Court grants leave to amend defence and counterclaim despite delay and mala fide claims due to materiality and fairness.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court granted the defendant's application to amend the Statement of Defence and Counterclaim, rejecting the plaintiffs' objections regarding undue delay and bad faith. Although the amendment sought to recharacterize the transaction from a building contract to a revoked gift, the judge found the proposed changes material and necessary to present the defendant's full case. The decision emphasized that refusing the amendment would unjustly preclude the defendant from presenting their evidence and that the plaintiffs were given a full opportunity to respond to the new allegations.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IACivil Procedure; Amendment of pleadings; Leave granted where amendment is material and necessary, no undue delay exists, and no injustice will be caused to the other party by granting leave to amend.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*861] 1974 January
(STYLIANIDES, P.D.C.)
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OP NICOSIA
Papachristoforos Christoforou.
Applicant Defendant,
and
Yiola Skaliotou and Another,
Respondents Plaintiffs.
(Action No. 31 27/72).
Civil Procedure - Pleadings - Amendment - No undue delay - Intended amendment not made mala fide - Proposed amendment material and necessary - Full opportunity given to the other parties to meet new situation- And no injustice will he caused to them fry granting leave to amend - Application granted.
Pleadings - Amendment - See under "Civil Procedure".
G. Ladas, for the Applicant.,
J . Papaphilippou, for the Respondents.
RULING
The following ruling was delivered by;-
STYLIANIDES, P. D, C. The Applicant/Defendant seeks leave to amend the Statement of Defence and Counterclaim.
The Plaintiffs/Respondents oppose this application on the following grounds:-
(a) The Applicant is guilty of undue delay.
(b) The application is made mala fide. [*862]
(c) The amendment asked, is irrelevant, unnecessary and useless.
The Plaintiffs are the Chairman, the
Secretary of the Benevolent Association “Σωματείον Κοινωνικής Μερίμνης Αγίων μολογητών”.
The Defendant at the material time was the parish priest of Ay. Omoloyitae.
The Plaintiffs’ claim in this action is for damages for breach of contract dated 9/7/71 for the erection of a building for housing the said Association.
The writ of summons was issued on 30/5/72; the Statement of Claim was filed on 5/9/72; the Statement of Defence and Counterclaim was filed on 6/12/72.
In paragraph 2 of the Defence the execution of the deeds, dated 9/7/71, was admitted but it was averred that in law there is not a valid contract for want of consideration.
Paragraph 3 of the same pleading reads: -
“Furthermore the defendant contends that the intention of the parties, the contents of the deed and what was exchanged before and after the signing of the deed prove that the defendant undertook to make a gift to the association and (therefore) no actionable right was created”.
By the Counterclaim the Defendant asks for declaration that the agreement of 9/7/71 is void for lack of consideration and/or it is a promise to make a gift which was [*863] revoked by the Defendant.
On 12/12/72 the Plaintiffs took out a summons praying that the following points he disposed of by the Court:-
(a) The validity of the written agreement dated 9/7/71.
(b) Whether the non-performance by the Defendant of the said agreement is a breach of contract.
On 13/2/73 the Defendant changed his advocate. On 24/2/73 the application for leave to amend was filed. The amendment sought was formulated and specifically stated in the application. The applicant asks for the substitution of paragraph 2 by a new paragraph, the insertion of a new paragraph namely 3(a) and 3(b), the amendment of paragraph 4 and the prayer in the Counterclaim.
In the course of his address counsel for the Respondents consented to the amendment of the Counterclaim, paragraph 4, the addition of 3(b) (iv) and 3(b) (v), part of 3( a) and part of paragraph 2.
The part of the new paragraphs 2, 3(a) and 3(b) objected to contain allegations of facts which took place prior to and led to the signing of the documents on which this action is based.
The application is based on Order 25 which corresponds to the old English Order 28.
As a general rule, either party is allowed to make any such amendment as is reasonably necessary for the due [*864] presentation of his case, on payment of the costs of and occasioned by the amendment, provided there has been no undue delay on his part, and provided also the amendment will not injure or affect any vested rights of his opponent.
But if the application be made mala fide, or if the proposed amendment will cause undue delay, or will in any other way unfairly prejudice the other party, or is irrelevant or useless, or would raise merely a technical point, leave to amend will be refused. (Annual Practice, 1963 p. 622: Odgers on Pleadings and Practice; 30 Halsburys Laws of England, 3rd ed. p. 33-35).
Undue Delay
Though an amendment may be made at any stage of the proceedings (0.25 r.l), the amendment should be made as soon as the necessity arises. (Rainy v. Bravo (1872) L.R. 4 P.C., 287). A slight delay is not a sufficient ground for refusing leave. Before hearing, leave is readily granted, unless the other party will be placed in a worse position than he would have been if the amended pleading had been delivered in the first instance. (Steward v. North Hetropolitan TramWays Co., 16 Q.B.D. 556). The applicant is not guilty of undue delay, neither will the amendment cause undue delay.
The intended amendment, having regard to all the circumstances, is not made mala fide.
Every pleading must state material facts only (0.19 r.4) [*865]
“The word ’material’ means necessary for the purpose of formulating a complete cause of act ion, and if any one 'material' fact is omitted, the statement of claim is had. (Per Scott L. J., in Bruce v. Odham Press- Ltd., (1/36) 1 K.B. at p. 712)”.
The Defence and Counterclaim
challenge the validity of the Agreement embodied in the documents dated 9.7.71. In the proposed amendment allegations of facts are made tending to prove that these documents did not
intend to and do not contain the whole agreement between the parties. They tend to show that the nature of the transaction is not a building contract but an agreement to make a gift
which has been revoked; that the legal relationship of the parties is different to the one alleged by the Plaintiffs.
Every party must state his whole case. He must plead all the material facts on which he means to rely otherwise he is not entitled to give any evidence to them at the trial- (Phillips v. P., 4 Q.B.D.). A. Defendant may plead any facts which he is entitled to prove.
If the Defendant be not allowed to amend his defence he will not be in a position to present his case before the Court.
In an application for leave to amend, the Court has to bear in mind that, for the sake of justice, the Court should have before it the real questions to be tried. [*866]
The proposed amendment is material and necessary, if admissible, according to the rules of evidence. Mr. Ladas submitted that it is admissible and referred me to various passages in Phipson on Evidence.
I shall not embark on the admissibility of extrinsic evidence in this particular case. I do not wish to prejudice the issue in case objection is taken before the trial Court.
For the purposes of this application only, I find that the submission of Mr. Ladas is legally sound.
To sum up, the proposed amendment is material and necessary; steps for the amendment were taken as early as possibler full opportunity is given to the ether parties to meet the new situation no injustice will be caused to the Other side by granting leave to amend as applied; refusal of the application is tantamount to precluding the Applicant from presenting his case before the Court.
In the light of the foregoing, leave for amendment is granted as applied for Applicant to pay the costs of the Respondents in the application and any costs thrown away. Such costs to be assessed by the Registrar.
Application granted.
Order for costs as above.