Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Yannakis Antoniades v. Faedon Economides and Another (1977) JSC 103 Generato dall'IA

Court allows partial consolidation of four traffic accident actions to trial liability only, separating damages issues.

Numero d'incarto Yannakis Antoniades v. Faedon Economides and Another (1977) JSC 103
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The District Court of Larnaca ordered the consolidation of four civil actions arising from a single traffic accident, but limited the joint trial to the issue of liability. Plaintiffs argued for full consolidation, while defendants requested separate trials for damages; the court found the latter more just. Consequently, liability will be heard together, with each plaintiff's damages claim to be tried separately afterward.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

O.14, r. 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules; The court possesses a wide discretionary power to order partial consolidation of actions to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, allowing joint trial of common issues like liability while separating distinct issues such as damages.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
partial consolidation Civil Procedure Rules traffic accident multiplicity of proceedings joint trial of liability separate damages issues discretion of the court congiunzione dei procedimenti

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
O.14, r. 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules

Giurisprudenza citata

Generato dall'IA
Healey v. A. Waddington & Sons Limited (1954)
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*103] 1975 January 27

(PIKIS, AG. P.D.C.)

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OP LARNACA

Yannakis Antoniades,

Plaintiff,

and

Faedon Economides and Another,

Defendants.

(Action No. 247/1974).

Civil Procedure - Action - Consolidation - Partial consolidation - Principles applicable - Discretion of the Court - Rule 2 of Order 14 of the Civil Procedure Rules - Four Actions arising out of the same traffic accident - Consolidation up to determination of liability - Separate issues as to damages.

Consolidation of Actions - See under "Civil Procedure".

Fr. Nicolaides, on behalf of Chr. Demetriades, for the Applicants-Defendants in all Actions.

B. Vassiliades, personally and on behalf of A. Anastassiades, for the Respondents-Plaintiffs in Actions 247/74, 248/74 and 249/74.

D. Savvidou, (Mrs.), on behalf of A. Lemis, for the Plaintiff-Respondent in Action 906/74.

RULING

The following ruling was delivered by:-

PIKIS. AG. P.D.C.: The applicants are the [*104] defendants in four Actions arising out of a traffic accident involving a collision between the car of the plaintiff in Action No. 243/74 and a car driven by defendant 1. The plaintiffs in three of the four actions were passengers in the car driven by the plaintiff in Action 249/74 and claim damages for injuries suffered at the accident, whereas the fourth plaintiff claims damages for personal injuries as well as loss for damage to his car.

The plaintiffs consent to an order for consolidation but submit that it should be limited to the trial of the issue of liability with separate issues being settled as to damage in each case.

Principles Regulating the Consolidation of Civil Actions :

The application is based on the provisions of 0.14, r. 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules whereby the Court is empowered, in its discretion, to order consolidation provided it appears that common questions of law or fact of sufficient importance in proportion to the rest of the matters in issue make it desirable that the actions be heard together. No provision is made in the rule as such for partial consolidation, that is consolidation for purposes of hearing of some of the. issues in dispute but the word "may", in the context of the rule, clearly imports a discretionary power wide enough to authorize any kind of consolidation designed to further the object of consolidation that lay in the avoidance of multiplicity of proceedings and the saving of expense. [*105]

The marginal note to 0.14 suggests that the order is modelled on the provisions of 0.19, r. 8, of the Old Rules of the Supreme Court, and, therefore, it may be instructive to have regard to the way the English Order has been interpreted by the Courts in England. In the White Book reference is made with approval to a decision of the Irish Court of Appeal on an application for the consolidation of actions arising out of the same accident deciding that in as much as the issue of liability was common in all actions, that issue should be tried jointly whereas the remaining issues concerning damage resulting from personal injuries should be settled separately and be heard individually (see Brady v. McDonald, (1931) N. Ir. 345). The case is helpful in so far as it underlines that it is perfectly possible, under the relevant rule authorizing consolidation to split the trial of the issues and the Court has a discretion to make, for the purpose, any order that appears to serve the interests of justice as well as the convenience of the parties.

Mr. Vassiliades for the respondents, in his address, mentioned a case where the English Court of Appeal directly sanctioned the course suggested by the respondents in a situation very much like the one posing before the Court for consideration in the present proceedings. Learned counsel was unable to cite the authority as the report was not immediately available to him.

As a matter of principle and proper procedure [*106] it is undesirable that the issues in a given case be split for purposes of hearing, and to that extent partial consolidation nay offend against the above principle. On the other hand, consolidation is an extraordinary procedure making possible the hearing of more than one action in the sane spell for the sake of convenience and in order to avoid duplicity of proceedings, and save expense. Therefore in an application for consolidation the Court, in making an order, will be guided by the principles underlying the need for consolidation. The argument of the applicants that if all the issues in the four actions are heard together this course will save expense, is not necessarily correct as the Court, ill an application for consolidation, may make any order as to costs that appears to be just and surely it would not be right to order one set of costs for the plaintiffs for all appearances if those appearances were not meant to ventilate before the Court the same issue which would be the case as to that aspect of the actions of the plaintiffs concerning damage.

In the light of the above, I incline to accept the suggestion of the respondents that the four actions should be consolidated only with regard to liability and that the remaining issues concerning damages should be tried separately. Accordingly I make the following orders:-

(a) All four actions are consolidated regarding the issue of liability. The plaintiff in Action 247/74 will have charge of the proceedings. [*107]

(b) The issue of liability will be tried before any other issue in the cause comes up for hearing.

(c) Following the decision of the Court on the question of liability, any of the plaintiffs may apply that his case be set down for hearing regarding damages. Thus separate issues as to damage are settled in all four actions.

The costs of these proceedings will be costs in cause. The Court will hear the parties on the issue of liability on 1st March, 1975.

Note: After the delivery of the judgment, Mr. B. Vassiliades, counsel for the respondents, brought to my notice a case he mentioned in the course of his address, that he was then unable to cite, namely the decision in Healey v. A.. Waddington & Sons Limited. (1954) 1 All E.E., 861. This is a decision of the English Court of Appeal supporting the reasoning of the above, judgment, whore, on a similar application for consolidation, the Court ordered that the actions be consolidated upto determination of the issue of liability, directing at the same time that issues peculiar to each one of the plaintiffs should be separately dealt with.