Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution Melis Kyriakides v. The Republic of Cyprus, through the Commander of Police (1969) JSC 1121 Generato dall'IA

Constitutional challenge to police standing order refusing bachelor constables lodging exemption dismissed.

Numero d'incarto In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution Melis Kyriakides v. The Republic of Cyprus, through the Commander of Police (1969) JSC 1121
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The applicant, a bachelor police constable, challenged a refusal of his request for exemption from mandatory barracks lodging during off-duty hours under Police Force Standing Order III/10. He argued the order violated Article 28 of the Constitution by discriminating against bachelor constables compared to married men. The court held that reasonable distinctions based on differing responsibilities and life statuses do not contravene the principle of equality, and the commander's decision was not an abuse of power.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Article 28 of the Constitution; Police Force Standing Order III/10 para 1(1): The principle of equality and prohibition against discrimination are not contravened by reasonable distinctions based on obvious differences in responsibilities and status between bachelor and married constables.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
Article 28 Constitution bachelor constables police standing orders lodging exemption reasonable distinctions abuse of power equality principle clausola generale di polizia

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Article 28 of the Constitution
I can find nothing in the said paragraph 1(1) which contravenes the right of equality, as safeguarded under our Constitution, and particularly under Article 28 thereof; or which entails a discrimination against batchelor constables contrary to such Article.
Art. 28 thereof
I can find nothing in the said paragraph 1(1) which contravenes the right of equality, as safeguarded under our Constitution, and particularly under Article 28 thereof; or which entails a discrimination against batchelor constables contrary to such Article.

Giurisprudenza citata

Generato dall'IA
Fekkas v. The Electricity Authority of Cyprus 1968 4 J.S.C. 459
Relating to Certain Aspects of the Laws on the Use of Languages in Education in Belgium
459: as well as, the case “Relating to Certain Aspects of the Laws on the Use of Languages in Education in Belgium” decided by the European Court of Human Rights, of the Council of Europe, on the 23rd July, 1968).
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*1121] 1969 August 16

(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, J.)

REVISIONAL JURISDICTION

In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution

Melis Kyriakides,

Applicant,

and

The Republic of Cyprus, through the Commander of Police, Respondent.

(Case No.33/69)

Administrative Law - Police Constable - Bachelor Police Constable -

Refused exemption from provisions of para.1(1) of Police Force Standing Order III/10 - Relevant request for exemption duly examined - No excess or abuse of

powers.

Police Constable - See under Administrative Law”.

Constitutional Law - Article 28 of the Constitution - Police Force Standing Order III/10 para 1(1) - It does not contravene the right of equality safeguarded under article 28 of the Constitution nor does it entail a discrimination against bachelor constables contrary to such article - There is an obvious difference in responsibilities and status in life between a bachelor and a married man - Principle of equality and cognate prohibition against discrimination are not contravened by reasonable distinctions.

D. Georghiades, for the Applicant.

K. Talarides, Senior Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.

JUDGMENT

The following judgment was delivered by: -

TRIANTAFYLLIDES, J.: In this case the Applicant complains against a decision of the Commander of the Nicosia [*1122] Police Division - who comes under the Respondent Commander of Police - By means of which he was refused exemption from the provisions of paragraph 1(1) of Police Force Standing Order III/10 (see exhibit 3)

Paragraph 1(1) of Force Standing Order III/10 reads as follows: -

“Batchelor constables when off duty must be in barracks by 01.00 hrs

during the months of June, July, August and September, and 24.00 hrs during the other months of the year. Batchelor constables of good

behaviour and reputation, who have parents or close relatives living in the town or suburbs in whose house they may lodge are, however, exempted from this order provided that they apply for and are granted special permission to lodge out by their Commander. This is to be regarded as a privilege which may be withdrawn at any time.”

The Applicant, who is a batchelor constable, stationed in the Nicosia Police Division, applied to his Commander, on the 7th November, 1968 (see exhibit 2), requesting permission to lodge out, and not in barracks; he stated that he wished to reside at Engome, near Nicosia, with his mother, sister and brother, and he stressed that he had enrolled at the Salonica University in order to study Mathematics by correspondence, and that his having to be in barracks would make it difficult for him to study and would, also, entail, in the circumstances, inconvenience for his colleagues there.[*1123]

He received a reply dated the 12th November, 1968 (see exhibit 1) by which he was informed that his application had not been approved, though it had been carefully examined and all the grounds stated therein had been taken into account.

As a result, he filed this recourse on the 25th January, 1969.

At the hearing of this case counsel for Applicant has attacked the sub judice decision on two grounds only:- First, that paragraph 1(1) of Force Standing Order IIl/10 is unconstitutional as involving a discrimination against batchelor constables, when compared with married constables who though they receive the same emoluments and perform the same duties as batchelor constables are not required to sleep in barracks, and, secondly, that the request of the Applicant for exemption was not properly considered.

I can find nothing in the said paragraph 1(1) which contravenes the right of equality, as safeguarded under our Constitution, and particularly under Article 28 thereof; or which entails a discrimination against batchelor constables contrary to such Article.

The principle of equality, and the cognate prohibition against discrimination, are not contravened by reasonable distinctions (see, inter alia, Fekkas v. The Electricity Authority of Cyprus 1968 4 J.S.C. 459: as well as, the case “Relating to Certain Aspects of the Laws on the Use of Languages in Education in Belgium” decided by the European Court of Human Rights, of the Council of Europe, on the 23rd July, 1968). [*1124]

There is an obvious difference in responsibilities and status in life between a batchelor and a married man, and it was not at all unreasonable to limit the obligation to sleep in barracks so as to apply only to batchelor constables; and there is, moreover, in the relevant provision, sufficient latitude for remedying hardship in any individual case.

Coming, next, to the second contention of counsel for Applicant, I am quite satisfied, having looked through the official records which were produced, that the relevant request of the Applicant was duly examined, and that there has not been any excess or abuse of powers, on the part of the Divisional Police Commander, in refusing such request.

In a letter addressed by the Divisional Police Commander, Nicosia, to the Commander of the Police (see exhibit 4) it is clearly stated that the reason for which the request of the Applicant was refused was the fact that he was a member of a Police Reserve Force, which had to be ready all the time; it was added that at the particular barracks there were rooms in which the Applicant could study, if he so wished.

It is correct that this letter was written after the recourse had been filed and served on the Commander of Police; presumably, on receiving copy of the recourse, he decided, immediately, as the superior authority, to examine himself the matter and he sought information about it from the Nicosia Police Division; and he received, in reply, the said letter which is dated the 1st February, 1969. [*1125]

I have, however, no ground for thinking that the reason given in such letter was an afterthought and not the reason which actually led to the refusal of the request of the Applicant.

I find such reason quite reasonable; especially, as under the provision concerned, the Applicant would not have to be in barracks - when off duty - before midnight, at the earliest, and he could use all his other time off duty to study at home, if he so wished, without suffering or causing - as alleged - any inconvenience in the process of doing so; and one would, normally, hardly expect him to study after midnight.

In the light of all the foregoing this recourse fails and it is dismissed accordingly; but as I do think that it was made bona fide, for the purspose of bringing before the Court a grievance which the Applicant and his advocate considered justifiable, I would not penalize the Applicant with an order for costs against him.

Application dismissed; no order as to costs.