Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
VSRS Sklep VIII DoR 233/2021-6 ECLI:SI:VSRS:2021:VIII.DOR.233.2021.6 Generato dall'IA

Supreme Court dismisses review application as legal questions lack importance for legal certainty or uniform application of law.

Numero d'incarto VSRS Sklep VIII DoR 233/2021-6
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Slovenia (SI)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Supreme Court of Slovenia rejected the applicant's request to permit a review of the final labor court judgment. The applicant argued that lower courts misapplied provisions regarding the calculation of excess workers in redundancy programs, specifically concerning organizational unit adjustments and leadership roles. The court determined that these specific legal questions were not significant enough to warrant a review for the sake of legal certainty or uniformity.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

ZPP 367.a ust. 1; ZPP 367.c ust. 2: A review application is denied when the legal questions raised do not concern issues of legal certainty, uniform application of law, or the development of law, as the lower court's decision does not deviate from established Supreme Court practice.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
review application labor law redundancy program excess workers legal certainty uniform application labor contract termination cessazione dell'attività lucrativa

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
ZPP 367.a ust. 1
ZPP 367.c ust. 2
Generato dall'IA
Sodba VIII Ips 461/2008
Appeal dismissed; employer lawfully terminated employee due to business reasons and offered better position to qualified colleague.
Sodba VIII Ips 78/2013
Supreme Court dismisses appeal regarding termination of employment contract for business reasons against an invalidly aged employee. The court rules that the employee did not meet the age threshold for special protection at the time of termination. The employer's delay in processing the employee's temporary inability to work was deemed beneficial to the employee and did not constitute an illegal reinstatement of the employment relationship. The appeal is rejected based on the specific provisions of the Employment Relations Act. The court clarifies that the termination of the employment contract for business reasons is valid, and the employer's delay in processing the employee's temporary inability to work was deemed beneficial to the employee and did not constitute an illegal reinstatement of the employment relationship. The appeal is rejected based on the specific provisions of the Employment Relations Act. The court clarifies that the termination of the employment contract for business reasons is valid, and the employer's delay in processing the employee's temporary inability to work was deemed beneficial to the employee and did not constitute an illegal reinstatement of the employment relationship. The appeal is rejected based on the specific provisions of the Employment Relations Act. The court clarifies that the termination of the employment contract for business reasons is valid, and the employer's delay in processing the employee's temporary inability to work was deemed beneficial to the employee and did not constitute an illegal reinstatement of the employment relationship.
Sodba VIII Ips 132/2013
Court dismisses appeal confirming business reason for dismissal via external outsourcing without formal job elimination.
VDSS Sodba Pdp 509/2018
Appeal dismissed; employer failed to prove business necessity for termination due to employee's prior knowledge of poor performance.
VDSS Sklep Pdp 332/2022
Appeal allowed: dismissal of termination due to excessive overtime without proper work organization review.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

Predlog se zavrne.

[JEDRO]

Zastavljena vprašanja niso pravno pomembna.

[OBRAZLOŽITEV]

1. Sodišče prve stopnje je zavrnilo tožbeni zahtevek za ugotovitev nezakonitosti redne odpovedi pogodbe o zaposlitvi iz poslovnega razloga z dne 21. 11. 2019 ter da tožnici delovno razmerje pri toženki ni prenehalo in še traja.

2. Sodišče druge stopnje je pritožbo tožnice zavrnilo in potrdilo sodbo sodišča prve stopnje.

3. Zoper pravnomočno sodbo sodišča druge stopnje je tožnica vložila predlog za dopustitev revizije glede vprašanj:

- ali sta sodišči druge in prve stopnje pravilno uporabili 89. člen ZDR-1 ter 98. do 103. člen ZDR-1, s tem, ko sta šteli, da v primeru, ko je s programom presežnih delavcev pri delodajalcu v določeni organizacijski enoti predvideno zmanjšanje števila zaposlenih za tri osebe, ni potrebno upoštevati zmanjšanja števila zaposlenih v isti organizacijski enoti, čeprav do takega zmanjšanja pride v času izvajanja programa presežnih delavcev;

- ali je sodišče druge stopnje pravilno uporabilo 89. in 101. člen ZDR-1, ko je štelo, da se pri ugotavljanju prenehanja potrebe po delu v programu presežnih delavcev ugotovljenega določenega števila presežnih delavcev, upošteva zmanjšanje potreb po delu zgolj za delavce na primerljivih delovnih mestih, ne pa tudi za vodjo, čeprav je vodja organizacijske enote vključen v izračun vseh delavcev organizacijske enote.

4. Predlog ni utemeljen.

5. Vrhovno sodišče na podlagi prvega odstavka 367.a člena Zakona o pravdnem postopku 1 (v nadaljevanju ZPP) dopusti revizijo, če je od odločitve vrhovnega sodišča mogoče pričakovati odločitev o pravnem vprašanju, ki je pomembno za zagotovitev pravne varnosti, enotne uporabe prava ali za razvoj prava preko sodne prakse. Vrhovno sodišče dopusti revizijo zlasti v naslednjih primerih: če gre za pravno vprašanje glede katerega odločitev sodišča druge stopnje odstopa od sodne prakse vrhovnega sodišča; če gre za pravno vprašanje, glede katerega sodne prakse vrhovnega sodišča ni, še zlasti, če sodna praksa višjih sodišč ni enotna; ali če gre za pravno vprašanje, glede katerega sodna praksa vrhovnega sodišča ni enotna.

6. Vrhovno sodišče ugotavlja, da pogoji iz prvega odstavka 367.a člena ZPP niso izpolnjeni, zato je na podlagi drugega odstavka 367.c člena ZPP zavrnilo predlog za dopustitev revizije.

7. Odločitev je bila sprejeta soglasno v senatu, navedenem v uvodu tega sklepa.

1 Ur. l. RS, št. 26/99 in nadaljnji.