Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Georghios Char. Fellas and Another v. Elenitsa I. Votsi and Another (1975) JSC 1696 Generato dall'IA

Court partially allowed appeal, varying security amount from £200 to £400 due to garnishee attachment.

Numero d'incarto Georghios Char. Fellas and Another v. Elenitsa I. Votsi and Another (1975) JSC 1696
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Court of Appeal set aside a default judgment and granted leave to defend, but varied the security condition from £200 to £400. The trial court wrongly fixed the security at £200 despite a £400 bank deposit attached via garnishee proceedings and a claim exceeding £1,100. The court held that while it would not interfere with the discretion to set aside the default judgment, the security amount must reflect the available assets to ensure fairness.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Civil Procedure Act; Civil Procedure Rules: Where a default judgment is set aside and leave to defend is granted, the court has discretion to impose security conditions, but this discretion must be exercised reasonably to ensure the security is adequate to meet the claim and any attached assets.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
default judgment security for costs garnishee proceedings judicial discretion appeal interference civil procedure bank deposit requisiti patrimoniali

Giurisprudenza citata

Generato dall'IA
Evans v. Bartlam (1937) 2 All E.R. 646
Ioannis Kotsapas & Sons Ltd. v. Titan Construction and Engineering Co. (1961) C.L.R. 317
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*1696] 1975 June 23

(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, P., STAVRINIDES, L. LOIZOU, JJ.)

APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Georghios - Char. Fellas and Another,

Appellants,

v.

Elenitsa I. Votsi and Another,

Respondents.

(Civil Appeal No.5418).

Civil Procedure Judgment in default of appearance - Setting aside of - Discretion of trial Court - Appeal - Principles on which Court of Appeal will interfere with such discretion - Claim for £1100 – Bank deposit of £400 to the credit of defendant 1 standing attached by means of garnishee proceedings

- Leave to defend upon payment into Court of £200 by way of security - Trial Court’s discretion wrongly exercised in relation to amount of the security - Said amount increased to £400.

M. Vassiliou, for the Appellants.

P. Maxioutis, for the Respondents.

JUDGMENT

The judgment of the Court was delivered by; --

TRIANTAFYLLIDES. P.: In the present case [*1697] the appellants (who are plaintiffs in the action before the trial Court) appeal against an order of such Court by virtue of which a judgment for the payment to the appellants by the respondents (who are the defendants in the said action) of. the sum of C£1100 was set aside, as having, been obtained default of appearance, and leave was given to the respondents defend the action, on condition that within fourteen days respondent l would pay into Court the sum of C£200 by way of security, in case the appellants, obtain once again judgment against the respondents; the respondents, were ordered, also, to pay the costs of the application to set aside the judgment obtained in default of appearance.

A noteworthy feature of this case is that at. the material time there was deposited with the Bank of Cyprus, to the credit of respondent l, the sum of C£400, which had been attached by means of garnishee proceedings, which were still pending before the trial Court, and yet the trial Court directed that only C£200 should be paid into Court by way of security, even though, as it

appears from the judgment obtained in default, the claim in the action was for a sum. exceeding by far not only the amount of

C£200, but that of C£400 as well.

Having in mind what has been stated about interfering on appeal with the exercise of judicial discretion in, inter alia, the case of Evans v. Bartlam. (1937) 2 All E.R. 646, 654, as well as in our own case of Ioannis Kotsapas & Sons Ltd., v. Titan Construction and Engineering Co., (1961) C.L.R. 317, we are not prepared, on the basis of [*1698] the record before us, to interfere with the decision of the trial judge that the judgment obtained in default of appearance should be set aside and that leave should be given to the respondents to defend the action; but we do think that the discretion of the judge was wrongly exercised in relation to the condition for the security to be given by respondent 1; the amount to be lodged in Court should not have been only C£200, but the full amount of C£400, which was the subject of the garnishee proceedings, and which is still inadequate to meet the claim of the appellants, if they are successful in the action.

We have, therefore, decided to vary the order appealed from by directing that within two months from today the respondents, or either of them, should pay into Court in all C£400, by way of security, and that only upon this condition being satisfied the order setting aside the judgment obtained in default of appearance and giving leave to defend shall become operative; otherwise, the said judgment shall remain in force and in such case the C£200, which has already been lodged in Court, is to be paid to the appellants in part satisfaction of the judgment.

Regarding the costs of this appeal, we shall let each party bear its own costs, because of the special family relationship which exists between the parties to the action

Appeal partly allowed. Each party to bear its own costs.