Cyprus Supreme Court refused plaintiffs' application to extend security time pending appeal in cargo arrest case.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court refused the plaintiffs' application to extend the time for furnishing increased security or stay execution pending an appeal. Plaintiffs sought relief after being ordered to provide additional security for arrested cargo, while defendants argued that special circumstances did not justify the delay. The court declined the request, noting that the partial release of cargo and the specific interests involved militated against granting the extension, though it allowed a ten-day grace period for compliance.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IACivil Procedure - Appeal - Execution - Stay of execution pending appeal; Admiralty - Arrest of property - Security - Increase of - Application for an order enlarging the time within which to furnish such security until determination of the appeal: A stay of execution pending appeal is granted only if special circumstances require it, and the same approach applies to applications for enlarging time to comply with an order appealed from.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*83] 1976 December 6
(TRIANTAFYllIDES, P .)
ADMIRALTY JURISDICTION
Distos Compania Naviera S.A. (No.4),
Plaintiffs,
and
The Cargo on board the ship "Siskina",
Defendant.
(Admiralty Action No. 43/76)
Admiralty - Arrest of property (Cargo) - Security - Increase of - Appeal - Application for an order enlarging the time within which to furnish such security until determination of the appeal -.Approach to the matter - Discretion of the Court - Hot only there do not exist such circumstances justifying acceding to the application but, on the contrary, the particular circumstances of the instant case militate against such a course - Application refused.
Civil Procedure - Appeal - Execution
- Stay of execution pending appeal - Is granted if the special circumstances of the case so require - Same approach adopted in applications for an order enlarging the time within which to comply with the order appealed from.
L. Papaphilippou, for the Appellants in C.A. 5618 –
Applicants (Plaintiffs in this action).
J. Erotocritou with Fr. Nicolaides, for the Respondents (Defendants owners of cargo under arrest in this action).
DECISION
The following decision was delivered by:-
TRIANTAFYLLIDES,P.: In dealing with an application by the plaintiffs in this action, made on October 9, 1976, for enlargement of the time for compliance with an order* of this Court made on September 14, 1976, until the determination of an appeal, C.A. 5618, made by them against such order (by means of which they were ordered to furnish [84] increased security in respect of the arrest of the defendant cargo), or, in the alternative, for stay of execution of the order of September 14, 1976, pending the determination of the said appeal, I have directed on November 15, 1976, that certain further information be placed before me by means of affidavits; as a result an affidavit was filed on behalf of the defendants on November 18, 1976, and another on behalf of the plaintiffs on November 20, 1976.
I have considered the contents of these two affidavits, together with all other material before me, and the position appears, at present, to be as follows:
Even though since September 14, 1976, a large part of the cargo under arrest in Limassol has been released, there still remains under arrest a considerable part of it, in respect of which counsel for the defendants have already appeared in these proceedings, or have been recently instructed to do so on behalf of persons who have an interest in the cargo.
As regards the action in England (to which reference was made in my Decision of September 14, 1976++, and my Ruling of November 15, 1976+) it appears that those who are represented in the present proceedings in Cyprus, as persons beneficially interested in relation to the cargo still under arrest in Cyprus, are not, also, all of them, parties to the said action in England.
A stay of execution pending appeal is granted [*85] if the special circumstances of the case so require (see, inter alia, in England, The Supreme Court Practice, 1976, vol. 1 , p. 880 and Admiralty practice by McGuffie, Fugeman and Gray, vol. 1 in the British Shipping Laws series, pp. 596,597, para. 1356); and, in my view, the same approach should be adopted in dealing with that part of the plaintiffs’ application by means of which there is sought, as an alternative to a stay of execution, an order enlarging, up to the determination of the appeal, the time within which to comply with the order appealed from, namely that of September 14, 1976; such enlargement being, in effect, another way of securing a stay of execution pending the determination of the appeal.
Having in mind all relevant considerations I have decided, in the exercise of my discretion, to refuse in toto the present application of the plaintiffs; in my view not only there do not exist such circumstances as to justify acceding to the application, but, on the contrary, the particular circumstances of the instant case militate against such a course.
In dismissing, however, the plaintiffs’ application I have decided to allow them a further period of ten days’ grace within which to make arrangements in order to comply with my appealed from order of September 14, 1976.
The question of costs of this application is reserved, to be decided at the end of the proceedings in the present action.
Order accordingly.
* Vide p. 65 in this Part ante.
++ Vide p. 65 in this Part ante.
+ Vide p. 78 in this Part ante.