Cyprus Supreme Court annuls Council of Ministers decision for violating natural justice by denying applicant right to be heard.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court declared the Council of Ministers' decision null and void after annulling a sub judice dismissal of the applicant's appeal. The applicant, a police inspector, argued that the disciplinary proceedings violated natural justice under Article 12 of the Constitution by failing to allow him to submit his views in writing. The court ruled that while written submissions suffice, the authorities must also invite the applicant to express reasons supporting his appeal, a requirement not met in this instance.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArticle 12 of the Constitution; Article 12 of the Constitution: The rules of natural justice applicable to offences in general require that a party has the right to be heard or submit views, which is satisfied by inviting the party to express reasons in support of their appeal.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1] 1980 June 14
(MALACHTOS, J.)
In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution
Aleccos Nicolaides,
Applicant,
v.
The Republic of Cyprus, through
the Council of Ministers,
Respondent.
(Case No. 278/78).
Natural Justice - Rules of - Right to be heard - Rules of natural justice applicable to offences in general - Article 12 of the Constitution - Police officer - Disciplinary punishment - Review and confirmation by Minister - Appeal to the Council of Ministers under regualtion 38 of the Police (Discipline) Regulations, 1958 to 1977 - Police officer has the right to be heard or to submit his views in writing - Sub judice dismissal of his appeal annulled as amounting to a violation of the above rule of natural justice - Petrou v. Republic (198O) 3 C.L.R. 203 adopted.
Police officers - Disciplinary offences - Disciplinary Committee set up under regulation 32 of the Police (Discipline) Regulations 1958 to 1976 - May be composed either of Public, Servants or Police Officers or both - Definition of "Public Service" in section 2 of the Public Service Law, 1967 (Law 33/67) - Petrou v. Republic (1980) 3 C.L.R. 203 adopted.
L.N. Clerides, for the Appellant.
N. Charalambous, Counsel of the Republic for the respondent.
JUDGMENT
The following judgment was delivered by:
MALACHTOS, J.: The applicant in this recourse [*2] claims a declaration of the Court that the decision of the respondent Council of Ministers which was taken on 8.3.78, and communicated to the applicant by letter dated 5.4.78, confirming the sentence of dismissal from the ranks of the Police Force imposed on the applicant, is null and void and of no legal effect whatsoever.
The facts of the case, shortly put, are the following:
The applicant, an Inspector of Police, was charged under the Police (Discipline) Regulations, 1958 to 1 976, for disobedience to orders contrary to Regulations 7 and 18(i)(a) of the First Schedule of the Discipline Code, that on the 4th August, 1977 being a member of the Police Force o the rank of Inspector and while on duty, disobeyed the Order of the Chief of Police under No. Limassol 56/6 dated 3rd August, 1977, by which he was bound to wear black arm band due to the death of Archbishop Makarios, the late President of the Republic of Cyprus. The case was referred to the Minister of Interior and Defence under Regulation 10(A) of the said regulations, who appointed by virtue of Regulation 32 a Disciplinary Committed consisting of three members of the Force in order to try the case of the applicant. This Disciplinary Committee tried the case and under Regulation 33 imposed on the 4th. November, 1977 on the applicant the disciplinary sentence of dismissal from the ranks of the Force. The case was then reviewed by virtue of Regulation 36 by the Minister, who,on the 16th January, 1978, confirmed the
decision of the Committee [*3]
The applicant appealed against the
decision of the Minister to the Council of Ministers in accordance with Regulation 38 and the Council of Ministers by its decision under No. 16682 dated 8th March, 1978, which was communicated to the applicant by letter dated 3th April, 1978, dismissed the appeal. The said decision reads as follows:
"Appeal of Inspector Aleccos Nicolaides who was convicted by the Disciplinary Committee to the punishment of dismissal”
“(Submission under No. 199/78)
“The Council considered the appeal of Inspector Aleccos Nicolaides attached to the submission, who was convicted to the punishment of dismissal by virtue of Regulation 36 of the Police (Discipline) (Amendment) Regulations of 1976 and decided, by virtue of Regulation 38 of the said Regulations, to confirm it, provided that the Attorney-General of the Republic will advise that there exists no legal obstacle to the said confirmation".
As against this decision the applicant, on the 15th June, 1978, filed the present recourse.
The relevant regulations in the present case are Regulations 10(A) and 32 to 38, both inclusive.
One of the grounds of law on which the present application is based, argued by counsel for applicant, is that the
Disciplinary Committee, which was appointed [*4] by the Minister was wrongly constituted as it was entirely composed
of members of the Police Force and did not contain any member of the Public Service. According to his own interpretation of Regulation 32, this Committee should be a mixed Committee of Public Servants and members of the Police Force.
Another ground of law argued by counsel for applicant is that the principles of natural justice in the proceedings before the Council of Ministers have been violated as the applicant was not invited to express his views and so he was deprived of the right to be heard.
It is not in dispute that the Council of Ministers in issuing the decision complained of, did not hear the applicant or his advocate, but it had before it only the record of proceedings before the Disciplinary Committee and the Minister, as well as the grounds on which the appeal against the decision of the Minister was based.
The aforesaid two grounds of law have been dealt with by this Court in the case of Evangelos Petrou v. The Republic of Cyprus through the Council of Ministers, reported in (1980) 3 C.L.R. 203.
At page 215 of this report we read:
"I have considered the wording of this Regulalation and I must say that I do not agree with the interpretation given by counsel for applicant. The purpose of insertion of the words 'including the force’ in Regulation 32 was to cover Police Officers who otherwise would be [*5] excluded, as Members of the Police Force are not considered as Public Servants, according to the definition appearing in section 2 of the Public Service Law, 1 967 (Law 33/67). This definition is as follows:”
"'Public Service' means any service under the Republic’other than the Judicial Service of the Republic or Service in the Armed or Security Forces of the Republic or Service in the Office of Attorney-General of the Republic or Auditor-General or Accountant-General or their deputies or service in any office in respect of which other provision is made by Law or service by persons whose remuneration is calculated on a daily basis’.”
"So, the Disciplinary Committee may be composed either of Public Servants or Police Officers, or both. And, therefore, the Disciplinary Committee in the present case, which was composed solely of Police Officers, was not wrongly constituted".
And at apage 218 it is stated:
"There is no doubt that where we are concerned with disciplinary proceedings before the Council of Ministers as a hierarchically superior organ, as in the present case, the rules of natural justice, which under Article 1 2 of our Constitution are applicable to offences in general, should be followed. Consequently, the applicant had a right to be heard. (Nicolaos D. Haros v. The Republic 4 R.S.C.C. 39). However, it is not necessary for an applicant to be heard before the Council of Ministers viva voce, as in open court, but this right should be considered [*6] as fully satisfied, if he were invited to submit his views in writing. This proposition finds support in the Rights of Defence Before the Administrative Authorities by Stassinopoulos, 1974 edition, pages 173 to 175.”
"Therefore, the question posed in the case in hand is whether by the two grounds of appeal appearing in Appendix B of Exhibit 2, the rules of natural justice have been observed. The answer should be in the negative. It cannot be said that by the letter of the 4th April, 1978, addressed by the Director-General of the Ministry of Interior and Defence to counsel for applicant to the effect that he had to state the
grounds on which his appeal was based, the right to be heard was satisfied. He should also be asked to express his views and give reasons in
support of the said ground. The net result is that in the present case there is a violation of the rules of natural justice and so the decision of the Council of Ministers complained of should be and it is hereby declared null and void. It is up to the Council of Ministers to reconsider its decision in the light of this judgment."
Needless to say that I adopt the reasoning of the above case on both legal grounds in the case in hand and in view of that I consider it unnecessary to deal with the other grounds of law submitted on behalf of the applicant.
For the above reasons the decision of the respondent complained of, is declared null and void and [*7] of no legal effect whatsoever.
As regards costs, the respondent authority is adjudged to pay to the applicant £20.- against his costs.
Sub-judice decision annulled.
Respondent to pay £20.- costs.