Court dismissed enforcement application against a foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court dismissed the enforcement application filed by a creditor against a debtor domiciled in Estonia. The creditor argued that the foreign judgment should be recognized and enforced despite the debtor's lack of presence in Estonia. The court ruled that the Estonian courts lacked jurisdiction over the original dispute and that the foreign judgment violated the principle of mutual trust, thus refusing enforcement.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: A foreign judgment cannot be enforced in Estonia if the Estonian courts lack jurisdiction over the original dispute or if the judgment violates fundamental principles of Estonian law.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
! " #$#%& '$ & ()'
' %& %$ * + % & + &
& , &+ $ + & $ - & !"#$ . / ' + 0& $ - & & / 1111111111111111111112 %1111111111111 $ %& %$ * + ! $% " & '((((((((((() *+,*-,./, -0/-12.. 3
- ') , 4 15 6 .
, 4 1+ - 7
3
(((((((((((((((((((((8
3
8 3 8
3
3
6 38
3 08 0 3 66
! 3 , 41+ . 7
-')3
9
3 9
3 9 3
3
-' ) , , & 6 3 , ! ,& &$ ,, &3& & 4+ & % &" ,, &- 3,&$ " 0 & 3,&$ 0 $ % $ ,, & & % $43%& %
: $%:!"!$%!; % & ))%
% 5 !6
&+
"
67!!" & 8 +!30!0",+ 4 &%6 " 9% $ + 8 95 + ! & & % % 4 &% !! ! 3
" 7 4 &% &, % 0 %$ + $4 + & 4 &%9 6%$ + 8 9 + & " $ %&& $ + & $-% &+0 ! 9%" 9 3,&$ 0 43 , % & & $ & 4 &% %!63,&$ $ +
3&& $ &+ + 5 !6 " 43&-! ! 89 +3!",+
%
3&& $7! " ! + !6 ! 9 !9 ,, &+ ", ' + %& & % & + &
& , &+ $ - & % ! &% ' + ' +
& % &89 +
& &
3&& $ % &" % & + &
& , &+ $ + & $ - &
& 5 ! & + % & % &+9%" !3,&$ $ + % & $ & %5 / 5
#
3 8 + ! 3 0 ",+ $ 5 2 ! #
3 86 +",+6%$ - % &
& & " + 2 #
3 8 +!30!0" 85 +!",+!
$ - % & 2 6 !! ! 3 86 +!3!089" 8 +!30! ",+ " %$ - % & ! & & " + 2 5 !6 !! 3 86 +!3!",+% & ' + & - % & + $ - &
& &, " 433& .$& %& & &3 & & " %0 ))% 4 & 0& $ & & ,
" &% + ",+0 % $4- + &
& , &+ $ - &0 %
& &0& &, % & $,& &+ + ,
$4- $ % % 3 $ & 4"
3&& $ & && & & % " && %& 3& - $4 " -& % & &
&, &+ &$ - & " ,
& 89 +3! & $4- & & && &3 & & ))% 4 &% & " + + &
& , &+ $ + & $ - % 0 ))% 4 & &+& , % % $,& 3 & 4 &% " 0 % & $,& % % & & & 4 &% " , % %) &3 &" &
% &&+ & : & & $ + & &
&, &+ & $ - & 8 9 + ",+ & " + + &
& , &+ $ + & $ - &
& $& - & &3 & & " %0 ))% 4 & 0$ & & , +, & % & " 0 & & + "
&% + ",+0 % $4- ))% 4 & & + &
& , &+ & $ - & % & & % & & & ,-0 & $ & " $ + &
)) % , + %& $ & % & & % ",& % &% $, "& %
$ & ' & " $ + & & & % ;<& % & + &
&, &+ $ + & $ - " &% 0 & ))% 4 & $ + & 3 & %0 ,- % &%
" $ - &%& % -, &3 % $ % 0 4 & $ - % & -0 & % & &- $ - % + &
& , " 433& $ + & ))% 4 &$ & & , +& %$ %4+ &%$ $ %
& & &0 & ,% $ " % % & & ",$ &
& & % $ -+ & $4 % - $ + & + &
&, &+ & $ - & % $ & &+ + & & " & $ % =$,& % % &4+ & &3 & & 0 &- % & &
8 5 + ,& % 4&& & & " 8 9 + 6 " 5 + ! & ,, ,& % $ & $ % &+ & ' - % & & & &&& % & %&
& &0 4 &- % 85 +!36
& % % << & 3& & $ - & "& )& " $4% % & -
& + 430 &-&& &3 & &&
& & & ,, 8 5 + ! 3 ,& % & & % % &+ % & && &$ % & $ $4 & 4&& + & )$ & % & % )& &&4 &- 89 + &6+ &$ ,, & & " 3 & ,, &&+& & " % 86!9 + 086! +