Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Lambros Lazarou, v. The Police (1969) JSC 1408 Generato dall'IA

Court dismisses conviction appeal but reduces sentence based on new medical and social investigation reports.

Numero d'incarto Lambros Lazarou, v. The Police (1969) JSC 1408
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appellant's challenge to his convictions, finding no sufficient reason to disturb the trial court's factual findings. However, the court allowed the appeal against sentence after obtaining and reviewing medical and social investigation reports that were not presented to the trial judge. Consequently, the sentence was reduced from 30 months to nine months for the principal counts to better reflect the appellant's personal circumstances.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Sections 91(c), 80, 242 and 95 of the Criminal Code; In appeals against sentence, the court must consider personal circumstances of the accused, and failure to have medical or social investigation reports before the trial judge warrants a reduction of sentence upon their subsequent admission.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
appeal against conviction appeal against sentence medical investigation report social investigation report reduction of sentence personal circumstances concurrent imprisonment pena di morte

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
s. 25(3) of the Courts of Justice Law 1960
s. 23(3) of the Courts of Justice Law (14 of 1960)
In the instant case, the trial Judge did not have before him the full picture of the appellant as seen in the light of the medical and the social investigation reports, obtained and admitted here under section 23(3) of the Courts of Justice Law (14 of 1960).
Sections 91(c), 80, 242 and 95 of the Criminal Code
Criminal Law - Appeal against conviction and sentence - Threatening violence, carrying arms to terrorize, common assault, disturbance - Sections 91(c), 80, 242 and 95 of the Criminal Code, respectively.

Giurisprudenza citata

Generato dall'IA
Lambides v. The Police (1967) 4 J.S.C 440
Georghios Nicola Christodoulides v. The Police (1968) 12 J.S.C. 1471
Diogenis Savva Karaviotis and others v. The Police (1967) 11 J.S.C. 1264
Costi Hadji Savva Tsiolis v. The Police (1969) 3 J.S.C. 446
1264, following in Costi Hadji Savva Tsiolis v. The Police (1969) 3 J.S.C. 446.
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*1408] 1969 November 19

(VASSILIADES, P., TRIANTAFYLLIDES, LOIZOU, JJ.)

APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Lambros Lazarou,

Appellant,

v.

The Police,

Respondents.

(Criminal Appeal No. 3108).

Criminal Law - Appeal against conviction and sentence - Threatening violence, carrying arms to terrorize, common assault, disturbance - Sections 91(c), 80, 242 and 95 of the Criminal Code, respectively.

Facts - Findings of trial court - No sufficient reason for disturbing findings - Approach on appeal.

Sentence - Material particulars connected with personal circumstances of appellant not before trial Judge when considering sentence - No medical or social Investigation Reports before trial Judge - Obtained and admitted by Court of Appeal under s. 25(3) of the Courts of Justice Law 1960 - Sentence reduced in the light of such reports.

Criminal Law - Sentence - Matters to be taken into consideration in measuring sentence.

Court of Appeal - Sentence - Appeal against sentence - Approach of Court of Appeal.

L. Clerides, for the Appellant.

S. Nicolaides, Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondents.

JUDGMENT

The judgment of the Court was delivered by:-

VASSILIADES, P. : The appellant, a young man of 26 years of age, a pedlar dealing with old iron, was charged together with his father and mother in the District Court of [*1409] Limassol, on a charge containing 14 various counts arising from an incident in a public street in the town of Limassol. The appellant attacked another man for an incident concerning his mother; appellant's both parents joined in the attack. At a certain stage of the incident, the appellant used an iron axe to terrorize the other man whom all three accused assaulted, causing wilful damage to the taxi in which the other man tried to escape the attack; and causing commotion and disturbance in the public street.

Eventually the appellant and both his parents were prosecuted together, upon a charge containing counts for carrying a weapon to terrorise; threatening violence; assaulting two different persons; wilfully causing £45 damage to a car; and public disturbance. All three accused pleaded not guilty, and after a strongly contested and exhaustive trial all three were convicted. They were sentenced on different counts to various terms of imprisonment.

The appellant before us (the son) was convicted on six counts; and was sentenced to 18 months' imprisonment on the count for threatening; 12 months’ imprisonment on. the count for terrorizing; 9 months’ imprisonment on two counts for assault; and one month on the count for public disturbance; all terms running concurrently.

The appellant challenges by his present appeal all his convictions and sentences. Learned counsel on his behalf went carefully and thoroughly into the circumstances in which the incident took place. Having heard him exhaustively, we - have not been persuaded that there is sufficient reason for [*1410] disturbing the findings of the trial court upon which the convictions were based. This part of the appeal must, therefore, fail. (See Lambides v. The Police (1967)

4 J.S.C 440; Georghios Nicola Christodoulides v. The Police (1968) 12, J.S.C. 1471).

As regards the part of the appeal against sentence, the trial Judge did not have before him for the purpose, the social investigation report in connection with this case; nor did he have before him the medical report regarding appellant's mental condition, which was put forward as the reason for which he was discharged from the army before the end of his national service. Taking the view that investigation into these matters was necessary for the purposes of sentence, we adjourned the further hearing of the appeal to enable the preparation and filing of such reports. We now have them before us; and their perusal leaves no doubt in our mind that if they were before the trial Judge they would influence his approach to the sentence.

We find it unnecessary to go into detail. We are in agreement with the trial Judge that the case calls for a rather severe sentence. But in measuring sentence, the Court must take into consideration the personal circumstances of the accused together with the circumstances in which he committed the offence for which he is being sentenced. Material particulars connected with the personal circumstances of the accused were not before the Judge when he was considering sentence in the case of this appellant. The approach of this Court in appeals against sentence was discussed in a number [*1411] of cases We may refer to Diogenis Savva Karaviotis and others v. The Police

(1967) 11 J.S.C. 1264, following in Costi Hadji Savva Tsiolis v. The Police (1969) 3 J.S.C. 446. We need not repeat the position.

In the instant case, the trial Judge did not have before him the full picture of the appellant as seen in the light of the medical and the social investigation reports, obtained and admitted here under section 23(3) of the Courts of Justice Law (14 of 1960). In the light of these reports, we think that the sentence must be varied to fit the offence as well as the offender.

The matter is not free of difficulty We gave it anxious consideration. In the end we reached the conclusion that a term of

9 months’ imprisonment on each of the two Principal counts, for terrorizing under section 80 and for threatening under section 91(c) of Cap. 154, is the proper term in this case. As the imprisonment on the counts for assault and on that for disturbance is concurrent, we do not think that we need interfere with, the sentences imposed on those counts. And as the adjournments in the hearing of the appeal were found necessary, we agree with the submission made on behalf of the appellant that the sentence should be made to run from conviction.

In the result the appeal against conviction is dismissed; the appeal against sentence is allowed to the extent of reducing the sentences imposed, on the first and second counts to nine months’ imprisonment on each count to run concurrently from conviction. The sentences imposed on the other counts are affirmed; they also to run concurrently from conviction. Order accordingly.

Appeal allowed.