Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
District Officer, Larnaca v. Andreas Plarkos (1975) JSC 236 Generato dall'IA

Court dismisses accused's defense that he is not an occupier, ruling the annual rate is legally imposed and payable.

Numero d'incarto District Officer, Larnaca v. Andreas Plarkos (1975) JSC 236
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The District Court of Larnaca dismissed the accused's criminal charge for failing to pay an annual rate assessed by the Village Health Commission. Although the accused argued he was not an 'occupier' under the Public Health (Villages) Law, the court found the rate legally imposed because the accused failed to appeal within the statutory 21-day limit or seek recourse under Article 146 of the Constitution. Consequently, the court ruled that the accused violated Regulation 99 and must defend himself against the charge, noting the lack of specific power to order payment directly.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Public Health (Villages) Law, Cap. 259; Village Health (Troulli) Rules, 1955: Failure to appeal an annual rate assessment within the prescribed statutory period or to seek constitutional recourse renders the imposition legal and the sum duly payable, precluding a defense based on the accused's status as an occupier.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
annual rate assessment occupier status defense statutory appeal period constitutional recourse failure public health law criminal charge dismissal village commission powers allontanamento nonostante motivi di salute

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Public Health (Villages) Law, Cap. 259
charge sheet cites sections 9(1)(c)(i) and 11 of the Public Health (Villages) Law, Cap. 259, and Rules 94 and 99 of the Village Health (Troulli) Rules,
Village Health (Troulli) Rules, 1955
259 - Imposition of annual rate under sections 9(1) (c) (i) and 11 of the law and rules 94 and 99 of the Village Health (Troulli) Rules, 1955 - No appeal against imposition as laid down by the said Law and Rules - And no recourse under Article 146 of the Constitution - Imposition a legal one and duly payable
Article 146 of the Constitution
259 - Imposition of annual rate under sections 9(1) (c) (i) and 11 of the law and rules 94 and 99 of the Village Health (Troulli) Rules, 1955 - No appeal against imposition as laid down by the said Law and Rules - And no recourse under Article 146 of the Constitution - Imposition a legal one and duly payable
Tax Collection Law, Law 31 of 1962
This law is the Tax Collection Law, Law 31 of 1962, and the Prosecutor may proceed according to the provisions of that law.

Giurisprudenza citata

Generato dall'IA
Shaw v. D.P.P. (1961) 2 All E.R. 466
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*236] 1973 August 11

(ARTEMIDES, D.J.)

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF LARNACA

District Officer, Larnaca, against

Andreas Plarkos,

Accused.

(Case No. 3479/73).

Public Health (Villages) Law, Cap.

259 - Imposition of annual rate under sections 9(1) (c) (i) and 11 of the law and rules 94 and 99 of the Village Health (Troulli) Rules, 1955 - No appeal against imposition as laid down by the said Law and Rules - And no recourse under Article 146 of the Constitution - Imposition a legal one and duly payable

- Defence that accused not an “occupier” within the meaning of section 9(2) of the law cannot be entertained.

C. Paraskevas, for the Prosecution.

G Achilles, for the Accused.

RULING

The following ruling was delivered by:

ARTEMIDES. D.J.: Accused is facing a criminal charge [*237] for failing to pay to the Village Health Commission of Troulli the amount of £10.- being the annual rate assessed on him for the year 1972. The

charge sheet cites sections 9(1)(c)(i) and 11 of the Public Health (Villages) Law, Cap. 259, and Rules 94 and 99 of the Village Health (Troulli) Rules,

1955 as being the relevant provision on which the charge is based.

The relevant facts of the case for the purpose of this judgment may be put briefly as follows:-

Accused has been granted a privilege to extract chavara and shingle from government land which is within the boundaries under the administration of the village commission of Troulli. The evidence adduced established that accused used the aforementioned privilege in the year in question and extracted chavara and shingle, which was loaded on lorries belonging to him and transferred to its final destination. Accused does not reside in Troulli village; he lives in Livadhia village.

At the close of the case for the prosecution counsel for accused submitted that no prima facie case was made out in that, on the facts as same have been put forward by the prosecution, accused was not an “occupier” within the meaning ascribed to the word by sub section 2 of section 9 of the Public Health (Villages) Law. Prosecution counsel submitted the opposite, but in view of the fact that neither counsel supported their submission on authority, I adjourned the case to another date in order [*238] to facilitate them to look into the matter and assist the Court properly. Some further argument was advanced by both sides in. support of their relevant submissions, but as the case has finally fell to be decided on other issues, I leave the matter entirely open to be decided in another case, if such need arises.

Counsel for the prosecution in his address submitted that accused could not put forward any defence because, and as provided for by subsection 3(a) (b) of section 9 of the law, he did not appeal within the prescribed limit of 21 days against the imposition of the rate to the District Officer, who is authorised to inquire into the justice of the assessment and whose decision thereon is final.

Counsel further submitted that the power of the Village Health Commission to impose annual rates falls within the domain of public law and its relevant act is an administrative one, subject only to a recourse under Article 146 of the Constitution. Since accused has not invoked the procedure laid down by subsection 3(a) and (b) and his rights under Article 146 of the Constitution he has no defence to the charge and hence, as counsel has put it, “he is guilty as charged and should be ordered to pay the rate levied on him, i.e. the sum of £10.-”.

That the decision of the village Health Commission to impose annual rates is an administrative act there is no doubt. Therefore, any complaint against such decision [*239] should be made by way of a recourse filed in the Supreme Court.

Another issue, which was touched slightly and feel it my duty to deal with, is whether the relevant legal provisions cited in the charge sheet and alleged to have been violated by accused, create any offence. Has accused committed any offence by failing to pay the annual rate levied on him under any legal provision and which therefore may be the subject of criminal proceedings?

In order to answer the above question, I consider it pertinent to dwell as briefly as possible on the theory as to what is a crime. In Russell on crimes, (11th edition), at page 18 one reads:-

“To define crime is a task which so far has not been satisfactorily accomplished by any writer. In fact, criminal offences are basically the creation of the criminal policy adopted from time to time by those sections of the community who are powerful or astute enough to safeguard their own security and comfort by causing the sovereign power in the state to repress conduct which they feel may endanger their position. But a crime may be described, although not defined, as a result of human conduct (active or passive) which it is the policy of the governing power in the state to prevent.”

“This prevention is nowadays mostly sought [*240] through the deterrent effect of a threatened suffering, punishment, after accusation against him has been investigated in legal proceedings of a special kind. The outstanding characteristics of a crime therefore, in modern times are that it normally results in punishment and that a special legal procedure is followed in deciding on the guilt of the accused person”.

Lord Atkin put the situation very briefly in the case of Proprietary Articles Trade Association v. Attorney-General for Canada. (1931)A.C. 324(P.C ). He said, “The criminal quality of an act cannot be discerned by intuition nor can be discovered by reference to any standard but one: is the act prohibited with penal consequences”.

A principle that for centuries is embedded in English criminal law and has always been considered as fundamental is that no-one shall be made to suffer except for a distinct breach of criminal law, which law is laid down in precise and definite terms (nulla poena sine lege). A relevant case underlining that principle is the old case of R. v. Price (1884) 12 Q.B.D., in which the accused was charged for attempting to burn the body of his child instead of burying it. Stephen J., in his charge to the Grand Jury told them that the burning instead, of the burying of a dead body did not amount to a criminal act, unless the burning amounted to a public nuisance. The great leading rule of criminal law is that nothing is a crime unless it is plainly [*241] forbidden by law. A more recent authority on the subject is that of Shaw v. D.P.P. (1961)

2 All E.R. 466, where it was held by the House of Lords that a count charging accused with “Conspiracy to corrupt public morals” was sustainable as such crime was known to English Common law. The Honourable members of the House of Lords decided by majority, that an agreement to commit certain acts, although not amounting to crimes, but which nevertheless are outrageously immoral so as to constitute public mischief, may amount to conspiracy.

In the present case, it is submitted that the failure of accused to pay the annual rate assessed on him by the Village Commission does amount to an offence in that it contravenes section 11 of the Law and the regulations made there under. Section 11 reads as follows:-

“Any person who contravenes any of the provisions of this law or any rule made thereunder, or who disobeys any lawful order of a Village Health Commission made in the performance of its duties or the exercise of its power under section 1, shall be guilty of an offence…..”.

Section 7 of the Law empowers the village Commissions to perform any of the duties and exercise any of the powers enumerated in that section and it relates, inter alia, to the duties and powers of the village commissions to see to the hygiene state of the village, to provide for markets and slaughter houses and generally to promote sanitation and [*242] cleanliness in the village. This section has no relevancy to the issue under consideration.

Section 9(1), however, empowers the Village Commissions to make regulations in order to provide for the imposition of an annual rate upon every occupier in the village. The village Commission of Troulli has adopted the regulations published in the Cyprus Gazette of 1952 No.515. The relevant regulations are contained in Part VIII under the title “Annual Rate” and regulation 99, expressly provides that the occupier whose name appears in the Occupier List shall on or before the 15th of October pay the amount of the annual rate assessed on him. Since accused has not invoked the procedure laid down by the relevant law and regulations to appeal against the

decision of the village Commission and has not filed a recourse under Article

146 of the Constitution the imposition of the rate is considered legal and the sum is duly payable. I cannot therefore entertain his defence that he is not an occupier within the meaning of subsection 2 of section 9 of the Law.

In the result accused has violated an express provision of the relevant regulation i.e. 99, made under the public Health (Villages) Law 259 and he is therefore called to defend himself.

I might as well however, say from now that I have no power under any enactment to order accused to pay the annual rate assessed on him. [*243]

A specific law provides for the procedure of collection of taxes, including rates, imposed by various public bodies under various enactments. This law is the Tax Collection Law, Law 31 of 1962, and the Prosecutor may proceed according to the provisions of that law.

Accused is therefore called to defend himself and his rights are explained to him.

Order accordingly.