Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Elias Christofi v. The Republic of Cyprus, through the Public Service Commission. (1970) JSC 453 Generato dall'IA

Constitutional recourse dismissed because applicant lost legitimate interest after dismissal from post.

Numero d'incarto Elias Christofi v. The Republic of Cyprus, through the Public Service Commission. (1970) JSC 453
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The applicant sought to annul a Public Service Commission appointment under Article 146 of the Constitution, arguing his legitimate interest was harmed by another's selection. Although he initially held a post, he was dismissed for misconduct before the court hearing. The court ruled that a legitimate interest must exist both when the act is made and when challenged, finding the applicant's interest extinguished by his prior dismissal.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Article 146.2 of the Constitution; A legitimate interest required for a recourse for annulment must exist both at the time the administrative act is made and at the time its validity is challenged.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
Constitutional Recourse Legitimate Interest Public Service Commission Annulment Action Existing Relationship Dismissal Consequence Administrative Law inesigibilità dell'esecuzione dell'allontanamento

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Article 146 of the Constitution
In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution
Article 146.2 of the Constitution
Constitutional Law - Recourse for annulment - Article 146.2 of the Constitution - Existing legitimate interest required thereunder - Must exist both at the time of the making of an act and at the time when its validity is challenged.

Giurisprudenza citata

Generato dall'IA
Theodores G. Papapetrou and The Republic
In the case of Theodores G. Papapetrou and The Republic, 2 R.S,C.C.
Costas Neophytou and The Republic
See also Costas Neophytou and The Republic 1964 C.L.R.
Decisions of the Council of State No. 1433/56
Decisions of the Council of State No. 1823/56
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*453] 1970 May 22

(HADJIANASTASSIOU, J.)

REVISIONAL JURISDICTION

In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution

Elias Christofis,

Applicant,

and

The Republic of Cyprus, through The Public Service Commission

(An Independent Organ of the Republic),

Respondent.

(Case No. 55/69).

Public Officers - Appointments and Promotions Recourse against appointment to the post of warder in the Department of Prisons - Applicant dismissed from his post during the pendency of the recourse -No existing legitimate interest - Article 146.2 of the Constitution - Recourse dismissed - See also under "Constitutional Law".

Constitutional Law - Recourse for annulment - Article 146.2 of the Constitution - Existing legitimate interest required thereunder - Must exist both at the time of the making of an act and at the time when its validity is challenged.

Chr. HadjiNicolaou, for the Applicant.

S. Nicolaides, Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.

L. Clerides, for the Interested Parties.

JUDGMENT

The following judgment was delivered by:

HADJIANASTASSIOU. J.: In these proceedings, under Article 146 of the Constitution, the applicant seeks to challenge [*454] the decision of the Public Service Commission to appoint Messrs. Andreas Pontikides, Andreas Menikou, Christakis Shakallis and Kostakis Patroklou, to the post of a warder in the department of prisons. The applicant has been appointed on January 8, 1964, as a warder in the department of prisons on a daily temporary basis, and on June 1, 1964, he was appointed again on a temporary monthly basis to the same post.

On September 12, 1968, the Council of Ministers by its Decision No. 8094, authorized, inter alia, the filling of twenty vacancies on a permanent basis, in the post of warder in the department of prisons, as well as any other vacancies which might be created as a result of the filling of vacancies in the higher grades.

The post of warder, in accordance with the scheme of service, is a first entry post, and on September 27, 1968, the Public Service Commission at its meeting, decided that the vacancies in the post of warder be advertised, and two weeks allowed for the

submission of applications. The advertisement appeared under notification No. 15/65 in the official Gazette on October

11, 1,968, and in response to it 66 applications were received. On December 2, 1968, the Public Service Commission decided that 44 candidates only, including the applicant and the interested parties, be called for an interview on December 6, 1968.

On December 6, 1968, the Commission interviewed the

applicant and the interested parties, and its decision [*455] was adjourned. The Commission, further, at its afternoon meeting,

after considering the merits, qualifications and experience of the candidates interviewed in the morning, as well as their performance during the interview with regard to the alertness of mind, general intelligence and the correctness of answers put to them, and bearing in mind . the views expressed by the senior superintendent of prisons on each one of them, decided unanimously that 23 officers, including the interested parties, were on the whole the best and that they be appointed on probation to the permanent post of warder w.e.f. January 1, 1969.

On December 18, 1968, the Public Service Commission wrote to the applicant informing him that it was not found possible to be selected for appointment to the post of warder in the department of prisons.

As I said earlier, the post of warder is a first entry post, and the duties and responsibilities are as follows:

"To perform such duties as may be laid down in the Prisons Legislation and Regulations; to be responsible under the supervision of a superior officer, for the observation, welfare, training and discipline of prisoners; in some cases clerical work; and any other duties which may be assigned to him. "

Qualifications Required:

"A minimum of 3 years’ secondary school

education; knowledge of Turkish in the case of a Greek Officer [*456] and Greek in the case of a Turkish Officer would be an

advantage training and experience in any of the trades used in the Prisons (e.g. carpentry, tailoring, plumbing and welding, bookbinding) would be an additional qualification. Age between 19 and 25 years; a height of not less than 5 feet 6 inches; strong physique and exemplary character; good personality and interest and ability in handling prisoners."

On February 14, 1969, the applicant, feeling aggrieved because of the refusal of the Commission to appoint him, filed the present recourse. On April 4, 1969, the opposition was filed, to the effect that the decision complained of was properly and lawfully taken after all relevant circumstances were taken into consideration.

On May 8, 1969, the hearing of this case began and, counsel for the applicant, before concluding the opening of his case, requested the Court for an adjournment because, as he put it: "As I have been now briefed that some of the interested parties were appointed without possessing the necessary qualifications under the scheme of service, I am asking for an adjournment in order to investigate more fully this allegation, and in order to file particulars within a period of fourteen days". See the record at p. 3.

On May 21, 1969, the particulars with regard to this new ground of law were filed. On July 8, 1969,the [*457] interested parties filed their opposition, 2nd paragraph 4 reads as follows:-

"4. Interested Parties allege the following misgivings of applicant and contend that by reason thereof applicant's claims, qualifications and merit for appointment to the said post are inferior to the claims of the Interested Parties:-

(a.) On 21.5.64 he was reprimanded for disobedience and unbecoming behaviour.”

(b) On 23.7.65 he was reprimanded for negligence of duty.

(c) On 18.1.66 he was reprimanded for unjustified absence from lessons.

(d) On 13.4.66 he was admonished for not carrying out his duties satisfactorily i.e. carrying out an inquiry in connection with a case of use of drugs by a convict.

(e) On 7.10.68 he was reprimanded for presenting himself late at Parade.

(f) On 19.2.66 he was reprimanded for un becoming behaviour.

(g) On 12.11.68 he was reprimanded following a complaint by his relatives i.e. his [*458] sister for having immoral relations with a woman in such a way as to bring discredit to the Prisons Dept."

On October 15, 1969, counsel for the interested parties gave notice to both counsel for the applicant and the respondent that he intended to argue on behalf of the interested parties that applicant's recourse cannot proceed inasmuch as applicant has been dismissed from the service on the 29.7.69 for misconduct, and hence he has no legitimate

interest to proceed with his case. The case was fixed for mention on October 20, 1969, and counsel for the applicant

made this statement:- "I would like to inform the Court that I have already filed a new recourse with regard to the applicant in this case, because he was dismissed from the service, and intend to proceed with the present case also. I would, therefore, apply for a date for hearing. "

On December 4, 1969, counsel for the applicant, in addressing the Court, had this, inter alia, to say:- "In view of the legal argument raised by my learned friend in the opposition on behalf of the interested parties, I propose to argue this point first, because if I fail to convince the Court, then this point disposes of the whole of the case". Counsel then contended that although the applicant has been dismissed from the service when this case was already before the Court, the

applicant has still a legitimate interest within the ambit of [*459] Article 146 of the Constitution. He further invited the Court to

take the view that the case of Kyriaikos Chrysostomides and the Greek Communal Chamber, 1964, C.L.R. 397, should be distinguished, because the facts in that case are entire ly different from the present case.

Counsel for the interested parties, on the contrary, has contended (a) that it was an accepted principle that the existing legitimate interest of a party must subsist at the time of the filing of the recourse, and also at the hearing of his case; (b) that although the applicant had a legitimate interest when he filed this recourse, nevertheless, because he was dismissed from the service, he no longer had such interest for the purpose of proceeding with his case; and because he was no longer in the public service he could not complain that another person was emplaced in his post. He relied on the authority of Neophytou v. CYTA, 1964, C.L.R. 280 at pp. 292-3.

It is pertinent to add that this contention has also been adopted by counsel for the respondent.

Now with regard to existing legitimate interest, paragraph 2 of Article 146 of the Constitution reads as follows:-

"Such a recourse may be made by a person whose any existing legitimate interest, which he has either as a person or by virtue of being a member of a Community is adversely and directly affected by such decision or act or omission." [*460]

It would be observed that this provision is more or less modelled on the lines of section 48 of the Greek Law No. 3713/28.

I would like to quote a passage from the Greek reports in the "Conclusions from the Jurisprudence of the Council of State" (1929-1959) at p. 260, under the heading

"Η προς την πράξιν σχέσις του αιτούντος, εξ

ης πηγάζει το συμφέρον του, δέον να υφίσταται ήδη κατά τον χρόνον της προσβολής

αυτής, η δε βλάβη αυτού δέον να έχει ήδη επέλθει ή να εμφανίζηται ως λογικώς

αναπόφευκτος. Ούτω το έννομον συμφέρον δέον να είναι ενεστώς."

In English, this passage reads as follows:- "The applicant's relationship to the act from which his interest flows must exist already when the act has been challenged, and his injury must have already taken place or appears reasonably unavoidable. Thus, the legitimate interest must be existing".

See also the "Recourse for annulment before the Council of State", 2nd edn., by Tsatsos at p. 42.

In the case of Theodores G. Papapetrou and The Republic, 2 R.S,C.C. 61 at p. 64, it was stated that: "Once it is a fact that the applicant had applied to the Public Service Commission for the appointment to the post in question, and that somebody else has been appointed

instead to such post, it follows from this fact alone that [*461] an existing legitimate interest of his was adversely and directly

affected by his not being appointed".

In fairness, however, to counsel for the interested parties, he has conceded during the argument, that the applicant, in this case had a legitimate interest at the time when he filed the present recourse. The question, therefore, which is posed before me is whether the applicant still has a legitimate interest when the validity of the act of the respondent is challenged today in Court.

In the Greek reports of the "Decisions of the Council of State" reported in 1956 Volume 'Τ’, there are two cases: The first is No. 1433/56 at p. 35. It was held at p. 36 in Greek:-

"Επειδή το κατά το άρθρον 48

του ν.3713 έννομον συμφέρον, το απαιτούμενον προς άσκησιν αιτήσεως ακυρώσεως,

δέον συν τοις άλλοις να είναι και ενεστώς. Εν τη εννοία δε του ενεστώτος, προκειμένου περί

προσβολής διοικητικής πράξεως, οία η προσβαλλομένη, δι’ ης ενεκρίθη η επί της

γραμμής Ομονοίας - Πειραιώς κυκλοφορία των τεσσάρων λεωφορείων της

παρεμβαινούσης περιλαμβάνεται, κατά την έννοιαν του νόμου, και η προϋπόθεσης,

όπως το έννομον συμφέρον πηγάζη εξ ειδικής τινός σχέσεως του διοικουμένου προς

την προσβαλλομένην υπ’ αυτού ατομικήν διοικητικήν πράξιν, υφισταμένης κατά τε

τον χρόνον της εκδόσεως της πράξεως ταύτης και κατά τον χρόνον της προσβολής

αυτής." [*462]

It would be observed that the legitimate interest required must exist both at the time of the making of an act and at the time when its validity is challenged.

The second case is No. 1823/56 at p.

547. It was held at p. 549 that the legitimate interest must arise out of a legal relationship of an applicant which is already in existence when the act concerned is challenged. See also Costas Neophytou and The Republic 1964 C.L.R. 280.

Having given the matter my best consideration, and in the light of the authorities to which I have referred, I have reached the view that because the applicant has been dismissed from his post on or about the 12th June, 1969, for misconduct, he has no longer an existing legitimate interest today and, therefore, cannot complain that another person was emplaced in that post.

For the reasons I have endeavoured to explain, this recourse is dismissed. No order as to costs.

Application dismissed;

no order as to costs.