Supreme Court dismisses appeal on loan claim where trial judge correctly preferred plaintiff's witness version over defendant's denial.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's appeal against a judgment awarding the plaintiff £350 for a loan, upholding the trial judge's finding that the plaintiff's witnesses provided the true version of events. The defendant flatly denied receiving the money, while the plaintiff's account was corroborated by a clerk and another witness, whereas the defendant's corroborating witness gave conflicting testimony. The court affirmed that matters of witness credibility fall within the trial judge's province and found no error in the judge's reasoning despite minor discrepancies in the pleadings regarding payment terms.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAs. 24 of the Civil Procedure Law; Credibility of witnesses is within the province of the trial judge, and the appellate court will not interfere unless the reasoning behind the findings is wrong.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*272] 1970 March 3
(VASSILIADES, P., JOSEPHIDES, IOIZOU, JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Maroulla A. Gregoriadou,
Appellant-Defendant,
V.
Evangelos Th. Kyriakides,
Respondent-Plaintiff,
(Civil Appeal No. 4836).
Debt - Claim for money lent - Denial by defendant - Oral evidence only - Version of plaintiff preferred - Court of Appeal not persuaded that trial Judge went wrong in any way.
Court of Appeal - Credibility of witnesses - Principles applicable.
Practice - Costs - Pleading - Drafting slip in statement of claim - Costs on minimum of scale awarded to successful litigant.
G. Constantinides, for the Appellant.
A. Paikkos, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
VASSILLIADE S. P. : The judgment of the Court will be delivered by:
JOSEPHIDES, J.: In the present case the plaintiff claims the sum of £350.- alleged to have been lent by him [*273] to the defendant on the 29th September, 1966. The children of the parties were married some eighteen days earlier, on the 18th September, 1966.
The plaintiff’s claim as pleaded in part
2 of the statement of claim was as follows:- "The plaintiff in the presence of witnesses lent the sum of £350. on the 29th September, 1966, to the defendant on the assumption that the said sum would be paid off not later than two months from the date thereof together with interest at the rate of 6% per annum". The defence was a flat denial. The defendant both in her statement of defence and in her evidence, denied that she ever received the sum of £350.-, or any sum at all, from the plaintiff. The trial Judge, after hearing the plaintiff and four witnesses called on his behalf, and the defendant and two witnesses called on defendant's behalf, preferred the version of the plaintiff and gave judgment as claimed.
The whole appeal turns on the credibility of the witnesses heard before the trial Court.
The approach of this Court in such matters is well settled, to the effect that matters of credibility are within the province of the trial Judge. Some of the cases which lay down this principle are: Charalambous v. Demetriou (1961) C.L.R. 14 Imam v. Papacostas (1968) 6 J.S.C. 626, 627; and HadjiPetri v. HadjiGeorghiou and Another (1969) 5 J.S.C. 729, 733. Needless to say that that does not mean that if the reasoning behind the trial Judge's findings is wrong this Court will not interfere with such finding. [*274]
We must say that we have read both the evidence on record and the very careful judgment of the trial Judge in the present case, and that we have been impressed with the strong reasoning behind the conclusions reached by the learned Judg. It is true that there is some difference between the case as pleaded with regard to the time of payment and the rate of interest, but that has been explained by learned counsel who drafted the statement of claim and who said that his client was not specific either as to time limit or as to rate of interest, and that he (counsel) thought fit to include that in his pleading. This is a matter which will be considered later when we come to decide the question of costs.
Reverting to the question of the findings of the learned trial Judge the versions as put forward are the
following: It was the plaintiff's version that on the 29th of September, 1966, the defendant being his "συμπεθέρα" (the mother-in-law of his
daughter) went to his office and said that she wanted to buy some silverware and that she was in need of £350.- At first, she asked him to join her in this venture but he said that he was not interested and, eventually, the plaintiff offered to give her by way of loan the sum of £350.- In fact he issued a cheque payable to himself which he sent through his clerk, Andreas Charalambous, to the bank. The said clerk cashed the cheque, came back and he paid the proceeds amounting to £350.- to the defendant. This version of the plaintiff was corroborated by the clerk Charalambous and by another witness, Pandelis Constantinou. The fourth person present there was one of the [*275 ] plaintiff's partners, Panayiotis Constantinou, who said in his evidence that soon after the defendant came into the office, and after he was introduced to her and the parties began speaking in a low tone, he left.
The defendant’s version was that she did go to the plaintiff’s office on two occasions but that she never received any money from him; and, on one occasion, she remembers that it was after passing by the Government Printing Office for the purpose of obtaining a copy of the official Gazette containing a law regarding her husband's pension rights. The witness called on her behalf (Ioannis Mentzis) to corroborate her on material points, in fact did not do so. On the contrary, his evidence was in direct conflict with that of the defendant. The material contradictions are pointed out in the careful judgment of the trial Judge and we need not go into detail.
The Judge with that evidence before him and, having watched the witnesses in the witness-box giving their evidence, came to the
conclusion that the plaintiff and his witnesses were giving the true version and, relying on that, he gave judgment for the plaintiff.
Considering the principles on which this Court acts in appeals turning on credibility of witnesses, we have not been persuaded by counsel for the appellant that the trial Judge went wrong in any way. For these reasons the appeal must be dismissed. [*276]
As regards costs, considering the drafting slip in the statement of claim, we are of the view that, although the appellant should pay the costs of the appeal, they should be assessed on the minimum of the scale applicable.
Appeal dismissed.
Order for costs as above.