Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Andreas Meletiou v. The Republic of Cyprus through the Minister of Interior (1970) JSC 393 Generato dall'IA

Cyprus Supreme Court annuls military service exemption denial due to Advisory Committee ignoring official District Officer reports.

Numero d'incarto Andreas Meletiou v. The Republic of Cyprus through the Minister of Interior (1970) JSC 393
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Supreme Court of Cyprus annulled the Minister of Interior's decision denying the applicant an exemption from National Guard service. The applicant argued he had more than three dependants, but the Advisory Committee rejected his claim based on unverified self-reported earnings. The court found the Committee misconceived by ignoring contradictory official reports from the District Officer confirming the applicant's income and family support role, leading the Minister to decide contrary to law.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Section 4(3)(f) of the National Guard Laws; where an Advisory Committee rejects an exemption application based on unverified applicant statements while official sources contradict those statements, the Minister's resulting decision is null and void for being based on erroneous facts.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
military service exemption National Guard Laws Advisory Committee error official source evidence excess of powers family dependants administrative review dimissioni del governo

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Section 4(3)(f) of the National Guard Laws from Law 20/64 to Law 86/69
Article 146 of the Constitution
In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution.
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*393] 1969 December 29

(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, J. )

Revisional Jurisdiction.

In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution.

Andreas Meletiou,

Applicant,

and

The Republic of Cyprus,

through the Minister of Interior,

Respondent.

(Case No. 284/69).

Administrative Law - Military service - Application for exemption on account of more than three dependants - Section 4(3)(f) of the National Guard Laws from Law' 20/64 to Law 86/69 - Conclusions of Advisory Committee, on factual situation, misconceived through their being contradicted by facts based on information emanating from an official source - Therefore Respondent Minister was led to decide application for exemption on an erroneous basis reaching sub judice decision contrary to law and in excess of powers.

Military Service - See under "Administrative Law".

N. Aloneftis, for the Applicant .

S. Nicolaides, Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.

JUDGMENT

The following judgment was delivered by:

TRIANTAFYLLIDES. J.: In this case the applicant complains against a decision of the respondent Minister of Interior not to exempt him from service in the National Guard. [*394]

The applicant was called up for military service on the 2nd January, 1969; the applicant applied immediately for exemption from such service for, more or less, the same reason which is mentioned later on in this judgment, but his application was rejected (see exhibits 3,4 and 5). As, however, the applicant was, then, a pupil of a secondary school-wherefrom he graduated in June 1969-his enlistment was deferred till the completion of his studies.

A further application of the applicant for exemption (exhibit 6), which has led to the sub judice

decision, was made on the 29th May, 1969, and it was based on the contention that as the applicant’s father had died in 1968, and the applicant became, thus, the head of his family, which comprised his widowed mother, who was doing no work other than house-work, and four younger brothers, all attending school, he was, by law, entitled to be exempted from military service, as having more than three dependants.

The decision which is challenged by this recourse is dated the 16th August, 1969 (exhibit 10). It was reached by the Minister of Interior and it must be read together with the relevant minutes of the Advisory Committee, which functions under the relevant legislation (The National Guard Laws from Law 20/64 to Law 86/69); the said minutes are dated the 21st July, 1969 and the 28th July, 1969 (see exhibit 8).

The non-exemption of the applicant was communicated to him by letter dated the 23rd August, 1969(exhibit 1); and [*395] this recourse was filed on the 2nd September, 1969.

It was alleged by the Applicant, all along, that even while he was a pupil he was working to support his family - (who have practically no other means of livelihood, except a very small income from immovable property)- and that he took up full-time employment after he had graduated from secondary school.

It appears from the afore-mentioned minutes of the Advisory Committee that it decided not to recommend the exemption of the Applicant because it did not accept as exact his statements about his working to support his family before and after he had left school, and because, in any case, the amount of his earnings, which the Committee took to be £15 monthly, did not justify treating him as having more than three dependants (so as to be entitled to exemption under section 4(3) (f) of the relevant legislation).

Yet, at the time of the relevant meetings of the Advisory Committee, the District Officer of Nicosia-Kyrenia, who had been asked, according to normal practice, to investigate the factual aspects of the case of the applicant, had reported, on the 15th July and 22nd July / 1969 (see exhibits 7 and 9 respectively) that the applicant had been earning £15 per month while at school, that he took up employment on a full-time basis, at £40 per month, after he had graduated, and that he was contributing £30 per month towards the maintenance of his family, which consists - as stated - apart from himself, of his mother and four minor brothers. [*396] In the circumstances the District Officer recommended the exemption of the applicant.

In the light of these facts, based on information emanating from an official source, I am bound to find that the conclusions of the Advisory Committee were misconceived and as a result the Minister of Interior was led to decide the matter of the application of the applicant for exemption on an erroneous basis, reaching, thus, the sub judice decision contrary to law and in excess of powers.

If the Advisory Committee had any doubts about the accuracy of the information supplied by the District Officer it could have asked for further investigations to be made; but, otherwise, it could not reject, as it did, the only official information available at the time.

In the circumstances, I have no difficulty whatsoever in declaring null and void and of no effect whatsoever the sub judice decision not to exempt the applicant from military service. The matter has to be re-examined by the Minister of Interior in its proper context; and on the face of the District Officer’s reports I would venture to say that there does appear - unless the contrary is established - that this is a case coming within both the letter and spirit of the relevant legislative provision (section 4(3)(f)) because of the applicant having more than three dependants.

Regarding costs I award, in favour of the applicant, and against the respondent, £30 towards costs.

Sub judice decision annulled.

Order for costs as above.