Supreme Court allows shipowner's claim for engine repairs and parts after accepting plaintiff's evidence over conflicting defense testimony.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court allowed the plaintiff's claim for work and labor on the defendant ship's engine, rejecting the defendant's denial of authorization. The court accepted the plaintiff's evidence that the ship's manager instructed him to repair the broken crankshaft, supported by corroborating testimony from the ship's engineer and the manager's son. Consequently, the court found the claimed remuneration and value of spare parts reasonable and granted judgment for the plaintiff.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAAdmiralty Act; Contract Law: Where a shipowner requests repairs and the plaintiff performs work under supervision, the court must weigh conflicting evidence and accept the plaintiff's account if corroborated by surrounding circumstances and the absence of protest upon bill production.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*226] 1980 August 20
( SAVVIDES, J. )
ADMIRALTY JURISDICTION
Manolis Kranidiotis,
Plaintiff,
v.
The ship m.v. "AMOR", lying in the port
of Larnaca,
Defendant.
(Admiralty Action No. 100/77).
Admiralty - Ship - Claim for repairs to ship - Two conflicting versions - Plaintiff’s evidence accepted - Claim sustained.
A. Mathikolonis, for the Plaintiff.
Ph. Valianthis for L. Papaphilippou, for the Defendant.
JUDGMENT
The following judgment was delivered by: -SAVVIDES. J.:- Plaintiff’s claim [*227] in this action is for work and labour done, and engine parts supplied in carrying out repairs on the defendant ship. The plaintiff is a mechanic and the said repairs were carried, as alleged by him, at the request of the Manager of the Company owing the defendant ship.
The defendant ship is flying the Cyprus flag and its affairs were managed by one Takis Skarparis (D.W.1). It was a small passengers' ship operating a passengers’ line from Larnaca to Junich, Lebanon.
By the statement of defence it is denied that plaintiff was ever requested to carry out the said work on defendant ship and in the alternative it is alleged that what is claimed by the plaintiff is unreasonable.
Plaintiff testified in support of his claim and two witnesses were called for the defendant ship. The one was the Manager of the ship Takis Skarparis (D.W.1) and the other the engineer of the ship (D.W.2).
The facts as appearing from the evidence of the plaintiff are shortly as follows:
In September 1976 the plaintiff who is a mechanic specializing in repairs to marine engines was requested by D.W.1/telephone to carry our certain[*228] repairs on the defendant ship. The plaintiff acting on such instructions visited the ship where the engineer of the ship informed him as to what was the trouble with the engine. To facilitate his working in the engine room which was very small, the windows were removed to make room for the operation of a pully to lift up the engine for finding our what was wrong about it. After lifting up the engine it was found out the the crankshaft of the engine had broken and had to be replaced. Plaintiff assisted by two of his workmen replaced the crankshaft and all other necessary parts which had to be replaced, under the supervision of the engineer of the ship, and the engine was completely repaired and refixed at. its place. According to the plaintiff, the carrying out of the work of removal, stripping and installation, assembling and alignment of the engine, took him and his two workmen 15 to 20 days and his reasonable remuneration for such work was £300. The work was very difficult in this case in view of the fact that plaintiff and his labourers had to work in a very small engine room with great difficulty in moving about. In addition to his remuneration, plaintiff claims £926.- as the value of spare/parts supplied by him; full particulars of such spare parts appear in the Petition and were mentioned. by plaintiff in his evidence. Out of these spare parts the most expensive items were: one chankshaft, standard size, for which [*229] plaintiff claims £500.- one set of main bearings £200 and one set big bearing £100.- All the rest consisted of various items of smaller value. All these spare parts were stocked by plaintiff and were part of a consignment of spare parts imported by him for sale at his shop. According to plaintiff all the above repairs were carried out in the presence and under the supervision of the engineer of the ship.
The Manager of the defendant ship, Takis Skarparis (D.W.1) denied that the plaintiff had any contract either with him or with his son who together with the engineer of the ship were the persons handling the affairs of the ship or that any instructions were given by him to plaintiff to carry out the said repairs. According to his evidence, on the occasion of one of the trips of the ship to Larnaca in September 1976, he was informed by the engineer of the ship (D.W.2) that there was engine trouble in one of the engines of the ship. It was found necessary to call a mechanical engineer to inspect the engine and examine the damage and as a result he gave certain instructions to the engineer as to what to do and to inform him about the costs. He was later informed by the engineer that the engine was repaired. The first contact he had with plaintiff was when plaintiff visited him at his office and produced his bill for repairs to the engine. Mr. Skarparis found the amount appearing on the bill as excessive and [*230] asked plaintiff to have it certified by the engineer of the ship and bring it back again. A few days later he received such bill by post.
The engineer of the ship, namely Costas Haridemou, who was mentioned by the previous witness, was called as a witness by the defence (D.W.2). His evidence, however, corroborates that of the plaintiff in most material respects. A brief of his evidence is as follows:
Whilst travelling from Lebanon to Cyprus he noticed that there was engine trouble and he suspected that the crankshaft had broken. Upon arrival at Larnaca he informed D.W.1 who undertook to send a mechanic to examine the engine and that plaintiff was sent to him for such purpose. He admitted that plaintiff carried out the work and that he replaced all broken parts mentioned by plaintiff in his evidence. The work lasted for about ten days to two weeks and plaintiff had an assistant working with him all the time and on some occasions and extra labourer to assist him in this work. He further mentioned that when the engine was opened, the son of D.W.1 was present who also noticed that the crankshaft was broken. D.W.I’s son asked the plaintiff whether they could get a crankshaft in Cyprus or whether they had to import one from England. Plaintiff said that he could provide such a crankshaft and it was not necessary to import [*231] one from England. After the work was completed the witness visited Mr. Skarparis (D.W.1 ) to inform him that the engine had been repaired and saw that Mr. Skarparis had already received a bill in connection with the work carried out by plaintiff. He got a photocopy of the bill from Mr. Skarparis and when he saw the plaintiff he told him that in his opinion he was overcharging for the crankshaft and for the labour. In reply plaintiff told him that what he was charging for the crankshaft was half of what a crankshaft would have cost if imported from England, The reason he discussed with plaintiff the latter's claim, was because he was asked by D.W.1 to check up whether what the plaintiff was charging was reasonable.
The son of Mr. Skarparis whose name was mentioned both by him and by his witness that he was the person who was dealing with the affairs of the ship and who was present when the engine was opened by the plaintiff, was not called as witness by the defence to contradict the plaintiff concerning either the work carried out or the instructions given to him. Furthermore, no evidence was called to contradict the plaintiff either as to the reasonableness of the remuneration claimed or the value of the engine parts supplied by him in replacement of the damaged ones.
On the whole of the evidence before me, I do not have the slightest hesitation in accepting plaintiff's evidence and rejecting that of D.W.1. The allegation of [*232] D.W.1 that he never instructed the plaintiff to carry out any work is contradicted by that of D.W.2 and all the surrounding circumstances as related by both defence witnesses. When defence witness Costas Haridemou visited Mr. Skarparis and informed him about engine trouble, Mr. Skarparis asked him to go back to the ship and that a mechanical engineer was to be sent. The only mechanical engineer who went to the ship soon after such meeting was the plaintiff who was, according to plaintiff's evidence, and which I accept as true, asked by Mr. Skarparis to go and see what was wrong about the engine. Mr. Skarparis did not allege in his evidence that he sent any mechanical engineer other than the plaintiff.
Before any repairs were carried on the engine and during the repairs, D.W.1's son, according to D.W.2, was present and saw that the work was being carried out by the plaintiff and in fact he discussed with plaintiff the question of how to get a new crankshaft. When the bill was produced to Mr. Skarparis by plaintiff, Mr. Skarparis did not protest that such work was carried out by plaintiff without any authorization on his part. The only matter he asked the plaintiff was to have the engineer of the ship certify the work appearing on the bill Furthermore, the work was carried under the supervision of the engineer of the ship who was present all the time.
In the result I find that D.W.1 is not telling the truth by saying that plaintiff was never [*233] instructed to carry out the work.
Having found so, I am coming now to consider whether what plaintiff claims is reasonable or whether it is exaggerated. The plaintiff has given full particulars of the value of the spare parts and no evidence was called on behalf of the defendant ship that any of those items is overcharged or that the value of same in the market is less than what plaintiff claims as a fair price. The fact that all spare parts claimed by plaintiff were placed on the engine is supported by the evidence of D.W.2. I, therefore, find that the plaintiff has proved his claim in respect of the spare parts supplied by him and their value. As to his reasonable remuneration it is in evidence that plaintiff worked for about 15 days assisted by two of his workmen. There is no evidence coming from the defence that what plaintiff claims as reasonable remuneration for the type of work he did is excessive or that a lesser amount would have been reasonable.
In the circumstances of the case and taking into consideration the nature of the work and its duration and in the absence of any evidence to the contrary, I find that what plaintiff claims for his remuneration is reasonable.
In the result plaintiff is entitled to what he claims in this action and I give judgment for plaintiff against the defendant ship for C£1,226.- [*234] with legal interest from to day and. with costs to be assessed by the Registrar.
Judgment for C£1,226.-
with costs.