Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Utraco United Trading Co. Ltd. v. The Ship ""BILLY"" ex ""JANNE WEHR"" (1979) JSC 278 Generato dall'IA

Court allows mortgage recovery but rejects foreign advocate costs as not within contract contemplation.

Numero d'incarto Utraco United Trading Co. Ltd. v. The Ship ""BILLY"" ex ""JANNE WEHR"" (1979) JSC 278
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court ordered the defendant shipowner to pay the mortgage debt and insurance premiums but denied the claim for $10,000 in foreign advocate fees. While the plaintiff proved the debt and insurance costs, the judge found the foreign legal instruction expenses were unnecessary and not within the parties' original intent. Consequently, the judgment was granted for the principal sum and insurance, but the specific claim for the foreign advocate's costs was rejected.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Section 31 of the Merchant Shipping (Registration of Ships, Sales and Mortgages) Law, 1963; The court held that costs incurred for retaining an advocate from abroad to give instructions for proceedings are not recoverable under a mortgage covenant unless expressly contemplated by the parties at the time of signing.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
admiralty jurisdiction ship mortgage recovery foreign advocate costs deed of covenants contractual contemplation insurance premiums statutory registration libertà di navigazione

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
section 31 of the Merchant Shipping (Registration of Ships, Sales and Mortgages) Law, 1963
The said mortgage was on the 11th November, 1976 duly registered in accordance with the provisions of section 31 of the Merchant Shipping (Registration of Ships, Sales and Mortgages) Law, 1963 as a first preferred mortgage.
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*278] 1979 September 21

(MALACHTOS, J.)

ADMIRALTY JURISDICTION

UTRACO UNITED TRADING CO. LTD.

Plaintiffs,

and

The Ship "BILLY" ex "JANNE WEHR"

Defendant.

(Admiralty Action No. 174/79).

Admiralty - Ship - Mortgage - Loan - Statutory mortgage on ship in consideration of loan - Default of payment of loan and proceedings for its recovery - Whether costs of advocate retained from abroad, in order to give instructions for the institution of the proceedings and for the insurance of the defendant ship, recoverable.

L. Papaphilippou, for the Plaintiffs,

E. Psillaki (Mrs) for the defendant ship.

E. Lemonaris, for the Interveners, the Second Mortgagees,

JUDGMENT

The following judgment was delivered by:-

MALACHTOS, J.: The plaintiff in this [*279] Admiralty Action is a private company formed and incorporated-at Gibraltar with limited liability and is the first Mortgagee of the defendant ship which is registered In Cyprus and is owned by a Cyprus Company, namely, Santamar Maritime Co. Ltd.

On the 11th day of November, 1976, the owning company of the defendant ship (hereinafter referred to as the "owners") in consideration of a credit by a current joint liability account up to U.S. Dollars 700,000 granted to their sister company George HadjiYiannis Shipping Company Ltd., by the plaintiff under a loan agreement dated 10th November, 1976, the owners executed, a statutory first preferred mortgage and a deed of covenants by which they agreed to pay to the plaintiffs the said amount with interest thereon at the rate which was fixed later at 10% per annum. Furthermore, by the said mortgage the owners agreed to pay any such other amounts which would be payable under the deed of covenants. As security for the payment of the said credit, the owners mortgaged the defendant ship. The said mortgage was on the 11th November, 1976 duly registered in accordance with the provisions of section 31 of the Merchant Shipping (Registration of Ships, Sales and Mortgages) Law, 1963 as a first preferred mortgage. The defendant ship was arrested on the 9th June, 1979, by an Order of this Court in Admiralty Action No.133/79, brought by Deutsche Schiffahrtsbank A.G. of Bremen, West Germany and Another, who brought that action as second Mortgagees of the defendant ship, and who applied and obtained leave of this Court in this action to appear as Interveners. [*280]

It is the allegation of the plaintiff company, as it appears in the petition that the owners in breach of The terms and conditions contained in the deed of covenants failed, inter alia, to maintain a copy of the mortgage on the vessel as provided by clause 3 of the deed of covenants. They also failed to notify immediately the plaintiffs about the arrest of the vessel in Admiralty Action Mo. 133/79 and allowed the vessel to be so arrested and failed to release same within reasonable time as provided by clause 5 of the deed of covenants as well as to insure and maintain the vessel covered by insurance as provided by clause 11 of the said deed of covenants.

The plaintiffs in pursuance to the provisions of the deed of covenants through their advocates served on the owners, as well as on George HadjiYiannis Shipping Co.Ltd. on the 4th July, 1979, a Notice with which they constituted the amount due under the said mortgage claimable and payable on the expiry of five days from the date of the Notice because of breaches of terms and conditions of the said deed of covenants. It is further the allegation of the plaintiffs that the owners failed to insure the vessel and so they had to insure same and pay the premium which is 1,900 Dollars per month as from the 4th July, 1979. The balance owed by the owners on the mortgage is U.S.Dollars 309,0 with interest as from 1st January, 1979, at the rate of 10% per annum.' The owners, as well as George HadjiYiannis Shipping Co. Ltd. by their letters dated 17th January, 1979, and 24th January, 1979, respectively, [*281] confirmed their agreement to the said balance of the account. As neither the owners nor George HadjiYlannis Shipping Co. Ltd. paid anything against the said balance the plaintiff company instituted on the 10th July, 1979, the present proceedings. It is also the allegation of the plaintiffs that in prosecuting this action had to send their lawyer Mr. Urs Moser from Switzerland to Cyprus for instructions to their advocate in this action and for survey of the condition of the vessel and to arrange the insurance cover and in this respect they incurred expenses amounting to 10,000 Dollars, which they claim as costs incidental to the mortgage and agreed in the deed of covenants.

The plaintiffs also contend that they are entitled to the equivalent of all amounts in U.S. Dollars due under the said mortgage at the rate equivalent to Cyprus Pounds as on the 10th July, 1979, when the amount secured by the mortgage was payable and the present action was brought. Therefore, they claim the Cyprus Pounds equivalent of U.S. Dollars 309,000, the amount of U.S. Dollars 1,900 for insurance premium of the defendant ship for the period from 4th July, 1979 until 3rd August,1979, plus insurance premium from 3rd August, 1979 until the sale of the above vessel, the Cyprus Pounds equivalent of 10,000 Dollars for expenses of the plaintiffs' representative in Cyprus which, as they allege, are payable according to the terms and conditions of the deed of covenants and interest on the above sums at the rate of 10% per annum. [*282]

The owners of the defendant ship in their answer contended that the mortgage was void ab initio as having been granted ultra vires since George HadjiYiannis who signed for the owners was not authorised to do so. They further deny that they committed any breaches of the terms and conditions contained in the deed of covenants and that the plaintiff company was entitled to send the Notice of the 4th July, 1979. They also deny that the balance due is 309,000 U.S. Dollars and, generally, deny all the other claims of the plaintiffs. In particular they deny that the expenses of 10,000 Dollars, which the plaintiffs allege that they paid to their advocate are recoverable under the mortgage in question.

Three witnesses were called by and on behalf of the

plaintiff company in order to substantiate its claim. Rosana Koutsiou of the Department of Merchant Shipping in giving evidence

as P.W.1, produced a certified true copy of the Mortgage and the Deed of Covenants attached thereto signed by George HadjiYiannis for Santamar Maritime Company Ltd., the owners of the defendant ship. She also produced the minutes of the proceedings of the meeting of 9th November, 1976, of the shareholders of the said company authorising George HadjiYiannis, its Managing Director, to sign on its behalf the mortgage.

It must be noted here that the only shareholders in this company are George HadjiYiannis and his wife Zoe holding 80% and 20% of the shares respectively. [*283] This witness further produced the relevant power of attorney given by the said company to George HadjiYiannis to proceed on its behalf and carry out the decision for the mortgage of the defendant ship to the plaintiff company. Edward Aelling, the Supervisor Accountant of the plaintiff company in giving evidence as P.w. 2, produced a copy of the accounts of George HadjiYiannis Shipping Co. Ltd. where it is stated that on 31st December, 1978, the amount due to the plaintiffs was 309,000 U.S. Dollars. He also produced a copy of the minutes of the meeting of the shareholders of this company dated 9th. November, 1976, by which George HadjiYiannis, its Managing Director, was authorised to contract the open account up to 700,000 U.S. Dollars with the plaintiff company. The relevant power of attorney was also produced. George HadjiYiannis and his wife Zoe are the only shareholders of George HadjiYiannis Shipping Co. Ltd. holding 99% and 1% of the shares respectively.

This witness also produced the letters dated 17th January, 1979, and 24th January, 1979, where George HadjiYiannis for and on behalf of Santamar company and George HadjiYiannis Shipping Co. Ltd. confirmed the aforesaid account. An insurance policy was also produced indicating that the ship in question was insured on the 4th July, 1979 for the premium of 1,900 Dollars per month. Two receipts were also produced, the one for 3,800 Dollars representing premium paid from 4th July to 4th September, 1979 and the other for 1,900 Dollars representing premium paid for the period from 4th [*284] September, 1979 to 4th October, 1979. A telex was further produced indicating that the insurance of the defendant ship was cancelled from noon of the 22nd June, 1979 as the owners had failed to pay the insurance premiums.

Simos Papadopoullos, an adv cates clerk, in giving evidence as F.W.3, stated that on 4th July, 1979, a Notice was served at the office of Santamar Maritime Company Ltd., as well as on George HadjiYiannis Shipping Co. Ltd. pursuant to the provisions of the Deed of Covenants constituting the amount due under the mortgage claimable and payable because of breaches of terms and conditions of the deed of covenants. He also produced a copy of this Notice.

No evidence was called by the defence or the interveners to substantiate any of the allegations contained in the Answer and the case was left to be decided on the evidence adduced by the plaintiffs.

On the evidence adduced both oral and documentary, which stands uncontradicted and unchallenged on all material points and which I accept as true and correct, I find that the amount due on the mortgage as on 31st December, 1978 was 309,000 Dollars with interest thereon at 10% per annum as from 1st January, 1979, and that the plaintiffs paid premiums for the insurance of the vessel up to 4th October, 1979, the sum of 5,700 Dollars and so they are entitled to judgment for the aforesaid amounts.

The only point that presents some

difficulty is as to whether plaintiffs are entitled to 10,000 Dollars [*285] which they paid to their advocate from Switzerland.

Counsel for the plaintiffs argued that this amount is recoverable by virtue of the provisions of the covenant attached to the mortgage under the heading "Rights of the Creditor for the Insurance of the Ship", term 2. This term reads as follows:

"Να προβαίνη

άνευ ευθύνης δι ' απώλειαν ή ζημίαν εις την πώλησιν του πλοίου οπουδήποτε και

αν ευρίσκεται αυτό και καθ' οιονδήποτε είτε δι' εκουσίας εκποιήσεως

υπό οιουσδήποτε όρους ήθελεν θεωρήσει καλόν, επί τω τέλει όπως εκ του τιμήματος

μετ' αφαίρεσιν των εξόδων καταλήψεως του πλοίου μετακινήσεως του, εξόδων

πωλήσεως μισθών πληρώματος από της ημέρας της καταλήψεως ή και καθυστερουμένων

προηγουμένως μισθών, εξόδων ασφαλίσεως τυχόν οφειλομένων φόρων και τελών ή

εισφορών προς οργανισμούς κοινωνικής ασφαλίσεως και πάσης άλλης συναφούς προς την κατάληψιν του πλοίου και την

πώλησίν του, καλύψη την διά της παρούσης υποθήκης ασφαλιζομένην απαίτησιν της, το απομένον δε

υπόλοιπον θα καταθέτη επ' ονόματι της πλοιοκτητρίας."

Counsel for the plaintiffs submitted that the phrase "kai pasas allis sinafous pros tins katalipsin tou pliou" covers the expenses of 10,000 Dollars incurred.

I must say that I entirely disagree with this submission of counsel. From a mere perusal of this term as a whole it cannot be extracted that these costs were [*286] within the contemplation of the parties when the said covenant was signed. It was quite unnecessary for the Plaintiffs to retain an advocate from Switzerland to come to Cyprus in order to give instructions for the institution of the present proceedings and for the insurance of the defendant ship. Therefore, the amount of 10,000 Dollars is not recoverable.

For all the above reasons Judgment is given in favour of plaintiffs against the defendant ship as follows:

(a) for the equivalent in Cyprus Pounds of the sum of 309,000 Dollars at the rate of exchange as on 10th July, 1979, with interest thereon at 10% per annum as from 1st January, 1979 to final payment;

(b) for the equivalent in Cyprus Pounds for the sum of 5,700 Dollars with interest thereon at the rate of 4% per annum as from today to final payment;

(c) the plaintiffs are entitled to the costs of this action to be assessed by the Registrar.

All the costs of plaintiffs’ witness

2 who came from abroad to give evidence in this case are specially allowed.

There will be no Order as to the costs of the Interveners.

Judgment and order

for costs as above.