Supreme Court extends appeal time due to counsel's filing error, granting extension under Criminal Procedure Law Cap. 155 s. 134.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court granted applications to extend the time limit for filing an appeal against a criminal conviction. Applicants had instructed their advocate to appeal within the statutory period, but the advocate mistakenly delivered the notice to the wrong court registry, causing it to be rejected as out of time. Although the court noted that a lawyer's error is not automatically a valid reason for extension, it exercised its discretion to grant the extension due to the severity of the sentence and the advocate's fair admission of the mistake.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IACriminal Procedure Law Cap. 155 s. 134; s. 132: While a counsel's mistake is not per se 'good cause' for extending time, the court may exercise discretion to grant an extension if the error was inadvertent, the case involves serious charges, and the opposing counsel concedes the merits.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1434] 1969 November 25
(VASSILIADES, P., TRIANTAFYLLIDES, JOSEPHTDES, JJ. )
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
1. R. Pullen,
2. S. J.Edwards,
Applicants,
v.
The Republic,
Respondent.
(Criminal Applications 6/69 and 7/69)
Criminal Procedure - Appeal out of time - Application for extension of
time to appeal - Criminal Procedure Law Cap. 155 section 134 – “Good cause” - Whether counsel's mistake may be
considered a “good cause” for extending time.
St. McBride, for the Applicants.
A, Frangos, Senior Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the Court was delivered by: -
VASSILIADES, P.: These two applications for extension f time for the filing of an appeal arise in the same case. The applicants were jointly charged in the Assize Court of Limassol and were tried and convicted in that Court on October 7, 1969. On the following day and well within the ten days' limit prescribed in section 132 of the Criminal Procedure Law (Cap. 155) the convicts gave instructions to their advocate to file on their behalf an appeal against sentence. The advocate proceeded to prepare the notice
of appeal straight away; but he delivered it to the Registrar [*1435] of the District Court of Limassol instead of the Chief Registrar as
required by section 132.
The notice was delivered and received at the Registry on October 10; and was forwarded, together with the notes of the proceedings to the Chief Registrar on October 17, 1969. Here the Registrar noticed that the appeal should have been filed in the Registry of the Supreme Court, and that the appeal was already out of time. The papers were, therefore, returned to the District Court with the suggestion that the appellants now had to obtain extension of time for the filing of the appeal.
Counsel for the appellants frankly admitted that it was a slip on his part to deliver the notice of appeal to. the Registrar of the Court where the case was tried instead of the Chief Registrar, as provided in section 132 of the Criminal Procedure Law.
Counsel for the Republic on the other hand, after pointing out that a lawyer's mistake cannot always be considered as a sufficient reason or "good, cause" for extending the time under section 134 of the Criminal Procedure Law, stated that the nature of the advocate's mistake in this particular case and the nature of the case itself were such that he did not wish to object to an extension which in any case is a matter for the Court's discretion. Considering the severity of the sentence, counsel added, he was inclined to facilitate matters so long as due care was taken to preserve the position that an advocate's mistake is not, by itself, a sufficient reason for extending the time for the filing of an appeal. [*1436]
There is no doubt that this is the correct position. See Finch Frederick Peter v. The Police, 1963, C.L.R. (Part 1, Criminal Cases) p. 42; Hagop Djeredjian v. The Republic (1967) 4 J.S.C, 434 at 436; and The Attorney General v. Petros Hji- Constanti (1968) 8, J.S.C. 885. In the special circumstances of this case, however, taking into consideration the nature of the mistake; the fact that the notice of appeal was delivered three days after conviction in the Registry of the Court where the case was tried; and the serious nature of the conviction and the severity of the sentence imposed on the applicants; together with the very fair stand of counsel for the Republic who readily conceded that on the merits this case deserves the Court’s favourable consideration, we came to the conclusion that we should exercise our discretionary powers in favour of the applicants and grant the extension required to enable them to pursue their appeal, Let the period for the filing of the appeals be extended under section 134 of the Criminal Procedure Law, Cap. 155, so as to expire seven days from to-day.
Applications granted. Order for extension as above.
Applications granted.