Valuation of psychiatric expert testimony as witness evidence without prior oath and instruction
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe German Federal Court of Justice (BGH) rejected the prosecution's appeal as inadmissible and the defendant's appeal as unfounded, thereby upholding the lower court's judgment. The dispute centered on whether the trial court erred in utilizing a psychiatric expert's testimony regarding additional facts without first administering the required oath and instructions for witness testimony. While the court clarified that such procedural objections are admissible as a procedural appeal, it held that the error did not affect the outcome, reasoning that the expert would likely have provided identical testimony had they been treated as a witness, and the evidence evaluation would not have been more favorable to the defendant. The decision rests on §§ 349(1) and 349(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO) and precedents regarding the admissibility of expert-witness hybrid testimony and the requirement for a favorable evidentiary outcome to justify reversal.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IA§ 349 Abs. 1 StPO, § 349 Abs. 2 StPO; Valuation of psychiatric expert testimony as witness evidence without prior oath and instruction: The dispute centered on whether the trial court erred in utilizing a psychiatric expert's testimony regarding additional facts without first administering the required oath and instructions for witness testimony. While the court clarified that such procedural objections are admissible as a procedural appeal, it held that the error did not affect the outcome, reasoning that the expert would likely have provided identical testimony had they been treated as a witness, and the evidence evaluation would not have been more favorable to the defendant. The decision rests on §§ 349(1) and 349(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO) and precedents regarding the admissibility of expert-witness hybrid testimony and the requirement for a favorable evidentiary outcome to justify reversal.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IABasis for declaring the prosecution's revision inadmissible.
Basis for rejecting the defendant's revision as unfounded.
Testo completo
Strafverfahren: Beruhen des Urteils auf Bekundungen des als Zeuge vernommenen Sachverständigen ohne entsprechende Belehrung
[TENOR]
Die Revision der Nebenklägerin gegen das Urteil des Landgerichts Cottbus vom 10. Juli 2009 wird aus den Gründen der Antragsschrift des Generalbundesanwalts vom 21. Dezember 2009 nach § 349 Abs. 1 StPO als unzulässig verworfen.
Die Revision des Angeklagten gegen das vorgenannte Urteil wird nach § 349 Abs. 2 StPO als unbegründet verworfen.
Jeder Beschwerdeführer hat die Kosten seines Rechtsmittels zu tragen.
Ergänzend bemerkt der Senat:
Die durch den Angeklagten erhobene Rüge, die Strafkammer habe Bekundungen des psychiatrischen Sachverständigen über Zusatztatsachen verwertet, obwohl der Sachverständige nicht als Zeuge belehrt und vernommen worden sei, ist entgegen der Auffassung des Generalbundesanwalts zulässig als Verfahrensrüge erhoben. Jedoch schließt der Senat unter den hier gegebenen Umständen aus, dass der Sachverständige, wäre er zugleich als Zeuge behandelt worden, andere Angaben gemacht hätte, und dass dann die Beweiswürdigung für den Angeklagten günstiger ausgefallen wäre (vgl. BGH NStZ 1985, 135).
Basdorf Brause Schaal
Schneider König