Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
VI ZB 2/23 ECLI:DE:BGH:2023:180423BVIZB2.23.0 Generato dall'IA

Judicial recusal for alleged neglect of unrepresented pleadings in mandatory attorney representation proceedings

Numero d'incarto VI ZB 2/23
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Germania (DE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) rejected the plaintiff's application for the recusal of the presiding judge, ruling the motion inadmissible as unfounded and thereby upholding the continuity of the judicial panel. The dispute arose in a legal complaint (Rechtsbeschwerde) where the plaintiff alleged bias because the court allegedly ignored arguments and motions contained in a procedural document, failing to account for the mandatory representation requirements in appellate proceedings. The court held that no grounds for mistrust of the judge's impartiality under § 42 Abs. 2 ZPO existed, as the legal complaint was filed without a lawyer admitted to the BGH; since statutory attorney representation is mandatory under § 78 Abs. 1 ZPO and the complaint was not admissible in the first place (rendering a court-appointed lawyer under § 78b Abs. 1 ZPO unnecessary), the unrepresented filings were ineffective. The court further determined that obtaining a personal statement from the recused judge under § 44 Abs. 3 ZPO was unnecessary as it would not contribute to clarifying the relevant facts.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

§ 42 Abs. 2 ZPO, § 78 Abs. 1 ZPO, § 78b Abs. 1 ZPO, § 44 Abs. 3 ZPO; Judicial recusal for alleged neglect of unrepresented pleadings in mandatory attorney representation proceedings: The dispute arose in a legal complaint (Rechtsbeschwerde) where the plaintiff alleged bias because the court allegedly ignored arguments and motions contained in a procedural document, failing to account for the mandatory representation requirements in appellate proceedings. The court held that no grounds for mistrust of the judge's impartiality under § 42 Abs. 2 ZPO existed, as the legal complaint was filed without a lawyer admitted to the BGH; since statutory attorney representation is mandatory under § 78 Abs. 1 ZPO and the complaint was not admissible in the first place (rendering a court-appointed lawyer under § 78b Abs. 1 ZPO unnecessary), the unrepresented filings were ineffective. The court further determined that obtaining a personal statement from the recused judge under § 44 Abs. 3 ZPO was unnecessary as it would not contribute to clarifying the relevant facts.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
domanda di ricusazione patrocinio obbligatorio patrocinio gratuito parzialità del giudice presupposti legali e-justice

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA

Giurisprudenza citata

Generato dall'IA
VIII ZB 3/05
Mai 2005 - VIII ZB 3/05, NJW 2005, 2017; vom 12.
I ZB 95/15
Januar 2016 - I ZB 95/15, juris Rn.
I ZB 5/20
Mai 2020 - I ZB 5/20, juris Rn.
X ZB 18/91
Februar 1992 - X ZB 18/91, NJW 1992, 1700, juris Rn.
VI ZB 66/20
Recusal motion for alleged bias based on erroneous legal views and insufficient qualification fails
VI ZB 67/20
Recusal motion for alleged bias based on erroneous legal views and insufficient qualification fails
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
§ 42 Abs. 2 ZPO

Basis for rejecting the recusal application as unfounded due to the absence of grounds justifying mistrust of the judge's impartiality.

§ 44 Abs. 3 ZPO

Procedural rule applied in the dispositive to justify the omission of the recused judge's statement as it would not contribute to the facts relevant for the decision.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

Das Ablehnungsgesuch des Klägers gegen den Vorsitzenden Richter Seiters wird zurückgewiesen.

[GRUENDE]

Das Ablehnungsgesuch ist, seine Zulässigkeit unterstellt, unbegründet. Ein Grund, der geeignet wäre, Misstrauen gegen die Unparteilichkeit des Vorsitzenden Richters Seiters zu rechtfertigen (§ 42 Abs. 2 ZPO), ist nicht gegeben. Ein solcher Grund liegt insbesondere nicht darin, dass im Rechtsbeschwerdeschriftsatz des Klägers enthaltenes Vorbringen und gestellte weitere Anträge - wie der Kläger geltend macht - ignoriert worden seien. Im Rechtsbeschwerdeverfahren besteht Anwaltszwang (§ 78 Abs. 1 ZPO; vgl. BGH, Beschlüsse vom 18. Mai 2005 - VIII ZB 3/05, NJW 2005, 2017; vom 12. Januar 2016 - I ZB 95/15, juris Rn. 1; vom 27. Mai 2020 - I ZB 5/20, juris Rn. 4). Dementsprechend können die die Einleitung und Führung des Verfahrens betreffenden Prozesshandlungen wirksam nur durch einen beim Bundesgerichtshof zugelassenen Rechtsanwalt vorgenommen werden (vgl. BGH, Beschlüsse vom 27. Mai 2020 - I ZB 5/20, juris Rn. 4; vom 4. Februar 1992 - X ZB 18/91, NJW 1992, 1700, juris Rn. 6). Entscheidend war deshalb, ob dem Kläger ein Notanwalt für die Durchführung der Rechtsbeschwerde beizuordnen war (§ 78b Abs. 1 ZPO). Dies war bereits deshalb zu verneinen, weil die Rechtsbeschwerde gegen den Beschluss des Landgerichts Nürnberg-Fürth vom 8. Juni 2022 (15 T 3066/22) nicht statthaft ist.

Der Einholung einer dienstlichen Äußerung des abgelehnten Richters gemäß § 44 Abs. 3 ZPO bedurfte es nicht, weil sie zur weiteren Aufklärung des Sachverhalts, soweit er für die Entscheidung über das Ablehnungsgesuch erheblich ist, nichts beitragen könnte (vgl. Senatsbeschluss vom 10. Februar 2021 - VI ZB 66/20, VI ZB 67/20, juris Rn. 7 mwN).

von Pentz

Oehler

Allgayer

Böhm

Linder