Legislator European & Swiss Legal Corpus
Încheierea nr. 3880/2013 Dismissed AI-structured

Încheierea nr. 3880/2013 — Petition for transfer of case dismissed as moot after prior resolution

Case Number Încheierea nr. 3880/2013 (ICCJ_99828)
Court / Authority
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Jurisdiction Romania — Case Law (RO)

Decision Summary (Facts, Holding & Outcome)

AI-structured

The High Court of Cassation and Justice dismissed the petition for case transfer submitted by a commercial plaintiff, upholding the procedural validity of the case's assignment to the Galați Court of Appeal. The dispute concerned a request to transfer a specific civil case from its assigned appellate court, but the court found the transfer legally improper because the proceedings had already been concluded with a decision on September 16, 2013, and the respondent had already filed a formal response and evidence in the record. The decisive legal basis for the dismissal was the principle that a motion for case transfer cannot be granted once the judicial process has reached a final resolution or when the procedural steps required for a valid transfer, such as the active pendency of the core dispute, are no longer met, rendering the petition moot.

Headnote / Official Regeste

AI-structured
The High Court of Cassation and Justice dismissed the petition for case transfer submitted by a commercial plaintiff, upholding the procedural validity of the case's assignment to the Galați Court of Appeal. The dispute concerned a request to transfer a specific civil case from its assigned appellate court, but the court found the transfer legally improper because the proceedings had already been concluded with a decision on September 16, 2013, and the respondent had already filed a formal response and evidence in the record. The decisive legal basis for the dismissal was the principle that a motion for case transfer cannot be granted once the judicial process has reached a final resolution or when the procedural steps required for a valid transfer, such as the active pendency of the core dispute, are no longer met, rendering the petition moot.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment — Încheierea nr. 3880/2013

Procedura de citare este legal îndeplinită.

Magistratul asistent face referatul cauzei și arată că, potrivit programului de evidență informatizată a instanțelor, dosarul a cărui strămutare se solicită a fost soluționat la 16 septembrie 2013 și că intimata SC R.C.R. SRL a depus la dosar întâmpinare, însoțită de copiile unor înscrisuri.

Înalta Curte acordă cuvântul asupra cererii de strămutare.

Procurorul pune concluzii de respingere a cererii de strămutare.

Analizând cererea,

ÎN NUMELE LEGII

D I S P U N E

Respinge cererea formulată de petenta SC A.S.B.I.E. SRL privind strămutarea pricinii care face obiectul Dosarului nr. 3239/91/2013* al Curții de Apel Galați.

Definitivă.

Pronunțată în ședință publică, astăzi 19 septembrie 2013.