Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
IECCA 82 ECLI:IE:CCA:2006:82 Generato dall'IA

Court refuses certificate for Supreme Court appeal on fresh expert evidence admissibility in criminal retrial.

Numero d'incarto IECCA 82
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Irlanda (IE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Court of Criminal Appeal refused a certificate to allow an appeal to the Supreme Court regarding the admission of fresh expert evidence. The applicant argued that the trial court erred in rejecting medical evidence proving no rape occurred, noting he had previously declined to use such a defense. The court held that the specific facts of this case did not meet the high threshold of exceptional public importance required for a certificate.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Section 29 of the Courts of Justice Act 1924; A certificate for a Supreme Court appeal on a point of law of exceptional public importance is refused where the facts do not demonstrate a need for a ruling on the admissibility of fresh evidence in criminal appeals.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
fresh evidence admissibility exceptional public importance criminal appeal certificate expert medical evidence retrial defense strategy

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
section 29 of the Courts of Justice Act 1924
pursuant to section 29 of the Courts of Justice Act 1924 certifying a point of law of exceptional public importance allowing
Justice Act 1924
pursuant to section 29 of the Courts of Justice Act 1924 certifying a point of law of exceptional public importance allowing

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

Appeal No. 240/2003

McCracken J.

Lavan J.

Murphy J.

BETWEEN:

THE DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

RESPONDENT

.v.

THOMAS O’REGAN

APPLICANT

Judgment of the Court delivered on the 16th day of June 2006 by Mr. Justice McCracken

The court has already delivered judgment on the 27th April 2006 in relation to the substantive application in this matter. In

that judgment the court refused to allow new evidence to be adduced. The court has now been asked to grant a certificate

pursuant to section 29 of the Courts of Justice Act 1924 certifying a point of law of exceptional public importance allowing

an appeal to the Supreme Court.

It is suggested by the applicant that the point of law to be certified is:-

“Whether in all the circumstances this honourable court was correct in refusing to admit the fresh expert

evidence sought to be adduced by the applicant, to the effect that as a matter of certainty the rape did not

occur as alleged by the complainant; and that as a matter of probability, no rape occurred; and in particular:-

(a) whether the criteria for deciding whether to admit fresh evidence to this honourable court includes a requirement that

the evidence was not available to the applicant prior to the trial; or whether the said issue is merely an important factor

in considering the requirements of justice in all the circumstances of the case.

(b) Where an application is made to adduce in this honourable court fresh evidence that was available prior to the trial,

is it necessary to assert or establish unreasonable, irrational, illogical or negligent conduct of the defence of the trial?

(c) Where counsel representing the applicant in the trial were not aware of the nature of, or potential impact of the said

expert evidence; and where the said evidence was likely to have led to an acquittal, must the circumstances be regarded

as so exceptional as to require the admission of fresh evidence on appeal?”

While there have been a number of judgments in the Court of Criminal Appeal dealing with the admission of fresh evidence

on the hearing of an appeal, it is strongly urged on behalf of the applicant that such decisions are not always consistent and,

correctly, that the question has never been considered by the Supreme Court. However, as stated in the earlier judgment,

the Supreme Court has set out the principles applicable to the introduction of new evidence in that court in civil actions.

The new evidence sought to be adduced in the present case is the evidence of two expert medical witnesses. It is not the

evidence of factual matters, but evidence of opinion to be given by experts. In considering whether to grant a certificate the

court must have regard to the background of the case itself.

In the present case there have already been two trials of the applicant, the first having been aborted at a late stage. On both

occasions it was open to the applicant to obtain expert evidence such as is now sought to be admitted, and to conduct a

defence based on medical evidence. In both cases the decision was made not to defend the case on that basis. This decision

was a considered one, taken after assessing the possible damage to the applicant’s case, and it appears to this court that it

was a very reasonable decision to have taken in the circumstances.

The court accepts that it might be desirable to have a Supreme Court ruling on the question of the admissibility of evidence

on a criminal appeal, but that is not the test. It is for the applicant to show that the ruling sought is on a point of law which is

of exceptional public importance. It is the view of this court that the facts of the present case would not bring it within that

category. This court rejected the applicant’s appeal primarily on the basis that he should not be allowed a retrial in which he

would put forward a defence which he had decided not to rely on in his earlier trial. In the view of this court the

circumstances of this case do not raise a matter of exceptional public importance in relation to the admission of new

evidence and accordingly the court refuses the certificate.

DPP v Thomas O’Regan