Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Elenitsa Pavlou Stefanidou v. Georghios Loizou Pirgoti (1975) JSC 1693 Generato dall'IA

Cypriot Supreme Court dismisses appeal on contract claim jurisdiction, holding cause of action arose in Nicosia District.

Numero d'incarto Elenitsa Pavlou Stefanidou v. Georghios Loizou Pirgoti (1975) JSC 1693
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's appeal against a District Court decision setting aside a writ of summons. The respondent claimed the cause of action arose in Larnaca District, but the court found no evidence the contract was concluded there or that payment was to be made outside Nicosia. Relying on established case law, the court held that without an agreement to the contrary, a debtor must seek their creditor at their place of residence or business, which was in Nicosia. Consequently, the Nicosia District Court possessed territorial jurisdiction, and the appeal was rejected with costs.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Section 21 of the Courts of Justice Law, 1960; In the absence of an agreement specifying otherwise, a debtor is bound to seek their creditor at the creditor's place of residence or business, thereby establishing territorial jurisdiction in that district for contract claims.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
territorial jurisdiction contract claim services place of business cause of action location Civil Procedure Rules District Court authority setting aside writ stato richiedente

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Section 21 of the Courts of Justice Law, 1960 (Law 14 of 1960)
Section 49 of the Contract Law

Giurisprudenza citata

Generato dall'IA
Theofanous v. Georghiou (1969) 1 C.L.R. 203
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*1693] 1975 April 24

(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, P., STAVRINIDES, HADJIANASTASSIOU, JJ.)

APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Elenitsa Pavlou Stefanidou,

Appellant,

v.

Georghios Loizou Pirgoti,

Respondent.

(Civil Appeal No.5312).

Jurisdiction - Territorial Jurisdiction - Cause of action - Contract Claim for services rendered - Nothing on record to show where contract was concluded - No place of payment specified in the contract either expressly or by implication - Creditor residing and having his place of business within Nicosia District - Debtor bound, in the absence of any agreement to the contrary, to seek his creditor at his place of residence or at his place of business Objection as to jurisdiction of the District Court of Nicosia fails Section 21 of the Courts of Justice Law, 1960 (Law 14 of 1960) - Theofanous v. Georghiou (1969) 1 C.L.R. 203 at p. 205 followed.

Contract - Claim for services rendered Jurisdiction – Territorial - Jurisdiction - See, also, under “Jurisdiction”

Per Curiam; The proper remedy inview, of the appellant’s contention that the action had been filed in the wrong District Court, was not to set aside the writ in the action, but to apply that the proceedings therein be stayed, in accordance with, rule 10 of . Order 33, of the Civil Procedure Rules.

A. Demetriou, for the Appellant.

A. Emilianides, for the Respondent.

JUDGMENT

The judgment of the Court was delivered by:-

TRIANTAFYLLIDES. P.: In this case the appellant [*1694] (who is the defendant in action No. 3181/72 before the District Court of Nicosia) - appeals against a

decision of a judge of such District Court by means of. which there was dismissed an application by her for the setting aside of the writ of summons in the said action on the ground that the District Court of Nicosia lacked Jurisdiction, inasmuch as the cause of action, if any, arose within the area of the territorial jurisdiction of the District Court of Larnaca.

The claim of the plaintiff in the action (who is the respondent in the present appeal) - is for an amount of C£302.500 mils as remuneration for services rendered by the respondent to the appellant in the form of the preparation by him of the plans of a house to be built by her.

The appellant denies that she ever instructed the respondent to prepare such plans, but we are not concerned in this appeal with the merits of the action.

Counsel for the appellant has submitted that, essentially, the complaint of the respondent is that the appellant decided not to build the house for which he had prepared the plans and that, therefore, the cause of action, if any, arose in Larnaca District where the house was going to be built.

We cannot uphold the above submission: This is a case in which it is claimed by the respondent that a sum of money is due, to him under a contract; as there is nothing on record to show where the contract was concluded and as no agreement, express or implied, specifying [*1695] a lace of payment outside Nicosia District, has been alleged to exist, it follows, in accordance with What has been stated in Theofanous v. Georghiou,

(1969) 1 C.L.R. 203, at P. 205, that in applying the provisions of section 21 of the Courts of Justice Law, 1960 (Law 14/60), we are bound to hold that the cause of action, if any, has arisen in Nicosia District, as a debtor is bound, in the absence of any agreement to the contrary, to seek his creditor at his place of residence or at his place of business, and the respondent resides and has his place of business within the limits, of Nicosia District (see, too, Section 49 of our Contract Law, Can. 149; Dutt on The Indian Contract Act, 4th ed., p. 428 - section 49 of the said. Indian Act being the same as section 49 of Cap. 149; as well as Chitty on Contracts, 23rd ed., vol. 1, p. 552, paragraph 1166).

In the light of the foregoing we cannot uphold the contention that the Nicosia District Court did not possess territorial jurisdiction to deal with the action concerned and. this appeal is dismissed accordingly with costs.

Before concluding we would like to observe that it seems to us that the proper remedy, in case the appellant’s view that the action had been filed in the wrong District Court was correct, was not to set aside the writ in the action, but to apply that the proceedings therein be stayed, in accordance with rule 10 of Order 33, of the Civil Procedure Rules.

Appeal dismissed with costs.