Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Katerina N. A. Georghiou and another v. Chrystalla Michael Pistolia (1969) JSC 1501 Generato dall'IA

Court allows amendment to statement of claim regarding right of passage but rejects new easement claim.

Numero d'incarto Katerina N. A. Georghiou and another v. Chrystalla Michael Pistolia (1969) JSC 1501
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Supreme Court partially allowed an appeal against a District Court order refusing to amend the plaintiffs' statement of claim. While the trial judge correctly rejected a claim for an easement to light and air as a different claim, the appellate court found the judge applied the wrong principle regarding amendments to the right of passage. The court held that since the proposed amendments did not introduce a different claim and there was no allegation of mala fide conduct, the plaintiffs were permitted to amend their pleadings despite the delay.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Civil Procedure Act; Amendment of pleadings: Where proposed amendments do not introduce a different claim and are not made in bad faith, the trial court's refusal to allow them on the ground of delay is an error of principle and should be set aside.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
Amendment of pleadings Right of passage Easement to light Mala fide conduct Discretion of trial court Statement of claim Civil procedure modificazione delle conclusioni
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*1501] 1969 December 11

(JOSEPHIDES, STAVRINIDES, LOIZOU, JJ.)

APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Katerina N. A. Georghiou and another,

Appellants-Plaintiffs,

v.

Chrystalla Michael Pistolia,

Respondent-Defendant.

(Civil Appeal No. 4827).

Civil Procedure - Practice - Pleadings - Amendment - Statement of claim

- Application for leave to amend after evidence given by plaintiffs - Matter within the discretion of trial Court - Discretion exercised on wrong principle

- Proposed amendments not asking to introduce a defferent claim and there was no allegation that plaintiffs were acting mala fide.

Practice - See under "Civil Procedure".

Pleadings - See under "Civil Procedure".

Amendment of pleadings - See under "Civil Procedure".

L. Clerides, for the Appellants-Plaintiffs.

C. Varda, (Mrs.), for the Respondent-Defendant.

JUDGMENT

The judgment of the Court was delivered by: -

JOSEPHIDES, J.: This is an appeal by the plaintiffs against the order of the District Court of Larnaca refusing amendment of their statement of claim. Having heard counsel of both sides and their submissions to Court, we need not give a long judgment in this case.

Briefly, the claim was for a right of passage and it was so pleaded in the statement of claim originally filed. [*1502] After the two plaintiffs gave their evidence, counsel applied to have the statement of claim amended in such a way as to extend the right of passage to include not only persons on foot but also loaded animals. Counsel also sought to introduce a claim of easement to light and air. He further asked for the deletion of paragraph 7 of his statement of claim. That application for amendment was refused by the trial Judge, mainly on the ground that it was made too late in the day and that the plaintiffs had. ample time to have included all these matters in their original statement of claim.

Learned counsel for the appellants (plaintiffs) today very rightly abandoned that part of his application, (that is, the proposed paragraph 8(d) in which he sought to introduce the claim of right to light and air. Undoubtedly that was an entirely different claim and the learned Judge was right in refusing it.

Furthermore, learned counsel for the appellants (plaintiffs) has abandoned that part of his application concerning the deletion of paragraph 7 of his statement of claim.

On the other hand counsel for the respondent (defendant) is not objecting today to the amendment of paragraphs 3 and 4 of the statement of claim and the addition of the new paragraphs 8(b) and (c) of the statement of claim, which refer to the right of passage. We think that counsel for respondent very properly has taken that stand, because we are of the view that although it is a matter for the discretion of the learned Judge, nevertheless, he applied a wrong principle in exercising his discretion. By their [*1503] proposed amendments the plaintiffs (appellants) were not asking to introduce a different claim and there was no allegation that the plaintiffs were acting mala fide. The plaintiffs had blundered and the injury to the defendant could he compensated for by costs. We are, therefore, of the view that the learned Judge ought, in the exercise of his discretion, to have granted this amendment which referred to the right of passage claimed by the plaintiffs.

In the result the appeal is allowed in part and the following order is made:

(1) The order of the trial Judge as regards the deletion off paragraph

7 of the statement of claim and the insertion of the proposed paragraph 8(d) of the statement of claim is affirmed;

(2) The order of the trial Judge with regard to the other parts of the plaintiffs' (appellants') application for amendment dated the 18th June, 1969, is set aside, and the plaintiffs are allowed to file an amended statement of claim within 15 days from today. The amendment allowed is in respect of paragraphs 3 and 4, and the proposed new paragraphs 8(b) and (c) of the statement of claim;

(3) The defendant (respondent) to file her defence within 15 days after the delivery of the amended statement of claim; and

(4) The plaintiffs (appellants) shall pay the costs of the amendment in the District Court and all costs thrown away as a result; but there will be no order as to costs in the appeal.

Appeal partly allowed. Order in terms as above.