Administrative court limits threat to work at applicant's cost to mandatory actions only, excluding optional ones.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Administrative Court of Finland modified the water authority's order regarding a diversion project, restricting the threat of cost imposition to mandatory actions only. The applicant argued that threatening them to perform optional measures, such as installing a specific pipe, was legally impermissible. The court ruled that a threat to impose costs cannot be used to compel a party to undertake an action they have a right to but no duty to perform.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAVesiL 6 luku 3 § 1; VesiL 6 luku 8 §; VesiL 20 luku 7 §: A threat to impose work costs on a party cannot be directed at optional measures where the party has a right but no duty to act.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
Vesilain 20 luvun 7 §:ssä tarkoitettua uhkaa siitä, että hakija
tai lautakunta saa teettää työn laiminlyöjän kustannuksella,
ei voida asettaa sellaisen vaihtoehtoisen toimenpiteen
suorittamiseksi, johon velvoitetulla on oikeus, mutta ei velvollisuutta.
Sen vuoksi vesiylioikeus muutti ojitusasiassa
ojan ennalleen avaamiseen tai tietyn suuruisen putken asettamiseen
liittyneen teettämisuhan koskemaan vain ojan ennalleen
avaamista.
VesiL 6 luku 3 § 1
VesiL 6 luku 8 §
VesiL 20 luku 7 §
Lainvoimainen