Criminal appeal dismissed; two-year sentence for desertion upheld as not manifestly excessive given prior conduct.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's appeal against a two-year prison sentence for deserting his military unit and withholding property. The appellant argued the punishment was manifestly excessive, but the court noted his guilty plea, previous conviction, and the need to maintain army discipline. Consequently, the court affirmed the original sentence while directing it to run from the date of conviction.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IASection 29 of the Military Criminal Code and Procedure Law 1964; Section 147(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law; A sentence is not manifestly excessive if it considers the appellant's previous conduct and the necessity of maintaining military discipline.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1405] 1969 November 14
(VASSILIADES, P., JOSEPHIDES, LOJZOU, JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Anthoullis Charalambous Constantinou,
Appellant,
v.
The Republic,
Respondent.
(Criminal Appeal No. 3128).
Criminal Law - Sentence - Military Service - Two years’ imprisonment for deserting one’s unit while on military service - Section 29 of the Military Criminal Code and Procedure Law 1964 (as amended from 1964 to 1967) - Not so manifestly excessive in view of appellant’s previous conduct - Affirmed.
Court of Appeal - Sentence - Appeal against sentence - Approach of Court of Appeal.
Sentence - See under "Criminal Law" - "Court of Appeal".
Appeal against sentence - See under "Court of Appeal".
Appellant in person.
A. Frangos, Senior Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the Court was delivered by:-
VASSILIADES, P.: This is an appeal against a sentence of two years’ imprisonment imposed on the appellant by the Military Court of Nicosia for deserting his unit while on military service, contrary to section 29 of the Military Criminal Code and Procedure Law -of 1964 (as amended from 1964 to 1967) ; and for withholding military property in his possession, contrary to section 85 of the said Code. [*1406]
The appellant pleaded guilty to both counts; and after the opening of the facts by the prosecuting officer, applied through his advocate that two other similar offences pending against him at the time, be taken into consideration by the Court in passing sentence.
The short facts of the case are that after serving for about six months of his national service, the appellant failed to return to his unit on expiry of a short leave of absence for a visit to his home; and disappeared. He was a wanted man for about seven months, until he was arrested by the Military Police, His explanation to the trial Court, was that having prolonged his visit to his fiancée beyond the period of his leave, the appellant was afraid to return to his unit. To this Court he further alleged that a 'kazandi’ pedlar, much senior in age, induced the appellant to go with him round village fairs to help him and share the profits of the 'kazandi'.
The very fact of putting forward such allegations as an explanation for his absence from his unit, indicates the mentality of the appellant; and the type of person he is.
In passing sentence upon the appellant, the Military Court took into consi deration a similar previous conviction for
which he had been sentenced to two months' imprisonment. Pointing out the seriousness of the offence, the President of the Military Court took the view that a severe sentence was necessary in this case to help maintain good discipline in the army; and to get the appellant to reconsider his attitude towards his legal responsibilities both as a soldier and later as a citizen. [*1407]
The ground upon which the appeal is taken is that the sentence imposed is manifestly excessive. The approach of this Court to appeals against sentence has been stated in a line of cases. We may refer to a recent one, Christodoulos Charalambous Ttooulas v. The Police. (1969) 9 J.S.C, 1182 at p. 1184. We need not repeat the position. Although a sentence of two years imprisonment may at first sight appear to be rather severe, when the. offence, committed by the appellant is placed in the background of his previous conduct in the army, we cannot say that the sentence imposed by the Military Court is so manifestly excessive as to justify interference. by this Court. No other reason has been put forward justifying intervention; and this appeal must fail.
In view, however, of all circumstances, including the severity of. the sentence, we have decided to make directions under section. 147(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law, Cap. 155, for the sentence to run from the date of conviction.
Appeal dismissed; sentence to run from, conviction.
Appeal dismissed.