Court dismissed asylum claim where applicant failed to prove persecution risk in Estonia despite prior detention.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Viru County Court dismissed the applicant's asylum application, ruling that the evidence presented did not substantiate a well-founded fear of persecution. The applicant, previously detained in Estonia, argued for protection based on alleged threats, but the court found no credible proof of specific danger. Consequently, the application was rejected as the statutory requirements for granting asylum were not met.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAAsylS 1994, § 1; § 2 AsylS 1994: An asylum claim is only granted if the applicant demonstrates a well-founded fear of persecution based on race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group, and the domestic authorities are unable or unwilling to provide protection.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
!"# $%!&'
()*+, !-#..%% /.#.-01.%!1
#2!#-.-334!. 56#27$$56)#27 '82' /.%2.-!1-334!. 56#27$'82$ #.77.&.-.!#. --.-!.-1%
.&!!9 6 ::6 %--!7#!5#27 $*'82%"4.!.2!! ::: -2--! 7#! 5 #2 7 $* '82 %"4.!.2*!! ;.-4<%!&-.#!. .&!!974" ;.-4<%!&-.#!. -4.4%44#- 1.#-%$#.-!--' !"#$% #
&'() *+',* - ./ 0
1 #
&'(. *+* - 2/ 0
1
& 4) ', , - 5/ 0
1 %-2!.!$-&.#!4/0
4/0%-2!!$.7==!..#. !8!&.#.$
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
1 %-2!.!$-&.#!)/ 0
4/0%-2!!$%!%#! 5+*. 7==!..#.!8!&.#.$
!.''#!1-.7-.!&.!!.2 %-2!.!$-&.#!4/0$-!.8. %! 56#2#.#!1-7#!%##%"!4.2#!. - $ (,4!'#--2.2 #2.4&88!4 !8-!!8.##! /.%2.-!1-#.%#!4!;.-4<%!&-.<!3!4--2%"!4!%#!!# ;! /.%2.- !1-#! 2!#4.. %8#' -4 +) (.!. !! %4, -$ !#49!'#.-!--'7#!&-#'&.-.!#.!!4;2"..!6: (.4 -.#3&&.-4 3., - .-!$ !' -!-- .#;1.% 7#! &-#'&.-.!#.!!4;2"..!6:(.4-.#3&&.-43.,- .-!$ !' #- 1.#-% 7#! &-#' &.-.!#. 7! !!4 ;2"..!+(3!!4.!.3&&.-4-.#,-.-!$!'#.-!-
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
- 3
% 1 !! 4.!. !!8!#. !8!&. * 78.% &==4&.# !!. ';!&.!$334#-..#.2-;4.4%"!!#!8!&.''#!-4 !!.#. %;" .!4 7.##!-." ) 78.% '# -2--!#. !%!&'4%84.!%!.&.-.!#-&4.&.#.!&.-.!#.$ !.!4. !#. '##! .". .!&. %!.! + 78.% '# !!. #!&.! 6
334!!..##.$.!!.&$) .7!.&"!- $% #--$.##2'-!- $!.2!.4.27/.%2.-!1-2$ 4%#!$.".4##!$4.A!#!.'73!7.!.-.!..4.B5*#2 8!.!!!$ .4-4&. ..&82# &-44 -!#! -.! &@.!&- ( - ) 2&& 2, ' 11! ( - ) 2&& 2, . 2.$ &##.! 7" -'". !.!&. %8.&#! 3&-.#. -&..#.$ .".4##! 44 -!# -.4 .-4 '. ' & .# !.!. 4.4.#9 %$ >1- ) (!#-.-,'..-#&6)(!1-,--24%#!-44.4&@.!&-'11! .-.%!.#.!.#.%#--$.##2 • !#-.- -4 .4 %8.. 2. &@.!&-
!-#.$ #.-!1.-#.$ F%"#.#.$ #1%#.$ 24-%#. --2 %8.. 2.11! G'4%#.?&332!'8.#.'88-4112. )2&&# %!!4'8%;.!4#8"!&.827#!.!==!'!.7#!? • !1- -4 .4 %8.. 2. &@.!&- > !1--#.$ %-%#.$ --2 4%#!$'%.&# '-!- -4.4&@.!&-' 11! . 2. .4&33&. #2 !#-.-#.? -$
'%. : !1--4&&'!.7'!#-.-#.&@.!&- 3#42. 2&& --2 11! 2. : 2&&$ &4 .## 7#4!#-.-#!#.!4'8%;.!47#!.!==!'!.7#!
+
, + , +, + &&'(2,'() ,11 &'() *+',* 1
&!!.&$##.!8.#-.$.-%.&!&.7--4 56*'6.!!.-8!4 !.4$ !.4.$ .! / #.!$ 3-4-4 ) ::$ - #.#-.$ ) .7!.&" %$>1-)!.7'&33#.!#.11!%8..2.)..!
+
, +, + &'(2,'() ,11 &'(. *+* 1 334!!..##.$.!!.&$'-!- $!.2!.4.27 #2 !#-.-2$ 4%#!$ .".4##!$ 4. A!#!. ' 73!7.!. -.!. .4.B 5 * #2 8!.!!!$ .4-4&. ..&82# &-44 -!#!-.!&@.!&-(-)2&&2,'11!(-)2&&2, . 2.$ &##.! 7" -'". !.!&. %8.&#! 3&-.#. -&..#.$ .".4##! 44 -!# -.4 .-4 '. ' & .# !.!. 4.4.#9 %$ >1- ) (!#-.-, ' ..-#& 6) (!1-, --2 4%#!-44.4&@.!&-'11!.-.%!.#.!.#.%#--$.##2 • !#-.- -4 .4 %8.. 2. &@.!&-
!-#.$ #.-!1.-#.$ F%"#.#.$ #1%#.$ 24-%#. --2 %8.. 2.11! G'4%#.?&332!'8.#.'88-4112. )2&&# %!!4'#8"!&.827#!.!==!'!.7#!8%;.!4? • !1- -4 .4 %8.. 2. &@.!&- > !1--#.$ %-%#.$ --2 4%#!$'%.&# '-!- -4.4&@.!&-' 11! . 2. .4&33&. #2 !#-.-#.? -$ '%. : !1--4&&'!.7'!#-.-#.&@.!&- 3#42. 2&&--211!2. :2&&$&# .## 7!#-.-#!#.!4'7#!.!==!'!.7#!8%;.!4
+ , + , +, + &&'(2,'() ,11 &'() *+',* 1 ;# #2 !#-.-$ /.%2.- !1-$ -.-4. !' #- 1.#-% ' -2--7! % -- -2--7= --.-! .-1% %.# : ;#&!4 #.77.2 -;" -2--7= ! #2 !#-.-#. !.9 & '() * + ',* .!!.-8!4 !. !&.7-.&. ..! . / 0
%-2!! &'(. *+*.!!.-8!4!.!&.7-.&...!!.2/ 0
%-2!! !!.&;!5/ 0
%-2!! %-2!.!$-&.#!4/0
4/0%-2!!$.7==!..#. !8!&.#.$!#-.-.7-.
!.''#!&.!!.2'!84" 5+)#2 8!.!!48!&-!##'7-44-!##-;4.49 ,.#&!&88!4##..#?
,#&& &-##4' &88!4 '%.&. '8.# &-##4-4 .2!..&.#.? *,##& &-##4' -!###. & .# --2 .!& !##. -4&.4 & !!.!8!&.'.#!%.-4!.!? ,& &-##4&.!-#! ..#-.% # .#! #&. .& %.!.!3&-.78.%? ),&&-##4&.!-#!..#-.%#.#$!==%;;77&%.!&.$ %-2!.!$-&.#!4/0$-!.8. %!!#-.-7#!%## %"!4.2#!. ..#.!8!&.#.#%!.!8!'#
& #.77.2 -;" -2--7=! /.%2.- !1-#. !. 5 6 #2 7 '82 . / 0
%-2!! %-2!.!$ -&.#! ) / 0
4 /0%-2!!$%!%#! 5+*$.7==!..#.!8!&.#.$
!.''#!1-.7-.!&.!!.2 %-2!.!$-&.#!4/0$ -!. 8 . %! !1-7#!%##%"!4.2#!. ..#. !8!&.#.#%!.!8!'# !!-2# 334!!%4 %#44$ .! %4 ;#&!4 #.77.! $ -;!%4 .##.2$ -44 %"!!##! -;#. #.77.&.-.!#. #4&.$ #.77. ;#&&.#%#44&!;.#!!.! >='!'4!.!4;#&!4#.7.! ' !# &. 82 ';4 %&.#.$ .! #.77.&.-.!#. #4&.# #.77. ;#&&-. # !#!. !;.#. !!. %#4$ ;4.! #.77.&.-.!#.-&4.!---7..!4 !.."!!.!%!!4'#4.$!;.-4!.'!.&88&.&!%4.#.# --2'-44. 56: #..%% !-