Criminal appeal dismissed; Court of Appeal declined to vary sentence without sufficient reason despite social reports.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Court of Appeal dismissed the appellant's appeal against a five-month prison sentence for contradictory statements. The trial judge imposed the harsh penalty based on the witness's retraction and prior convictions, while the appellate court requested social investigation reports to better assess the offender. Ultimately, the court declined to interfere with the original sentence as no sufficient reason for intervention was demonstrated.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IASection 113(2) of the Criminal Code; Section 147(1) of the Courts of Justice Law: The Court of Appeal will not vary a sentence imposed by the trial court unless there is sufficient reason shown for such intervention, even when social investigation reports are available.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*515] 1970 March 5
(VASSILIADES, P., JOSEPHIDES, LOIZOU, JJ.)
APPELLIATE JURISDICTION
Nicolas Georghiou Ioannou,
Appellant,
v.
The Police,
Respondents.
(Criminal Appeal No. 3147).
Criminal Law
- Sentence - Five months' imprisonment for contradictory statement by a witness - Section 113(2) of the Criminal Code Cap. 154 - Appeal - No sufficient reason shown for intervention - Dismissed.
Court of Appeal - Sentence - Appeal
- Approach by Court of Appeal.
Criminal Law - Sentence - Social investigation reports - Desirability.
Appellant in person.
A. Frangos, Senior Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the Court was delivered by:
VASSILIADES P.: The appellant was convicted in the District Court of Nicosia on January 20, 1970, [*516] of the offence usually referred to as contradictory statement by a witness, contrary to section 113(2) of the Criminal Code, Cap. 154; and was sentenced to five months imprisonment. He took the present appeal against sentence on the ground that the term imposed by the trial Court is in the circumstances, manifestly excessive.
The particulars of the offence charged were that –
"... on November 20, 1969, at Nicosia ... being a witness in a case (for the possession of a pistol without a special permit) ....... against Nicos Charalambou Terlas ... and having made a statement to acting police sgt. 1444, M. Kouis, an investigating officer, subsequently on his examination as a witness in the summary trial (of the said Terlas) did make a statement tending to prove the innocence of (the said Terlas) contradictory to his first statement to acting P.S. 1444 M. Kouis."
At the trial the appellant appearing together with his advocate, pleaded guilty to the charge; and was convicted accordingly.
The short facts of the case as stated to the Court by the prosecuting police officer after appellant’s plea, are that the appellant having made a statement to the investigating officer named in the charge, to the effect that a fellow prisoner in the central prison had spoken to him regarding the possession of a pistol, retracted from that statement at the trial of the case. [*517]
After hearing appellant's advocate in mitigation, and after taking from the prosecuting officer information regarding appellant’s previous convictions, the trial Judge took the view, according to his notes, that the appellant had "committed a serious offence". He referred to Stelios HjiAgapiou Mavros v. The Police (1963) 1, C.L.R. 100; and noting that the alleged statement of the fellow prisoner amounted to an admission on his part for the possession of a prohibited dangerous weapon and was therefore "of importance in a criminal trial", the trial Judge reached the conclusion that imprisonment was the appropriate sentence; and imposed a term of five months imprisonment.
When the appeal came up for hearing before us on February 26, 1970, the appellant appeared in person. It soon became obvious that mere information regarding the appellant was necessary to enable the Court to deal with the only question arising in the appeal: Whether the sentence was, or was not, manifestly excessive. We, therefore, had to adjourn the hearing till March 5, 1970, to enable counsel for the prosecution to supply the Court with a social investigation report. The Prison Welfare Officer as well as a Social Investigation Officer prepared and filed in due course the reports which are now before us. Counsel for the prosecution and the appellant were duly supplied with copies.
The need for such information in connection with sentence was stressed on more than one occasions. In The Attorney-General v. Georghios Stavrou and others. 1962, [*518] C.L.R. 274, this Court referred to Kioftes v. The Republic (Criminal Appeal 2413, unreported) and repeated (at p.277) that -
"such reports are very useful where the offenders are young persons and the Court felt confident that all courts would avail themselves of such reports in appropriate cases. And it added that it is to be regretted that since then more than once this Court had to adjourn the hearing of an appeal against sentence, as we had to do in this case, in order to have such reports prepared and filed".
The need for pre-sentence information was also recently stressed by this Court. We shall only refer to a few recent cases. In Lambros Lazarou v. The Police (1969) 12, J.S.C. 1408, it was again found necessary to call for such information.
"In the instant case" (it was said at p. 1411) "the trial Judge did not have before him the full picture of the appellant as seen in the light of the medical and the social investigation reports obtained and admitted here under section 25(3) of the Courts of Justice Law (l4/60). In the light of these reports we think that the sentence must be varied to fit the offence as well as the offender. The matter is not free of difficulty, we gave it anxious consideration". [*519]
In Andreas Evangelοu v. The Police (Criminal Appeal 3149, decided on the 2nd April, 1970)*and in Demetris Kourris v. The Police (Criminal Appeal 3161, decided on the 14th May , 1970) the need for pre-sentence reports was again stressed, especially where the case seems to call for a severe sentence.
The responsibility, however, for measuring sentence rests primarily with the trial Court. This Court will only interfere on appeal, for sufficient cause shown. (Karaviotis v. The Police (1967) 11, J.S.C. 1264; Robert Pullen v. The Republic (1970) 4, J.S.C. 348 at 353). Considering the matter in the light of the information contained in the reports now before us, we have not reached the conclusion that we should interfere with the sentence imposed by the trial Judge. We cannot say what the effect of the information now before us, might be on the mind of the trial Judge if such information were placed before him when he was dealing with the question of sentence. But approaching this matter on the basis that this Court will not interfere with a sentence imposed by the trial Court unless there is sufficient reason for such intervention, we do not feel that in the circumstances of this case, including those pertaining to the accused, we should interfere with the sentence.
The appeal is, therefore, dismissed; the sentence to run according to law (sect. 147(1) of Cap. 155) from today.
Appeal dismissed.
* published in (1970) 5 J.S.C. 416.
published in (1970) 5 J.S.C. 498.