Supreme Court dismisses constitutional challenge to army promotions where discretionary powers were reasonably exercised.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe applicant, a Sergeant, challenged the validity of his colleagues' promotions to 2nd Lieutenant under Article 146 of the Constitution. He argued that his seniority and better performance in training courses entitled him to promotion, yet the Council of Ministers appointed others without recommending him. The court upheld the appointments, ruling that the respondents' discretionary powers were exercised reasonably given the circumstances.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IASection 5(1) of the Army of the Republic (Constitution and Enlistment) Law, 1961; Article 146 of the Constitution: Discretionary powers of the Council of Ministers in appointing officers are valid if exercised reasonably, even if an interested party with seniority is not recommended.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1930] 1973 April 14
(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, P.)
REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution
Nicolaos Ayiomamitis,
Applicant,
and
The Republic of Cyprus, through
1. The Council of Ministers,
2. The Minister of Interior and. Defence,
Respondent.
(Case No. 125/68).
Army of the Republic (Constitution and Enlistment) Law, 1961 (Law 8/61) Appointments of 2nd Lieutenants - Validity
- Seniority in the Army - How established - Interested parties recommended for promotion - Applicant not so recommended - Discretionary powers of the respondents, in appointing interested parties, exercised in a manner which was, in the circumstances; reasonably open to them.
L. Papaghilippou, for the Applicant.
L. Loucaides, Senior Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
The following judgment was delivered by:
TRIANTAFYLLIDES, .:The applicant, who is a Sergeant in the Cyprus Army, challenges by this recourse the validity of the appointments as 2nd Lieutenants of Ch. Phacouras and C. Pissarides (who are the “interested parties” in these proceedings). [*1931]
The said appointments were published on March 21,1968 (see exhibit 5).
Under section 5(1) of the Army of the Republic (Constitution and Enlistment) Law, 1961 (Law 8/61) the appointments of all commissioned and non-commissioned officers are made by the Council of Ministers; but by a decision (No.4545), reached on March 18, 1965, the Council of Ministers delegated its relevant powers to the Minister of Defence, subject to his decision, on each particular occasion, being approved by the Council.
On February.15, I968, the Council of Ministers considered proposals (see exhibit 8) made by the Minister of Defence (who was the Minister of Interior acting, also, as Minister of Defence) for appointments to, inter alia, the rank of 2nd Lieutenant. These proposals were the same as those made in this respect to the Minister by the Commander of the Cyprus Army, after consulting his senior military advisers.
It should be pointed out, at this stage, by way of a parenthesis, that in the said proposals there appears the name of “C. Pissarides”, who was recommended for appointment as a Sergeant; it is common ground that he as, actually, a different person from interested party
C. Pissarides.
As it appears from official records which were produced before me (see exhibit 6) the applicant protested against the appointments, of the interested [*1932] parties on the ground that he was senior, as regards length of service, to both of them, and that when all three of them participated in a special training course he completed it 9th in order of merit, whereas the interested parties were 31st and 17th, respectively.
His present recourse to this Court has been based on substantially the same grounds.
The applicant and the two interested parties went originally, on enlistment, in 1961, through a course for non-commissioned officers, and on completing it they were given the rank of Corporal. Later on, in 1965, all three of them - having become by then Sergeants - followed the aforementioned special training course.
As was stated in evidence by Lieutenant-Colonel A. Myrianthopoullos, of the Cyprus Army, the 1961 course was of such a nature that, in accordance with established military practice, the quality of the performance of the participants in that course established their seniority in the Army; on the other hand, the 1965 course was only a refresher course; but, of course, performance during that later course was, also, taken into account for purposes of selection for promotion to higher rank.
It is not in dispute that in the 1961 course the applicant was rated as 18th, whereas the interested parties were rated as 14th and 10th, respectively.
It has, also, been stated in the Opposition - and it has not been disputed - that on three occasions when the applicant and the interested parties appeared [*1933] before Selection Committees the interested parties were rated as better than the applicant; the last such occasion was in April, 1967.
Interested party Phacouras was recommended to the Council of Ministers, for appointment as 2nd Lieutenant, both by the Commander and by the Minister. Interested party Pissarides was not recommended for such appointment by the Commander or the Minister on this occasion, but he had been so recommended by the Commander to the Minister, on a previous occasion, about a year earlier (see exhibit 10). The applicant was not recommended at all on either occasion.
From all the relevant material, which has been placed before me, including what has been already specifically referred to in this judgment, it appears that the appointments of the interested parties were made as a result of the exercise by the respondents of their discretionary powers in a manner Which was, in the circum stances, reasonably open to them; and that being so I have to uphold the said appointmehts as having been made validly; therefore, this recourse fails and is dismissed accordingly; but there shall be made no order as to costs against the applicant.
Application dismissed.
No order as to costs.