Patent law ruling: Patent value does not increase solely due to expiration of utility model protection. Outcome: Appeal dismissed, case remanded. Key issue: Calculation of inventor's share in economic effects.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court dismissed the appeal against the appellate court's decision awarding the inventor a reduced share of economic profits. The lower courts incorrectly held that the patent's value increased because the utility model protection expired, allowing free use of the design. The Supreme Court ruled that the patent's inventive contribution remains constant regardless of the utility model's status, and the inventor's share must be calculated based on the combined effects of both projects during their joint application period.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAUstawa z dnia 19 października 1972 r. o wynalazczości, art. 98a ust. 3; § 10 ust. 2 i 3 zarządzenia Ministra z dnia 31 stycznia 1986 r.: Wygaśnięcie prawa ochronnego na wzór użytkowy stosowany razem z opatentowanym wynalazkiem nie ma wpływu na wysokość udziału tego wynalazku w efektach uzyskiwanych w rezultacie jego zastosowania ustaloną w okresie stosowania obu projektów łącznie.