Supreme Court grants adjournment of custody appeal due to absent counsel but imposes conditions on stay of execution.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court granted an application to adjourn the hearing of an appeal regarding child custody because the appellant's second counsel was absent abroad. While the court acknowledged the serious issue of jurisdiction over children in Greece, it refused a blanket adjournment, instead imposing a condition that the appellant must allow the children to visit the respondent for 15-17 days if the stay of execution remains in force. The court balanced the appellant's need for legal representation against the respondent's right to spend time with the children during the summer.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IACivil Procedure; Custody Orders; Adjournment of Appeal; Stay of Execution: The court may grant an adjournment of an appeal on grounds of absent counsel but may conditionally uphold a stay of execution, requiring the appellant to facilitate visitation rights for the respondent pending the appeal's outcome.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1065] 1976 July 30
(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, P., STAVRINIDES, HADJIANASTASSIOU,JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Loulla G. Economou,
Appellant,
v.
George K. Economou,
Respondent.
(Civil Appeal No. 5598).
Civil Procedure - Appeal - Adjournment - Appeal against part of order for custody of children - Stay of execution granted ex parte - Application to adjourn hearing of appeal on the ground that another counsel also retained by appellant, and who did not appear before trial Court, is absent abroad - Application granted subject to terms.
Appeal - Adjournment - See under “Civil Procedure”.
Adjournment of Appeal - See under “Civil Procedure”.
G. Ladas, for the Appellant.
Chr. Demetriades, for the Respondent.
DECISION
The decision of the Court was delivered by:-
TRIANTAFYLLIDES. P.: This is an appeal [*1066] against that part of an order for the custody of the two elder out of the three minor children of the parties which allows the said two children to be taken to Greece in order to stay there with their father, the respondent, for a “period between 15-17 days during the summer months only”.
The order appealed from was made on June 12, 1976; the appeal, by the mother of the children, was filed on June 25, 1976, and on July 2, 1976, notice was given to the parties that the appeal had been fixed for hearing on September 27, 1976.
Then, on July 10, 1976, counsel for the respondent applied that this appeal be heard as an urgent one during this Court’s summer vacation. As a result, it was fixed for hearing today.
In the meantime, the appellant applied ex parte on July 1, 1976, to the trial court for a stay of execution, pending the outcome of this appeal, of the complained of part of the custody order, and such stay was ordered on July 8, 1976. It appears that the respondent’s side came to know only today of the order for stay of execution.
As the issue of the possibility of obtaining the said order for stay of execution from the trial court has not been raised at all in argument before us in this appeal, we shall make no pronouncement, of any kind, in this connection.
Today counsel for the appellant has applied for an adjournment of the appeal on the ground that another counsel, also retained by the appellant to appear for her [*1067] in the appeal, and who did not appear before the trial court, is absent abroad; counsel for the appellant has explained that a second counsel was retained by his client because of, inter alia, the delicate position in which counsel for the appellant had found himself due to his efforts, at the trial, to reconcile the parties as regards their dispute about access to their children; counsel for the appellant has stressed that, in the circumstances, he feels that it is essential that this appeal should not be heard in the absence of the second counsel who has been retained by his client.
It was, further, stated, in support of the application for an adjournment, that there is involved in this appeal the rather serious issue of whether the trial court could have made an order allowing the children to go to Greece where they would be outside the jurisdiction of the Cyprus Courts.
On the other hand, counsel for the respondent has argued that if the appeal is not proceeded with - and in view of the existence of the order staying execution - the respondent will, in effect, be deprived completely of the possibility of having the children with him in Greece during this year’s summer, for the prescribed in the custody order period, and, thus, grave hardship will be caused to him; we were told that the respondent is a very busy man and it is practically impossible for him to come to Cyprus in order to spend any time with his children here.
We have weighed all the elements involved in the very difficult situation before us, and we have decided, not without some difficulty, that we should not refuse the adjournment of the hearing of the appeal applied for by the [*1068] appellant, but that we should grant it on condition that, if the appellant is going to take advantage of the order for stay of execution, which was granted ex parte by the trial court (with the result that the children will not leave Cyprus during the current summer), she will be bound to allow them to stay here with the parents of the respondent, or with either of them, for a period of 15-17 days to be specified by the respondent, who will be, of course, at liberty to come and stay with them during such period for as long as he may be. able to do so.
If the respondent does not want to have the above condition implemented then, depending on the outcome of this appeal, he will be at liberty to exercise his right of taking the children to Greece later on for a period of 15-17 days at any suitable time during the year.
The appeal will be heard on September 23, 1976, at 4.15 p.m.
If respondent wishes to take any proceedings before the trial court in relation to the stay of execution, which was granted ex parte, he is not in any way precluded from doing so in the meantime.
The question of costs for today shall be decided at the end of the proceedings.
Order accordingly.