Supreme Court dismisses appeal against trial judge annulling public service appointments for lack of due reasons.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court dismissed the Public Service Commission's appeal against a trial judge's decision to annul certain public officer appointments. The trial judge found the Commission failed to give due weight to a candidate's passing of a required qualifying examination and lacked cogent reasons for preferring another candidate despite the latter's seniority. The court held that the trial judge correctly applied administrative law principles by requiring the Commission to provide explicit, material reasons for its discretionary choices rather than substituting its own judgment.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IASection 44 of the Public Service Law; Administrative Law: A public body must give due weight to material considerations and provide cogent reasons for its discretionary decisions; failure to do so justifies judicial annulment of the appointment.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1384] 1969 October 14
(VASSILIADES, P., JOSEPHIDES, STAVRINIDES, LOIZOU, HADJIANASTASSIOU, JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
The Republic of Cyprus, through
the Public Service Commission,
Appellant,
and
Theodoros Vonditsianos and others,
Respondents.
(Revisional Jurisdiction Appeal No.57)
Public Officers - Promotions - Principles applicable - Appeal against judgment†+ of trial Judge - Not justified
A. Frangos, Senior Counsel of the Republic, for the appellant,
A, Triantafyllides, for the respondents.
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the Court was delivered by:-
VASSILIADES, P.: In October 1967 the Public Service Commission had to consider the filling of some 23 vacancies in the post of Customs and Excise Officer, 1st grade, in the [*1385] Customs and Excise Department. Thirteen were existing vacancies; and about ten more were likely to be created as a result of promotions in the higher grades (see exhibit 2A.).
There were fifty candidates; and the Commission considered the case of each of the 50 candidates, as provided in section 44 of the Public Service Law. That is to say the Commission considered these candidates on the basis of merit, qualifications and seniority taking into account the annual confidential reports for each candidate.
In dealing with this rather complicated matter, the Commission had before them exhibit 9, which placed the candidates in different categories or grades, within which each candidate in. the particular grade was placed in order of merit. In the result, the Commission made appointments for the filling of the vacancies in question, which - as usual in such cases - caused disappointment to a number of the remaining candidates. Some of them filed recourses against the appointments; which were eventually consolidated and heard together as they turned on, practically, the same matter. Similar considerations governed all the consolidated recourses.
The learned trial Judge, in a carefully considered judgment, came to the conclusion that all the recourses, except one (71/68) failed; and upholding the decision of the Public Service Commission in the recourses which failed, [*1386] dismissed them.
The trial Judge reached his conclusion by approaching the cases on the principle which he stated earlier in his judgment, as follows:-
"I have approached these cases bearing constantly in mind that I cannot substitute my own discretion in the place of that of the Respondent, and that, therefore, so long as an appointment, as made, was reasonably open to Respondent in the circumstances, then I should, and could, not interfere therewith; moreover, that it was up to the Applicants to satisfy me that any one of the appointments challenged ought to be annulled".
In two of the cases, the trial Judge found that the recourse of applicant Constantinou should succeed. As against interested party Vovides, it should succeed on the ground that the record did not show difference in merit, or other reasons sufficient to outweigh the considerable seniority of the applicant. The relevant part of his judgment reads:-
"On the whole of the material before the Court, and in the absence of any due reasons to the contrary - which I would expect to find duly recorded in the relevant minutes of the Respondent I fail to see how it was open to the Respondent, in the proper exercise of its discretionary [*1387] powers, to prefer Interested Party Voviaes to Applicant Constantinou, in spite of the greater seniority and experience of the latter over the former, and there being no difference in merit in favour of the Interested Party".
As against interested party Markides, the trial Judge found that applicant Constantinou's recourse should succeed on the ground that: -
"The Respondent appears to have lost sight of the fact that, though he (Markides). was exceptionally, eligible for promotion - under Note
(l) to the schemes of service - even though he had not yet passed the departmental qualifying examination, Applicant Constantinou (like Interested Party Chrysanthou, too) had passed such examination.
"In my opinion, (the trial Judge proceeds) in deciding to disregard the relevant recommendations and in preferring, contrary to such recommendations, Interested Party Markides to Applicant, Constantinou, the Respondent had to give due weight to the fact that the former, unlike the Hatter, had not yet passed the required qualifying examination, for promotion, and had to give expressly cogent reasons for preferring, in the circumstances, a candidate who had not been, found by means of the appropriate examination, to possess the requisite knowledge and experience, to a candidate who had already been so found.” [*1388]
"In the absence of anything on this point in the relevant minutes (exhibit 2A) I am forced to the conclusion that the Respondent has failed to give due weight to a material consideration, and has, in any case, failed to give due reasons for its sub judice decision.”
"For all" - these - "reasons, (the trial Judge concludes) the recourse of Applicant Ch. Constantinou (71/68) succeeds only as against the appointments of Interested Parties Vovides and Markides and it fails in all other respects. All the other recourses fail in toto.”
And the Judge adds: —
"It is true that in the minutes of the Respondent it is stated that, eventually, Mr. Philippides, the Head of the Department concerned and Mr. Afxentiou, the representative of the Ministry of Finance (under which comes such Department) agreed with the conclusions arrived at by the Commission1, But this ex post facto blessing of the sub judice appointment did not carry with me such weight as to prevent me from annulling., for the reasons,. already set out in this judgment, the appointments of Interested Parties Vovides and Markides, as having been made contrary to the relevant principles of Administrative Law and in excess and abuse of powers;" [*1389]
From this decision, the Commission took the present appeal, argued mainly on the ground that the trial Judge erred in applying the principle on which he approached the case as stated in his judgment, by substituting his own discretion for that of the Public Service Commission.
After hearing learned counsel for the appellant in a forceful and exhaustive argument, we are not persuaded that the appeal is justified.
The appeal, therefore, fails; and is dismissed with costs which we fix at £15.-
Appeal dismissed with, costs.
+ Judgment appealed against published in (1969)
2 J.S.C.287.