Supreme Court allows appeal, increasing general damages for road accident injuries from £400 to £800.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court allowed the appellant's appeal against the trial court's award of £400 in general damages for a road accident. The appellant suffered painful crushing injuries, including a wrist fracture and cerebral concussion, resulting in permanent residual deformity and psychological symptoms. The court found the original sum clearly inadequate given the severity of pain, suffering, and lasting after-effects, thereby increasing the award to £800.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IACivil Procedure Act; Damages Act: Where general damages for personal injury are appealed, the court may intervene if the awarded sum is clearly inadequate in relation to the degree of pain, suffering, and permanent after-effects sustained.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*330] 1973 November 12
(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, P., A. LOIZOU, MALACHTOS JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Andreas Mesimeris,
Appellant-Plaintiff,
v.
Costas Kakoullis,
Respondent-Defendant.
(Civil Appeal No.5085).
Damages - General damages - Road accident - Principles on which Court approaches appeals concerning-amount of general damages - Painful crushing injuries including fracture of left wrist, cerebral concussion and lacerated wound on the scalp - After-effects being, inter alia, a mild residual deformity of left wrist and a mild deficit in the strength of the left hand - Amount of £400 clearly inadequate - Increased to £800.
A. Panayiotou, for the Appellant.
N. Pelides, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the Court was delivered by:-
TRIANTAFYLLIDES. P.: In this case [*331] the appellant - (plaintiff in the Court below) - complains against that part of the judgment of the trial Court which relates to the award to him of £400 as general damages; he contends that this amount is, in the circumstances of this case, inadequate.
The trial Court in assessing the general damages stated the following, in its judgment:
“Having in mind that this plaintiff has sustained not very serious injuries; that he has suffered, however, pain and suffering, mild dizziness and headaches, a Colles’ fracture
of his left wrist, the opinion of Dr. Pelides” - (an orthopaedic surgeon) – “as to the present condition of the plaintiff and the fact that he
has not alleged that he will suffer any loss of future earnings, we find that the appropriate amount to be awarded as general damages is the sum of £400”.
The injuries of the appellant were caused in a traffic collision; and there is no dispute about the liability of the respondent to compensate in this respect the appellant.
As it appears from a medical report, the appellant, who was at the time thirty-two years old, was found on admission to hospital to have sustained “a number of painful crushing injuries” which were, mainly: Cerebral concussion (as a result of which he remained in a dazed condition for three days.), lacerated wound scalp haematomason [*332] both eyelids, bruising of the left chest wall and left leg, and a fracture, as already mentioned, of his left wrist. He was kept as an in-patient for ten days and he was under follow up treatment for eight weeks.
According to the final report of a clinical psychologist, the appellant has “moderate permanent residual post-concussional in nature ‘symptoms’ reinforced, however, by psychological factors; though they do not constitute a debilitating condition, they appear to cause much discomfort and affect to some extent his work efficiency and work output”.
According to the .final report of the orthopaedic surgeon, the after-effects of appellant’s injuries are a mild residual deformity of the left wrist coupled with a small restriction of the left forearm’s rotation range and a mild deficit in the strength of the left hand.
The principle upon which this Court approaches appeals concerning the amount of general damages has been reiterated in quite a number of cases, two of which were cited by counsel in argument, i.e. Manoli v. Evripidou (1968) 1 C.L.R. 90, and Christodoulides v. Kyprianou, (1968) 1 C.L.R. 130. To the same effect are English cases such as Brown v. Thompson. (1968) 2 All E.R. 708, at p. 712, and George and Another v. Pinnock and Another. (1973) 1 W.L.R. 118, where Orr L.J. said (at p. 125) in dealing with an appeal in relation to the amount of general damages: [*333]
“ .... it is in my judgment near the lower end of the bracket which would be applicable today to injuries such as these, but I have not been satisfied that it is so low as to justify interference by this Court”.
We would not have been prepared to interfere in this case if we were of the view that the amount of general damages, £400, was on the low side but not so very low as to justify our intervention, We have reached, however, the conclusion that this is indeed a case in which we should, intervene because taking into account the degree of pain and suffering which the appellant’s injuries must have entailed, plus their already stated after-effects, we find the said amount to be clearly inadequate. As a result, we have decided that we should award him the amount of £800 general damages, and that the order for costs in the Court below should be altered so that the costs there should be assessed in the proper scale applicable to the new sum of damages.
The appeal is therefore allowed and the judgment of the lower Court is varied accordingly.
Appellant is entitled to the costs of this appeal.
Appeal allowed with costs.