    ' !$ $'# # K)  B!$' :  , :!' ' < ' ( :J=  # K) #   27 *$;! 5666  ,: * #  !! ( #$' *BB'#!*)#: !$B#:-!  #< ! !$! ( :!' # !'#! 8$D$ (    # !*!    #:$%  I #  $'>$ :'* ( 25+59.B!%

26% ! !' # 72 ;! 5662 :   !-' ( :!'  ! 0! #:*#'  ,:  ! $  # #>!' >!* ( !! # 4 *!5662%

22% ##57*$;!5662:! !E&&&&&&&&&&F% %#!'(+!'  B! ! $$ + # G  #+ *;  #+ #<#+$#26+534B!%.3  %

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



1234215667  891228   +! ! E&&&&&&&&&& F% %  3H6 B!% #  B! # +! !    FR&&&&&&&&&&%

27% ! $$ # 26 @*! 5662 +   !#' ( +!' ( ! # $- )!  !  <!> # B! #+$'>$ #  #< ( <!#9+444B!%43#*#+! !E&&&&&&&&&&F% %(<! #3H6B!%#*#+! !    FR&&&&&&&&&&%

29% ! $$# 29@*!5665+ !-'(+!' !$ !D #+ B ! $ #+ < !' !< '#  # ;!!0! '!#%

23% ! !#55*!5665!F  O#+J= #K)  $' , +!' * '@!' # +';$ # 2. *$;! 566253$!5665##!!(#$%

24% !!!!#72$5665"#$&&&&&&&&&& ! #+#'#!)) '(+ ,$'>$#   # #<  # G  ' # ; !  !! ( #$ # :!'%

2/% ! !!! # / @ 5665 "! &&&&&&&&&& !<8 # :!8B!$B!$'+ ,++'!#<L+!'B# *'!B!+$'>$#+#<*G *;#+!'#' @B'   $   #  #   #  #$ # ) !)#+ !#<# #+!'#+! !%F  # ' +'  $   @#    '$, $ ;P';,#;G ) ';!   !D!# '<# #+!'%! * #  #BB' ( +<;!  (  #' !  ' $ '!B #  BB!!  #< # G    *; #  $D$   , + !'# !# ;%  )  '!,  #* ;>!$ D! '>'##<%

2H% ##23@5665+!'#''#'%

2.% !#'#2HB'*!!5667+ B!$'$$#26@*! 5665 ! ,  !  <!>  B! #+$'>$ #  #< ( <!#9+444B!%43#*#+! !E&&&&&&&&&&F% %(<! #3H6B!%#*#+! !    FR&&&&&&&&&&%

56% ! !!! # 2/ $! 5667 +'  # +!'  B!$'   (  #''>,$!(,'!';! *  #' !  *!   !#! )  % B #  !$! # !! ( #$#$'>$#+ !$+'!'*'''!% $ 



1234215667  831228    #  !    #   # ; )  # +$ ;' # :!' #+!  ;>!   # #< * *;  G  * '' $'>' #   !'# # + !$%  $ # 22+3H4 B!% .3 S'!' ? /36 B!%P  ! ? 26+534 B!% .3P !!> ? 3H6 B!% A5955OOCT#*D! !<!> !+!8*#'%

52% ! #' !   # 3 @ 5667 +  B!$  #' # 2HB'*!!5667! ',+* !<!>,$B!'! #+$'>$(<!#3+594B!%43% !!BB#+! !# OF "  # 22 #'$;! 5662 ,  ! '' BB  #  *##;?#' =#;>!$ #+; # #< !  ', ' #+ < # #< #' = # ;#% ! ! +'#'#+!'+'>>!*'#';*$;!5662*#ID! < ' # 2. *$;! 5662  53$!5665%   ) +* '$ ! "! &&&&&&&&&& !<8 # !8B!$  /@ 5665 +' #'!$ ,::'+'  !' '#*! !! ( #$ # +!' ' *>;  *>' ( !$%   !*)! ! !B$$#+!'(*B!$!  !';+  !' #  )!0!#$ '#+#', !, !%

55% ! !!! # 9 @ 5667 +'  # +!'  !! !  #'  !0 #  $$  # !!  $0! #+!8*#' ! $ '%    (  !  <!> #  ' # B! #+$'>$#*#;#+$#22+3H4B!%.3* '!D ( 3U #0  52 I 5662  ! ! # +$; +!>$ #'* '# #2/$!5667%

57%   !'  # 24 @ 5667 +    !@ # !! + !'B'!'! !#OF " #22#'$;!5662%

59%  2! I 5667    '' !$ #+BB  !;  # !#0!$ '%

53%   !' , # 55 I 5667 :'  # !!  ! ' ,: B !'#! ) $'>$ >) *  # # !! ( #$ #  $!% ! '@!#+'#'#$!+'  !'*; $$ # !B!$ #   # ;   >>!*  * !  $B # !B # +  # !#!  <!>  I # !*)% B B #  !#! $  #   +!' $ ' ! #I  #' ! ! *! ! ,  B>! # ) )>  $'>$!''% #0!'! !!  !' !! #'>'#!!%



1234215667  841228   54% # ,#2H $;!5667+  !'#!$# !''#'!!#%

5/% ##$ ! !# !:#* !; # '24$!5663%"#$%&&&&&&&&&&) ',$!' !*($( !$0!<  !*! 5662%  :' ! !# $  ,   ! A#<  C :'  # '  <#  # :!'%  :*   !B!$!#;)!$ ,#V!W  !'*   !;0$ # %  BB  '$ !  G  :'  !'8'##;%!'#!*<  '$ !  G  ' #'@( ( !  ' !'* ! #  ! ,    D! !B!$'   # #<%  ' # ; ,  G   #  $D$  ,  #<   *; !'*!#' $<!%  !'',:*$;!5662 :' # ' #  $! :' >>!*'P  * '' < ' @,: $! 5665##!!#'BB(#$%

5H%  ! ! !   #$ # :!'  '' BB'  # # 2H $! 5663%  $! #   # ;  A* ;>!  *;C # #*#;A*#<*;G C'' !,# <#)%

5.% !!!!#55$!5663:' #:!'!$ !;#'  # !$%

76% !!!!#54*!5663#!0! !'#%

72% ! !!! # 26 $ 5663 :   !'' , !  B! # :! !    F R&&&&&&&&&&  * '' !  <!>   !;;'  B! !B  !!>%   #* # :! ! E&&&&&&&&&&F  X7*''!$;!'9+77/B!%), B!@!/4U#  ,! !'#9+444B!%45%

75% !!!!#54$5663 !;#'B!$' !#$# :) !<#,,:< !%

77% ! !!!#/$5663:' #:!'#$#' (,:,  '$! '(:) !%

79% ! !!! # 26 @ 5663 :   '>$ ' ,: ,  '$!$%







1234215667  8/1228    

2%   >* ! :!> @#! # 55 *$;! 2.92 AC  '' $#B'   ' #0  2! I 5667  !;  # ! $ '#3@># !'#*8 !'#3 ' 24@>!A!%2%!34 C%

F(:#:'#24@>! ! !;B'#'! 5/@*!5669A O276264C!# >*# '27B'*!!  # !!!> !$ !;#!  # '>!  ! ( ! @> !  # : # :'#*)@>!%

5% B!$'$ ( :!% 7 % 7 # #  !!   !# *:!'*>!# ##* $$# !!  $0! #:!8*#'  '' !$ #:BB  !; #!,! $0!#:!8*#'$$AB%!%34C%$ '# !;#''; !@>!##: 0%

7% B'#'!! !>''!##!#!#4;! 5666A C!' *>!2!@*!5667!Y$#B #$;!# '>##$#!%F! $'! #*!,#!+ ,#D!!<'($0! # ! ,!0> ;*>!$$Z  B @!#,$ #'!$   !# A O 25/  94/ #% 2P 254  274 #% 9;   !'B'!C%  !*<   , !  !'#!(#'B#!0>!!!!*#!+ , !'!*#0@!#!'*>!A O22/.7#%4;P225 746 #% 9P  "  2..H [ 7/ % 724 #% 7;C% + !,  !'#! !#  !0  2! @*! 5667 #*  !;  $ '$0!#+!!'> !* !0># !'#!#  !# # !'#! ##BB'! '$#B' ! % B#B #'!$ :' !#  5662  #  #   B'#'! ! :!8*#' # 2. @ 2.3.  #  !# #:  ! '#!!*>!(#%

9%  !; # '   ! ,  !! !@'  $    #B!$!,!*;B!$'$(:!%46 %

3% F+!%H !'*#$'#+*#'$$ #! ) $! # !'#  ,  '!  # ! ( !';! !  '#>(+$'!!(*>!#!(B*!!+>% #!  #'!$' B##!'#+*' !;;A%2C% !'



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

4% +!' #$!* # ! #+BB  B #'!$ +8(8#! ! ##' #+ #!0>##!A O22/ 542 #% 7 % 547P %  J  !#! # FL*!<!>!< ! 2..9 %  % 97HC%  +#$!   #+!#!  ! $ '$! !,  '> # !   ''$ !! # #! !,0!   $! A O 22/  5H5 #% 9 % 5H7 P  "  2.H3 %596#%9P J %%C%='@>,#0!, B BB$$'#' !*-!(+#$! ! $ '$ #+!  !'#! 8$D$ (   ! $ '$!A " 2..7 %274C%

/% F!;#!%52 29 5" :  !<!>B! #+$'>$ #  #< ( <! # 9+444 B!% 43  #* # +! ! E&&&&&&&&&& F% %  ( <! # 3H6 B!%  #* # +! !    F R&&&&&&&&&&%  # :'  # !!   !$;!$#22+3H4B!%.3*!!B!$#:* # ; S'!' ? /36 B!%P  ! ? 26+534 B!% .3P !!> ? 3H6B!%A5955OOCT%

 * #  :!! # #'!$! , '  !*) #:$'>$ #  # ; '!   $ I)%  OF "   :  !')BB#:$'>$# #;#' =#;>!#' =#;#$ #:



1234215667  8.1228   #< $   # B ,  G  ) ' ; ! :!'% :' #!!$,(,$! * ! )!B!$'!'#8,$ !#'@( !!*'#: !G !!$(#;8#)0$  # ; *  #: #< #: *;  # G   , !Y '>$ #!!>#:'!,#',%

:!! !;#' !!#! !!  ,  G  ) ' !  '! ! D! ; ! :!' $  #: *;!* >A#!*;$!?93 $C%  ' # @B' #:! # #)0$ G %  #< ' '>$ # ;  !! ,  * B!<!  !  #  ;>!%  # ( #'B # :* #:  '  :  :'  ;  !; #  #'!$! , (   #:$'>$   '$, ' !'' ,  $ #  ;>! !  B! # :'  # !! :   ''$ #'!$ !  <) # !B!$%

 !;#'$$!#) !!<B,:'*, '   #:$'>$ # '  <#  # :!'  $ I% B,, !*#!*!$!(:) ! !! !,#$!Z !%







1234215667  8261228   # &' "*2 ,' #*+%, &%"%, $' +#%&' "&*,'



  93 

2% '!!!!*;%

0 

5% !#  ) ! :) ! - ! $ # #'!$! , '  #:$'>$##;# '<# #:!'$ I  !0 :D! !' #   ''$  A$$ * # : !$)$# \C%

7% B("!&&&&&&&&&&!<(0*%

9% <!>:) !#!' #!),*?

 % #;$ !8!!*'#: !#G ]

 ;%  G  !8  D! ' (   # ;# )A,  '' #' '!#!B!$ !!$<(*!C]

 % !'''<'I#!B!$#:!!*'#: ! #G ##;]

 #%  !'# $ !8 #'@( * !B!$  !!*' #: ! # G ]

 % :$'>$##;##<*G *; A#' =#;>!#' =#;##:#<#G  !**;C'8 ;]

 B%  , $  B!% $L8*  !*) #'!  ! C   #!!' ;]

 >%  !*) !8 ''  *  '$, , ) !,' A!B!$ # !'#  #)0$  # ; *  #: #< #:*;#G #!!>#:'!,#',C]

 <% '<' *L8*) ,! !,8$B8*!*#*!>88 #'$ !OF " #! !#22#'$;!5662]

 % O!!$!, ! %



1234215667  8221228   3% B)#'72I5663 !!$! !;#'! ! #:) !%

4% B!$  ! #  ,: * B!$! !! !  !' !!D #  #' # 26 @! #0  B !  !$$#' #!'  !; B'#'! # ! F<ML!<B, 4 4669     ! )$ !%  #'   D! !>'%  $'$! #? C #,! )$,#'!!#'!;! ##' ,'P ;C ) ! ! , $B  $ *! #$#!  ! #'P C !!  >!   #  ! !'% F  $'$!     ! ''$ '$'!'  ! C ;C  C 8#  !;B'#'!#! !! !!$0!!!!,: #*!#'!!!!*;%$'$!#!!$!!$- # !* , ! @  ,  #' ,'  :*  # ,'') '#'!!A!%27526426HC%  >!BB!?  !'#? G# $! #'            !'!8@!? O!'#'!,!      

 B!$# !'!!DB') !,:(:BBB'#'! #! !>!BB





1234215667