Cypriot court strikes down mandatory waterworks removal law sections as disproportionate punishment violating constitutional rights.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Constitutional Court declared subsection (6) of the Government Water Works Law unconstitutional while upholding subsection (1). The accused argued the law violated property rights and proportionality principles, but the Court ruled it must decide unconstitutionality in abstracto without examining case facts. Consequently, the mandatory removal order was struck down as disproportionate punishment, yet the section remains valid regarding general property interference claims.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAGovernment Water Works Law Cap. 341 s. 28(1); Government Water Works Law Cap. 341 s. 28(6): Mandatory removal orders constitute disproportionate punishment under Art. 12.3 and must be modified to allow judicial discretion.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*24] 1961 October 17
(forsthoff, p., triantafyllides and munir, jj.)
(September 29, October 17, 1961)
In the Matter of Article 144 of the Constitution,
And
In the Matter of a Reference by the District Court of Famagusta In Criminal Case No. 2609/61, THE DISTRICT OFFICER, FAMAGUSTA and YIACOUP NAIM OF AY.ANDRONIKOS
(Case No. 65/61)
Government Water Works Law, Cap. 341 — Section 28(1) not contrary to, or inconsistent with, Arts. 12 or 23 — Punishment not to be disproportionate to gravity of offence, Art. 12.3 — Section 28(6) inconsistent with Art.
12.3 — May be applied modified in accordance with Art.
188.4 — Section 28(6) not inconsistent with Art. 23.
Decisions of Supreme Constitutional Court under Article
144 taken in abstracto.
At the hearing of a criminal case instituted before the District Court of Famagusta by the District Officer, Famagusta, against Yiacoup Nairn, for offences against the Government Water Works Law, Cap. 341, Counsel for the accused raised a question of alleged unconstitutionality of subsections (1) and (6) of section 28 of the said law, which was referred to this Court as follows:—
Whether:—
“Section 28(1) and (6) of Government Water Works Law, Cap. 341 is unconstitutional”.
Held : (a) sub-section (1) of section 28 of the Government Water Works Law, Cap. 341, was not unconstitutional as being contrary to, or inconsistent with, Article 12.3, or with Article 23;
(b) this Court in deciding the unconstitutionality of a Law under Art. 144, does not take cognizance of the facts of the particular case before it, but decides in abstracto;
[*25] (c) sub-section (6) of section 28 of the Government Water Works Law, Cap. 341, because of its mandatory provisions upon the court to make an order for removal or extinguishment, without allowing such court discretionary powers, was unconstitutional as being contrary to, and inconsistent with, Art. 12.3, as the making of such an order would substantially be in the nature of a “ punishment” in the sense of Art. 12.3, and it might result in punishment being imposed which would be disproportionate to the gravity of the offence;
(d) sub-section (6) of section
28 of the Government Water Works Law, Cap. 341, was not unconstitutional as being contrary to, or inconsistent with, Art. 23 (The District Officer, Nicosia and Georghios Haji Yiannis oj Akaki, 1 R.S.C.C., letter G p. 82, affirmed).
PER CURIAM : In a case where a person accused of an offence under section 28(1) of Cap. 341, alleges that the waterworks constituted an unconstitutional interference with his property, and that this factor affords him a defence, the issue should not be the unconstitutionality of section 28(1) of Cap. 341, but that such waterworks were placed on the accused’s land contrary to a specific provision of the Constitution, or under an enactment the constitutionality of which was being challenged. It would then be up to the trial court to make a reference to this Court, either for the interpretation of the provision of the Constitution involved, or, concerning the unconstitutionality of the enactment in question.
Cases referred to :
The District Officer, Nicosia, and Georghios Haji Yiannis of Akaki, 1 R.S.C.C.
R. R. Denktash, for the Complainant.
P. N. Paschalis, Counsel of the Republic, for the Accused.
Cur. adv. vult.
October, 17. The Decision of the Court was read by :
FORSTHOFF, P. : The Court declares —
(a) Sub-section (1) of section 28 of the Government Waterworks Law, CAP 341, is not unconstitutional as being contrary to or inconsistent with either Article 12 or Article 23 of the Constitution.
(b) Sub-section (6) of section 28 of the Government Waterworks Law, CAP 341, is not unconstitutional as being contrary to or inconsistent with Article 23 of the Constitution.
(c) Sub-section (6) of section 28 of the Government Waterworks Law, CAP 341, in so far as it makes it mandatory upon a court, before which a person is [*26] convicted under the said Law, to make an order for removal or extinguishment, is inconsistent with the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 12 of the Constitution and is, therefore, unconstitutional in so far as it prevents such court from exercising a discretion, according to the merits and the justice of each particular case, whether or not to make an order of removal or extinguishment under such sub-section (6).
This is a reference from the District Court of Famagusta of a question of alleged unconstitutionality which was raised under paragraph 1 of Article 144 of the Constitution during the hearing of criminal case No. 2609/61. The question as referred to this Court on the 4th July, 1961, is whether :
“Section 28(1) and (6) of Government Waterworks Law CAP 341 is unconstitutional”.
The reference was received in the Registry of this Court on the 6th July, 1961, and the Case was heard on the 29th September, 1961.
This reference only concerns two provisions of CAP 341, i.e. sub-sections (1) and (6) of section 28 thereof.
Sub-section (1) creates a specific offence and provides the punishment for it. As framed it does not in any way contravene the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 12 of the Constitution. Its infringements may quite possibly be of a very grave nature and, therefore, the maximum punishment provided therein cannot be said to be disproportionate to the gravity of the particular offence. There is, also, no provision about a minimum punishment.
It has been argued that in the above-mentioned criminal case the facts are such as would render the waterworks, destroyed by Applicant, an unconstitutional interference with his property and that therefor esub-section (1) is unconstitutional as being contrary to Article 23 of the Constitution.
Under Article 144 this Court does not take cognizance of the facts of any particular case in order to decide the unconstitutionality of a Law in relation thereto, but decides on such question of unconstitutionality in abstracto. There is certainly nothing in the said sub-section (1) as would render it in itself unconstitutional as being contrary to or inconsistent with Article 23.
It is quite possible that, as in the present instance, it may be alleged by a person, accused of an offence under sub-section (1) of section 28, that the waterworks in question constituted an unconstitutional interference with his property and that this factor affords him a defence, though this Court [*27] does not express at this stage any opinion about the validity of such an argument. In such a case, however, the issue would not be the unconstitutionality of sub-section (1) of section 28 itself ; the issue would be that the waterworks were placed on the land of the accused person either directly contrary to a specific provision of the Constitution or under the authority of an enactment, the constitutionality of which is being challenged. It would then be for the trial court to make a reference either for the interpretation of the provision of the Constitution alleged to have been directly contravened or of the question of the alleged unconstitutionality of the enactment involved.
Coming now to sub-section (6) of section 28 the Court is of the opinion that the making of an order as provided for in sub-section (6) is substantially in the nature of “punishment” in the sense of paragraph 3 of Article 12.
The Court, further, is of the opinion that in accordance with the principles expounded in its Decision in Case No. 24/61 *[1] and bearing in mind the great variety of circumstances in which the offence, for which sub-section (6) provides an additional punishment, may be committed, such sub-section is unconstitutional in so far as it makes an order of removal or extinguishment mandatory in all cases without the exercise by the particular court of trial of a discretion according to the merits and the justice of each case whether or not such order should be made.
It is for the trial court in the Case under reference to apply sub-section (6) of section 28 modified in the light of this Decision, so as to bring it into accord with the Constitution as provided by paragraph 4 of Article 188.
The Court, finally, is of the opinion, for the reasons stated in its Decision in Case 24/61† in relation to sub-section (3) of section 20 of CAP 96, that sub-section (6) of section 28 is not unconstitutional as being contrary to, or inconsistent with, Article 23 of the Constitution.
[1] *The District Officer, Nicosia and Georghios Haji Yiannis, 1 R.S.C.C., letter B p. 82.
†The District Officer, Nicosia and Georghios Haji Yiannis,
1 R.S.C.C. letter G p. 82.