Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
4-05-249\1 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:4.05.249.12649 Generato dall'IA

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding deportation of foreign national based on public order grounds.

Numero d'incarto 4-05-249\1
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Estonia (EE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court dismissed the appeal against the administrative decision to deport the appellant, a foreign national residing in Estonia. The appellant argued that the deportation violated his right to private and family life under the European Convention on Human Rights. The court found that the administrative authority had correctly assessed the risk to public order and security, which outweighed the appellant's private interests. Consequently, the deportation order was upheld as legally sound and proportionate.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 10 § 1 of the Constitution of the Republic of Estonia; Art. 8 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms: The right to private and family life does not preclude deportation if the individual poses a threat to public order or security.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
deportation order public order grounds private life rights foreign national status proportionality test

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 10 § 1 of the Constitution of the Republic of Estonia
Art. 8 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

                             

      !

   " # $  $%  !  &   % #' (  % %  )* + 

 ,   * % )   $-    ./  !  *     0  1'

     %  #'  (  %   &  )* + 

 ,    &)   $.2 

 !     )*  + 

 ,     & )    $ .2 

     33!!1 #' (  %  

* 44*

 * 51...!51.!5 133! 5 13  . %   *    *  5 .  . %   

 *  *

' '   

*  *   3 ! !3  ! % 3  

%  '  % *    * !   31    .   #'  (  %  %     % &    0  '

* !   '66*  7    31        / "   '

* ! ' '  %& !  *     ! '

*   '    * !    !   '  % !     ' 

 *  5 1.  .! 5 1.! 5 133! 5 13  . %   *  

 * 5..% 

 *   *  .  &  #' (  % '  !   *

           %  * &       !  8 *  

*! '   * 

 '

* % *   ! '  ' %& !   

% *      

% *  31    * *     7    

 %   '  

 0   0,% * ! '        %    7 *   *      %  4 '     %  !       %      *!   ' * '  0  0,% *        



%  * !      + & 



  &  *  +  

*  

  % *!  * * !  

%   ' 0,% *  + & 



       4 * % '   *     &   %  

 '  & % 4  !      *   4'   % %    &0,% * % 9 :    *   '' *7   0,% * 7       !  ! '   7* '  

**   * !'*  % * %   %

 " '  '' 

  44*  !     " % '  ''   * !         + 

 * % )   $ 

! 31 .#' (  % %     % &    

 * %& 

  % '  + 

 * %  

! 

    *

      (  % 7 %     

+

*  ! *'   * "     %  (  %  7   * * ' ! * 

  &*          %   *    '    %  '  %  0,% *  ; *!       (  %  7* '    4      0,% *   4  '   *!      % & 7     ' !   *   *    4 *  % *     ! 4  !   & ' % 9 8*

4'            

%   ' '            '  + * <* %     *!         7  '   %  

 (  % '  '  !  

 '   '   ! 4  !   & ' % 0,% * 

  %  ' 8

*4'     0   % & !% %   (  % %  *     0,% *  

* +  !    '   *% 

 *   % %    *   !   0,% * 

   

 =  '    (  % !0,% *       !"! 4  !  * *74'   8  *)  !  ! (  % !0,% * !9 %  ' 0 '*%*  ! '  0,% *   ' 

   7 

 *  %  !   0,% *   %   * 

*   

   '     '  ':   0,% *  & ' % 9 

7   %        *

 * 0,% *   0,% *   * %     

 (  %  %   '   

0*% *    

% * (  %     % % 0,% * *   *    '  &   , %  4'      %  %*    % %     '  

>* 

 *    (  %      ! 4  !   )   $   .' *7 *   '  

  ?  *@ 0     *   0!     & ' 66    4

 

  8    % *

 % *  % %  %  "   (  %  (  %   *      "  

   

 

 0'    %  

  

!   %   '  (  %  ;  * ' 

*  

  !'

  %   ' %    % 7  *4 

 *' *!6*! '    

  % 

 &*              * *   #$$ -  ./!   4   4 '  31 !   0  0,% * A *  '  %   7   %   <*       '&    '    

      7  % *8   % *    

7*   ' %   !  7 

'    

  '  %  '      * * !"4  *!  *31 - ./! 4  !   31   .    A *   %     ' 

   '    % "   ' !* '* *       %  <*  +  *   *   *!  % %   % ! ' ! % * 

8  % *  

% *  '-   %  %!*/+ 

 

  

    ' 4   *'       * *   % '  % *

   3.1       33!!1- 1/B  % &  *  '       - 2/!'  &! (  %    '  % &  * B  % &  *  !#' (  % !* '   - /B  #' (  % 4 '   - ./! 4  31 !   A * 

  '!   %  ''     %  7  

  ! ' C  !     7 * <*%  7  

%  !'   

 % %   %%  ; 

3'  !% *    

% 

     % ! 

% *B  8   ! 

  &!4 '   - ../!  * 4  *!  7 *     (  % 0'  '  % A * %   B   

  &)   $  - .1/! '  ! 31    . % 7 ' % 8     

*A *!'   * *   "     4

* 

  * %  * *   % * "     %   ' !   

* 

  *  %  '* 

  *4 

8  (  % 74   '  * ' % %&  

  % % * ' 

  '    %  '  %   !  0,% * 0*  !  

 %   *   *     '  

     %   %   4 '   * 

 * *    %  +  (  %     *  

%& !  * ' % *      7 *    &    % !  % *!  *   %  '  % !    % & ' ! )* + 

 ,  

  &%

' ' !#' (  %  &  * ' % '    

7   &  %  

 ' 8   4  ! 4  

 '  % %   !  * 

A *%  #' (  %  

8 '     &  

 '  )    $  !   ' & ' !   A *%  #' (  % 

7   * &*4  ! *4  * '      '  % *    %  0   0,% * ! =* * 9  %   %   +   4  

        &      0* 4  *  4  

 '  4   !   

* 4'

  ! A *%  (  % !   

**

  *     % 4  *   *%      * *   %  %  +  4  *  '   *

7   &

  '  '       4    

  4 '  31 

8 '    &

   4  4 '  

 31  +       * *  %  

     4  *!   4    ' !       '   %  '!   %    + 

  4  *  %  +  4  !  

%   ' !* '* *

8 '  %     4 '  +   4  !   

 %   0,% * !   & 0,% * % 9 " *  * 

* (  %   #' (  %     * ' '   '    & !   

    A * 4   * !     %        '  #'  (  %  % 

 *  

 

% 

 

7    *  &   % !0,% * %     %  

 !  

 %     0   0,% * !    

   % *   %* 0,% * !   

*66 ** '  %  *    '   * '** % !'

*   '   % *     (  %  

 

 '  % 0,% *    

6*! '  '      !  * 

 % * '   *   *    &! 85   

* % '    *

%  * 

*%  '   !'  44*

 #' (  %   

7    &!     

 

 (  %  %   !  * * % '    * * '**!

*   *      %  '

*   '    +   %  '  % & !'* 

 % &  *  '        0'

** ' **'  % % &  *   %      % * 51.!!3!51.% 5.22!  '   *

 * 51..!51.!5 133!513.%  *    * 5..%   0'

*  *    * %  

 *    *    *  %   ,

  *  (  %     * *  * * %  * '  %  

* 8          &!        (  %  ' *       ' '    +* *  * * *       !    &   %    

   * ' 

*

7     * '   *    )* + 

 ,    = *  !%**   '    * 5*.3.3% !      % ! "           % &" '   ()*+,*-++.* 

-//+0+.0++1.+.2   03  4     $ *  

  &   *  

  &  :  3   %  

  

 '      *!      * '  

    '   %  1 %                   >