Administrative court dismissed water authority's claim for pre-approval damages when no prior demand was made.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Administrative Court of Finland dismissed the water authority's request to investigate compensation for damages occurring before a water usage permit was granted. The authority argued for compensation under Section 8(2) of Chapter 11 of the Water Act, but the claimant had never formally demanded such compensation prior to the permit application. The court ruled that without a prior demand, the water authority lacks the legal basis to initiate an ex officio investigation into these damages.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAVesiL 11 luku 8 § 2 mom; VesiL 16 luku 21 §: The water authority cannot ex officio investigate compensation for pre-permit damages unless a formal demand for compensation was previously made by the affected party.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
Kun vahingonkärsijä ei ollut tehnyt luvanhakijaan kohdistuvaa,
vesilain 11 luvun 8 §:n 2 momentissa tarkoitettua vaatimusta
lupaa edeltävien vahinkojen korvaamisesta, vesioikeus ei saanut
ottaa sellaista korvauskysymystä viran puolesta tutkittavakseen.
Vesioikeuden päätöksestä poistettiin sitä koskeva
ratkaisuosa.
VesiL 11 luku 8 § 2 mom
VesiL 16 luku 21 §
Vastaava ratkaisu vesilain 11 luvun 8 §:n 3 momentin soveltamisesta
VYO:n päätös T:156/1993, A:10.9.1993
KHO:n päätös T:190, A:19.1.1994: Ei valituslupaa