Supreme Court allows appeal where driver's sudden stop and shout prove due care despite missing pedestrian.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the appellant's conviction for careless driving. The appellant argued that his immediate stop and verbal warning demonstrated due care, while the prosecution contended that failing to sound the horn was negligent. The court held that the appellant's conduct was consistent with a prudent driver given the sudden nature of the pedestrian's movement and the lack of prior warning.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IASection 8 of the Motor Vehicles and Road Traffic Law, 1972; A driver's conduct is not inconsistent with that of a reasonably prudent driver if they stop and warn immediately upon seeing a pedestrian approaching suddenly, and failure to sound a horn does not prove driving without due care and attention.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1264] 1975 September 10
(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, P., A. LOIZOU, MAIACHTOS, JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Andreas Pitsillides
Appellant,
v
The Police,
Respondents.
(Criminal Appeal No. 3633).
Road Traffic - Careless driving - Section 8 of the Motor Vehicles and Road Traffic Law, 1972 (Law 86/72) - Pedestrian .knocked down when he suddenly stepped backwards whilst standing near parked car and whilst driver was driving past at a distance of about two metres from said car - Driver stopping and shouting as soon as he saw pedestrian coming towards him - Driver’s conduct not inconsistent with that of a prudent driver - Failure to sound his horn did not suffice in order to say that it was proved that he was driving without due care and attention.
St. Erotocritou, (Mrs.), for the Appellant.
Gl. Michaelides, far the Respondents.
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the Court was delivered by:-
TRIANTAFYLLIDES. P; The appellant was [*1265] convicted of the offence of driving a motor vehicle without due care and attention, contrary to section 8 of the Motor Vehicles and Road Traffic Law, 1972 (Law 86/72).
The facts of the case are that on the 27th June, 1974, as the appellant was driving a pick-up, No. HB 813, in a street in Nicosia, he noticed a car parked to his left side and a man talking to its driver. As the appellant was driving past, at a distance of about two metres from the parked car, the said man stepped suddenly backwards and collided with the left side of the vehicle of the appellant.
There is no suggestion, nor was it so found by the trial judge, that the appellant had had any prior indication, by any behaviour on the part of the complainant or otherwise, that he was about to step backwards; also, the trial judge accepted the version of the appellant that as soon as he saw the complainant coming towards his car he called out to him and stopped; but, nevertheless, the collision was not averted.
The trial judge found, however, the appellant guilty of the offence in question because he did not sound his horn before driving past the complainant or when he saw him stepping backwards.
In Simpson v. Peat, (1952) 1 All E.R. 447, 449, Lord Goddard C.J. said: “If, on the other hand, the circumstances “show that his conduct was not inconsistent with that of a reasonably prudent driver, the case has not been proved”; [*1266] and, taking into account that the appellant had no indication that the complainant was about to step backwards and that the appellant drove past the stationary car and the complainant leaving the sufficient clearance of about two metres, as well as that he stopped and shouted as soon as he saw the complainant coming towards him, we are of the view that the appellant’s conduct was not inconsistent with that of a prudent driver and that his failure to sound his horn did not suffice in order to say that it was proved that he Was driving without due care and attention.
This appeal is, therefore, allowed and the conviction of the appellant is set aside.
Appeal allowed.