Cypriot Supreme Constitutional Court declares mandatory court orders under Game Law unconstitutional as they deny judicial discretion.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Constitutional Court of Cyprus declared Section 27 of the Game and Wild Birds Protection Law unconstitutional regarding its mandatory provisions. The accused argued that the law's requirement for courts to issue specific orders violated Article 12.3 of the Constitution by removing judicial discretion. The Court held that while the law is not contrary to Article 23, the mandatory nature of the orders prevents courts from exercising discretion based on the merits of each case.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArticle 12.3 of the Constitution; Article 188.4 of the Constitution: A statutory provision mandating courts to issue specific orders upon conviction is unconstitutional if it deprives the judiciary of the discretion to determine whether such orders should be made.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*28] 1961 Ocotober 19
(forsthoff, p., triantafyllides and munir, jj)
(October 3, 19, 1961)
In the Matter of Article 144 of the Constitution,
And
In the
Matter of a Reference by the District Court of Famagusta in Criminal Case No. 3009/61, GENDARMERIE and ANTONAKIS GEORGHIOU YIALLOUROS OF VAROSHA.
(Case No. 89/61)
Game and Wild Birds Protection Law, Cap. 65 — Section 27 — Making of an order, a “punishment” under Art. 12.3 — Provisions making mandatory an order under paras, (a), (b) & (c), unconstitutional — To be applied with modifications, in accordance with Art. 188.4 — Not contrary to, or inconsistent with. Art. 23.
In the course of the hearing of a criminal case instituted before the District Court of Famagusta by the Gendarmerie against a certain Antonakis Georghiou Yiallouros of Varosha, for pursuing wild birds during a closed season, contrary to the provisions of sections 6(1) (b), (2) and 27 of the Game and Wild Birds Protection Law, Cap. 65, counsel for the accused raised a question of alleged unconstitutionality of section 27 of the said Law, Cap. 65, which was referred to this Court, as follows:-
“Whether having regard to Article 12.3 of the Constitution -
(a) Section 27 of the Game and Wild Birds Protection Law, Cap. 65, is unconstitutional”.
Held : (a) The making of an order under section 27 of Cap. 65, was, substantially, in the nature of a “punishment” in the sense of Art. 12.3;
(b) the mandatory provisions of section 27 of Cap. 65, requiring a trial court to make an order under paras. (a), (b) and (c) thereof, was unconstitutional (District Officer, Nicosia and Georghios Haji Yiannis, 1 R.S.C.C., letter B p. 82, affirmed);
(c) section 27 of Cap. 65, was not contrary to, or inconsistent with, the provisions of Art. 23 (District Officer, Nicosia and Georghios Haji Yiannis, 1 R.S.C.C., letter G, p. 82, affirmed).
Cases referred to :
The District Officer, Nicosia, and Georghios Haji Yiannis of Akaki, 1 R.S.C.C.
A. Pouyouros with P. G. HajiPetrou for the Accused. [*29]
P. N. Paschalis, Counsel of the Republic, for the Gendarmerie.
Cur. adv. vult.
October, 19. The Decision of the Court was read by:-
FORSTHOFF, P.: †The Court declares —
Section 27 of the Game and Wild Birds Protection Law, CAP. 65, in so far as it makes it mandatory upon a court, before which a person is convicted of an offence under the said CAP 65, to make any order under paragraphs (a) (b) and (c) of such section 27, is inconsistent with the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 12 of the Constitution and is, therefore, unconstitutional in so far as it prevents such court from exercising a discretion, according to the merits and the justice of each particular case, whether or not to make any order under such section 27.
This is a reference from the District Court of Famagusta of a question of alleged unconstitutionality which was raised under paragraph 1 of Article 144 of the Constitution during the hearing of criminal case No. 3009/61. The question as referred to this Court on the 11th August, 1961, is as follows:
“Whether having regard to Article 12.3 of the Constitution-
(a) Section 27 of the Game and Wild Birds Protection Law, CAP 65, is unconstitutional”.
The reference was received in the Registry of this Court on the 14th August, 1961, and the Case was heard on the 3rd October, 1961.
The Court is of the opinion that the making of any order as provided for in section 27 of CAP 65 is substantially in the nature of “punishment” in the sense of paragraph 3 of Article 12.
The Court, further, is of the opinion that, in accordance with the principles expounded by this Court in its Decision in case No. 24/61*[1], section 27 of CAP 65 is unconstitutional in so far as it is made mandatory for a court of trial before which a person is convicted of an offence under CAP 65, to make any order under paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) of such section 27 without the exercise of a discretion whether or not any such order should be made.
It is for the trial court in the case under reference to [*30] apply section 27, modified in the light of this
Decision, so as to bring it into accord with the Constitution as provided by paragraph 4 of Article 188.
The Court, finally, is of the opinion, for the reasons stated in its Decision in Case No. 24/61* in relation to sub-section (3) of section 20 of CAP 96, that section 27 is not unconstitutional as being contrary to or inconsistent with Article 23 of the Constitution.
[1] *The District Officer, Nicosia and Georghios Haji Yiamtis, 1 R.S.C.C., letter G p. 82.