Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Christakis Christoforou Ttofaros v. Niki ?. Vassiliou and 2 others. (1970) JSC 343 Generato dall'IA

Supreme Court dismisses appeal regarding refusal of adjournment due to counsel's absence abroad.

Numero d'incarto Christakis Christoforou Ttofaros v. Niki ?. Vassiliou and 2 others. (1970) JSC 343
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's ground of appeal challenging the trial court's refusal to adjourn proceedings because the original counsel was traveling abroad. The court noted that the appellant was promptly represented by a new advocate who proceeded without seeking further delays, thereby avoiding prejudice. Consequently, the court held that the trial judge exercised wide discretionary powers correctly and the appellant's constitutional rights were not infringed.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Article 30(3) of the Constitution; The trial court's refusal to adjourn proceedings due to a counsel's temporary absence abroad does not constitute a contravention of constitutional rights if the party is adequately represented by another advocate and no prejudice is caused.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
counsel absence abroad adjournment refusal constitutional rights infringement trial court discretion change of advocate sostituzione nell'obbligazione diritto di ottenere una decisione motivazione del mutamento giurisprudenza

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Article 30(3) of the Constitution
Practice - Adjournment - Application for adjournment due to counsel's absence abroad - Refused - Wide discretionary powers of trial Court - Appellantrepresented by another Counsel - Notice of change of advocate filed - Neither prejudiced nor his constitutional rights infringed - Article 30(3) of the Constitution.
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*343] 1970 January 16

(TRIANTAFYILIDES, STAVRINIDES, HADJIANASTASSIOU, JJ.) APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Christakis Christoforou Ttofaros,

Appellant Defendant 1,

v.

1. Niki E. Vassiliou,

Respondent-Plaintiff,

2. Ioannis Michael,

Respondent-Defendant 2,

3. Efstathios Kyriacou & Sons Ltd.,

Respondent-Defendant 3.

(Civil Appeal No. 4838).

Practice - Adjournment - Application for adjournment due to counsel's absence abroad - Refused - Wide discretionary powers of trial Court - Appellantrepresented by another Counsel - Notice of change of advocate filed - Neither prejudiced nor his constitutional rights infringed - Article 30(3) of the Constitution.

Adjournment - See under "Practice".

Chr. Mitsides with X. Syllouris, for the Appellant- Defendant 1.

L. Papaphilippou, for the Respondent-Plaintiff.

C. Indianos, for the Respondents-Defendants 2 and 3.

DECISION

The decision of the Court was delivered by:

TRIANTAFYLLIDES. J.: We had to deal first, as a preliminary issue, with ground of appeal (e), whereby [*344] it is contended that the trial Court

erred in dismissing an application for the adjournment of the further hearing of the case, as fixed before it for continuation on the 3rd May, 1969.

As a matter of fact, on the 30th April, 1969, Mr. Syllouris, who had been appearing till then, at the hearing, for the appellant, applied in writing for the adjournment of the hearing, as fixed, on the ground that he would be away from Cyprus. All counsel appearing, at the time, for the respondents countersigned the application for adjournment, stating that they had no objection thereto.

The matter was dealt with by the trial. Court on the 1st May, 1969; and from the record before us it does not appear that counsel were heard for the purpose.

The ruling made on the 1st May, 1969 reads as follows:

"We have considered this application and we find ourselves unable to accede to this request for adjournment. This case has been pending for a long time. It was adjourned repeatedly, and we would be doing injustice not only to the parties in this action but to other litigants, because, if we adjourn it on a day that there are no other cases fixed, this will have to be after the summer Court vacations and if we try to finish it before, then it will [*345] mean the adjournment of other cases who are not to blame if Mr. Syllouris wishes to go abroad. It is a simple accident case and we are certain there are numerous advocates in Nicosia who are both competent and willing to facilitate their colleague during his absence abroad."

As he has stated to us, counsel for appellant was informed of the refusal of the application for adjournment on the 1st Hay, 1969, just before he was about to leave Cyprus; without having had an opportunity of consulting his client he proceeded to hand over this case to a colleague, Mr. Ch. Loizou, an advocate in Nicosia.

Up to that point all that had happened was that there had been a refusal of an application for an adjournment; and had matters been left at that, we would have to examine whether such refusal had been decided upon in the proper exercise of the relevant discretionary, powers - which are of quite a wide nature - and we might have had to consider, too, whether, because of the said refusal, there had occurred, in any way, a contravention of the rights of the appellant as laid down in Article 30(3) of the Constitution.

Subsequent events, however, led to an altered situation, indeed: On the 3rd May, 1969, Mr. Ch. Loizou did appear at the resumed hearing of the case, but not on [*346] behalf of Mr. Syllouris; he appeared as counsel appearing directly for the defendant (now appellant); and he, also, during the hearing on that date, filed a notice of change of advocate signed by his client and accompanied by the appropriate retainer.

On the 3rd May, 1969, Mr. Loizou did not make any effort to secure an adjournment pending the return of Mr. Syllouris. On the contrary, after he was given by the trial Court 15 minutes to receive instructions before the appellant would be called by him to give evidence, he said that he had received such instructions and the proceedings continued in the normal course.

The main difficulty of Mr. Loizou on that date was that one of his medical experts was absent. The case was adjourned until the 5th. May, 1969, so that this expert could attend.

Again Mr. Loizou did not think, fit to apply for a longer adjournment so as to enable Mr. Syllouris - who admittedly had appeared, earlier on, for the appellant for most of the duration of the case, and when very material medical evidence had been heard - to return from abroad. Further medical evidence was to have been heard but Mr. Loizou did not seem to think that the presence of Mr. Syllouris was necessary in the circumstances; the reason for such an attitude being, most probably, that consequent upon the change of advocate Mr. Syllouris was no longer appearing for the appellant. [*347]

As a result the hearing of the case continued on the 5th and the 8th May, 1969, when it was concluded.

In these circumstances we cannot see how in any way appellant can be said to have been prejudiced, or his constitutional rights to have been infringed. He was represented after the refusal of the adjournment by new counsel, duly retained by him, and it was not thought necessary - and no effort was made accordingly - at any time to attempt to adjourn the proceedings so that counsel who had appeared earlier on for the major part of the case could also join in the defence of the appellant.

In our view, therefore, ground of appeal (e) fails and the hearing of this appeal should proceed on the other grounds of appeal.

Order accordingly.