Seniority disregarded without cogent reason; promotion annulled; appeal allowed in part.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court allowed the appellant's appeal regarding the promotion of a Postal Officer, declaring the promotion of a junior colleague null and void. The court found that the Public Service Commission ignored the appellant's substantially greater seniority without providing a cogent reason, as all other factors like merit were equal. Furthermore, the court ruled that oral recommendations made by the Head of Department were inadequately recorded in the minutes, preventing proper judicial review of the decision-making process.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAAdministrative Law; Public Officers; Promotion; Seniority; Discretionary Powers; "All other things being equal the appellant's seniority ought to prevail"; "Oral recommendations must be adequately recorded to enable judicial review".
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*246] 1969 November 6
(VASSILIADES, P., TRIANTAFYLLIDES, JOSEPHIDES,
STAVKINIDES, LOIZOU, JJ. )
REVISIONAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Costas D. Partellides,
Appellant,
and
The Republic of Cyprus, through
the Public Service Commission,
Respondent.
(Revisional Jurisdiction Appeal No.60).
Administrative Law - Public officers
- Promotions - Seniority - Substantially greater seniority of appellant disregarded without any really cogent reason - All other things being equal the appellant’s seniority ought to prevail - Sub judice promotion annulled.
Public Officers - Promotion - Post of Postal Officer first grade - Appeal against decision dismissing recourse - Situation concerning seniority of parties not such as it was placed before trial Court - Appeal allowed.
Administrative Law - Head of Department - Oral recommendations made by him before public Service Commission when meeting to consider promotions - To be adequately recorded.
Seniority - See under "Administrative Law".
Head of Department - See under "Administrative law".
Appellant in person.
S. Georghiades, Senior Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
VASSILIADES. P.: The judgment of the Court will be delivered by Mr. Justice Triantafyllides.
TRIANTAFYLLIDES, J. : This is an appeal from [*247] the judgment of a Judge of this Court, who determined, in the first instance, recourse No. 331/68*, made by the appellant, against the promotions, decided up on by the respondent Public Service Commission, on the 3rd July, 1968, of interested parties N. Christophides and K. Gregoriades, to posts of Postal Officer, 1st grade.
At the material time, all three of them were Postal Officers, 2nd grade; the appellant and interested party Christophides as from the 1st January, 1956, and interested party Gregoriades as from the 1st July, 1956.
In view of these dates the learned trial Judge Properly concluded, in the light of how the matter was presented to him, that the appellant and interested party Christophides were of equal seniority and interested party Gregoriades was only six months junior to appellant; and the trial Judge proceeded to find that it
was reasonably open to the respondent, in the exercise of its discretionary powers on the basis of the material before it (including the
recommendations of the Head of the Department concerned and of the annual confidential reports) to promote the two interested parties instead of the appellant; as a result the appellant’s recourse was dismissed.
During the hearing of this appeal, it has been confirmed that, indeed, interested party Christophides and the appellant had, at the material time, equal seniority [*248] in the post of Postal Officer, 2nd grade; it is, moreover, clear, from a comparison of their qualifications and confidential reports, that the Commission was quite entitled to prefer the former to the latter, especially as this interested party knew French and he, thus, possessed an advantage expressly mentioned in the relevant scheme of service.
Regarding, however, the comparison as to seniority between interested party Gregoriades and the appellant, it has transpired, during the hearing before us, that the situation is not exactly such as it was placed before the trial Judge. In actual fact, the appellant from the 1st August, 1954, until the 31st December, 1955, was a Sub-Postmaster, having been previous to that a
Mail Officer from the 1st January, 1946, until the 31st July, 1954, On the 1st January, 1956, the until then non-existent post of
Postal Officer, 2nd grade, was created, by means of the 1956 Revision of Salaries, and the appellant was appointed thereto not by way of promotion, but by way of abolition of some postsincluding that of Sub-Postmaster - and their amalgamation into the new post of Postal Officer, 2nd grade.
On the other hand, interested party
Gregoriades was a Mail Officer from the 20th June, 1949, until the 30th June, 1956; it is clear that in the post of Mail
Officer the interested party was junior to the appellant who was appointed as Mail Officer since the 1st January, 1946. This interested party became a Postal Officer, 2nd grade, on the [*249] 1st July, 1956 by way of promotion from the post of Postal Officer, 3rd grade, which was the post which replaced the post of Mail Officer at the time of the aforesaid Revision of Salaries.
Thus, the appellant was, in effect, from 1949 to 1954, senior to interested party Gregoriades, and from August 1954 he was holding a post equivalent, in substance, to that of Postal Officer, 2nd grade: it follows that the total period of seniority of the appellant over this interested party in the post immediately below that of Postal Officer, 1st grade, was not only six months but just under two years (from the 1st August, 1954 to the 30th June, 1956).
The respondent Commission has, nevertheless, promoted to the post of Postal Officer, 1st Grade, interested party Gregoriades, instead of the appellant, in spite of the substantially greater seniority of the appellant, and without any really cogent reason for disregarding such seniority.
The most recent, at the time, the 1968 confidential reports on them, which were both signed by the Director of the Department of Posts, Mr. P. Hajioannou, showed them to be about equal in merit. It is to be noted that an observation of Mr. Hajioannou in the 1967 confidential report on interested party Gregoriades, to the effect that he deserved promotion, was not repeated in the 1968 report on the same officer; actually, in 1968 Mr. Hajioannou made, himself, a rather poorer general assessment of this interested party than the one made in 1967, which was made by another officer; [*250] a thing which explains why Mr. Hajioannou did not mention anything about promotion in 1968.
In the circumstances we are of the opinion that it was not reasonably open to the respondent Commission to promote interested party Gregoriades instead of the appellant. All other things being more or less equal the appellant's seniority ought to prevail. It follows that the relevant discretionary powers of the respondent were exercised in an erroneous manner.
While on this point let it be stated that we have, indeed, noted a general statement, in the relevant minutes of the respondent, that the decisions as to the promotions concerned - including the sub judice one - were reached bearing in mind, inter alia, the "recommendations" of Mr. Hajioannou (which were made orally at the particular meeting of the respondent on the 3rd July, 1968); but, in the opinion of the Court, without these recommendations being adequately recorded in the said minutes, so as to enable this Court to examine how and why it was reasonably open to the respondent to act upon them, notwithstanding the greater seniority of the appellant and the equally good confidential reports, such a general statement in the minutes of the respondent, as aforesaid, cannot have the effect of rendering the promotion of interested party Gregoriades one which can be treated as having been properly decided upon in the exercise of the particular powers of the respondent. [*251]
In the result this appeal succeeds in so far as the promotion of interested party Gregoriades is concerned, which is declared to be null and void and of no effect whatsoever, and it is dismissed in so far as it relates to the promotion of interested party Christophides.
We are making no order as to costs, in these circumstances.
Appeal allowed in part.
No order as to costs.
* Published in (1969) 5 J.S.C. 735.