Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
RiSt 1/21 ECLI:DE:BGH:2023:100123BRIST1.21.0 Generato dall'IA

Recusal and hearing objections in federal service law: lack of legal interest and failure to substantiate violation of right to be heard

Numero d'incarto RiSt 1/21
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Germania (DE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Inammissibile (Inadmissible)
Spese processuali a carico del ricorrente / reclamante

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Federal Service Court of the Federal Republic of Germany (BGH Dienstgericht des Bundes) rejected all of the defendant's procedural challenges as inadmissible, thereby prevailing for the plaintiff. The defendant had filed motions for recusal against five judges and an objection regarding the denial of a hearing, challenging the court's composition and procedural fairness in a public service law dispute. The court held that the recusal motions were obviously inadmissible, particularly as they lacked a legitimate interest in legal protection regarding a judge who had already ceased to serve, and that the objection concerning the denial of a hearing failed to meet the stringent substantive requirements for demonstrating a violation of the right to be heard. The legal basis for the rulings rested on the absolute admissibility thresholds for recusal and hearing objections under § 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, and § 152a VwGO, as well as the doctrine that a judge's mere application of specific statutory conflict-of-interest provisions does not, in itself, create a reasonable suspicion of partiality.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

§ 152a Abs. 4 Satz 1 VwGO, § 152a Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2 VwGO, § 152a Abs. 2 Satz 6 VwGO, § 152a VwGO, § 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a Abs. 4 Satz 1 VwGO, § 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a Abs. 2 Satz 6 VwGO; Recusal and hearing objections in federal service law: lack of legal interest and failure to substantiate violation of right to be heard: The defendant had filed motions for recusal against five judges and an objection regarding the denial of a hearing, challenging the court's composition and procedural fairness in a public service law dispute. The court held that the recusal motions were obviously inadmissible, particularly as they lacked a legitimate interest in legal protection regarding a judge who had already ceased to serve, and that the objection concerning the denial of a hearing failed to meet the stringent substantive requirements for demonstrating a violation of the right to be heard. The legal basis for the rulings rested on the absolute admissibility thresholds for recusal and hearing objections under § 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, and § 152a VwGO, as well as the doctrine that a judge's mere application of specific statutory conflict-of-interest provisions does not, in itself, create a reasonable suspicion of partiality.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
diritto di essere sentito domanda di ricusazione censure procedurali diritto legale conflitto d'interessi dottrina giuridica

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
§ 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a Abs. 4 Satz 1 VwGO

Provisions determining the admissibility and cost allocation of the hearing objection (Anhörungsrüge) which was dismissed as inadmissible.

§ 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a Abs. 2 Satz 6 VwGO

Procedural requirements for the substantiation of a hearing objection that the defendant failed to meet.

§ 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a VwGO

Exclusive statutory framework governing the legal remedy, rendering the defendant's counter-complaint (Gegenvorstellung) inadmissible.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

Die auf den 11. November 2022 datierten und unter dem 9. Dezember 2022 und 16. Dezember 2022 ergänzten Ablehnungsgesuche der Beklagten gegen den Vorsitzenden Richter am Bundesgerichtshof Pamp, den Vorsitzenden Richter am Bundesgerichtshof Prof. Dr. Karczewski, die Richterin am Bundesgerichtshof Dr. Menges, die Richterin am Bundesfinanzhof Hübner und den Richter am Bundesfinanzhof Prof. Dr. Nöcker werden als unzulässig verworfen, weil sie offensichtlich unzulässig sind (vgl. zuletzt nur BVerfG, Beschlüsse vom 12. August 2022 - 1 BvQ 54/22, juris und vom 17. August 2022 - 2 BvQ 66/22, juris). Das gilt insbesondere auch, soweit die Beklagte die Besorgnis der Befangenheit aus der Anwendung der § 21g Abs. 7, § 21e Abs. 9 Halbsatz 1 GVG (dazu BGH, Beschluss vom 25. September 2019 - IV AR (VZ) 2/18, WM 2020, 567 Rn.

12) ableiten will. Das Ablehnungsgesuch ist, soweit es sich gegen den mit Ablauf des Geschäftsjahres 2022 aus dem Dienstgericht des Bundes ausgeschiedenen Vorsitzenden Richter am Bundesgerichtshof Prof. Dr. Karczewski richtet, überdies unzulässig, weil es der Beklagten zusätzlich am Rechtsschutzbedürfnis fehlt (vgl. BGH, Beschluss vom 13. April 2021 - RiZ 2/16, juris Rn. 23).

Die Anhörungsrüge der Beklagten gegen den Beschluss des Senats vom 19. Oktober 2022 wird gemäß § 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a Abs. 4 Satz 1 VwGO auf ihre Kosten als unzulässig verworfen, weil sie das Vorliegen einer Verletzung des Anspruchs auf Gewährung rechtlichen Gehörs im Sinne von § 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2 VwGO schon nicht in einer den Anforderungen der § 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a Abs. 2 Satz 6 VwGO genügenden Weise darlegt. Im Übrigen wäre die Anhörungsrüge auch in der Sache unbegründet, weil der Senat das Vorbringen der Beklagten in vollem Umfang zur Kenntnis genommen und erwogen und eine Überraschungsentscheidung nicht gefällt hat.

Die wegen der abschließenden Regelungen in § 63 Abs. 1 DRiG, § 3 BDG, § 152a VwGO unstatthafte Gegenvorstellung der Beklagten gegen den vorbezeichneten Beschluss wird als unzulässig verworfen.

Pamp

Harsdorf-Gebhardt

Dr. Menges

Hübner

Prof. Dr. Nöcker